It’s a weird feeling when a team that’s been around since 1896 just... vanishes. For over 120 years, st francis bk basketball was the heartbeat of Brooklyn Heights. They were the "Boys from Brooklyn," the oldest collegiate hoops program in New York City. Then, on a random Monday in March 2023, the school dropped a bombshell that basically ended an era. They didn't just cut a team; they nuked the entire athletic department.
Honestly, it felt like a gut punch to the local sports scene. You had a program that survived two World Wars and the Great Depression, only to be taken down by a mix of post-pandemic debt and a "strategic realignment." If you walk past their old stomping grounds now, you won't hear the squeak of sneakers or the roar of the "Pope" (the Generoso Pope Athletic Complex). It’s all gone.
The Day the Ball Stopped Bouncing
Most people assume programs die because they’re losing. That wasn't the case here. The 2022-23 season wasn't even that bad—the Terriers finished 14-16 and were actually competitive in the Northeast Conference (NEC). They lost to Fairleigh Dickinson in the quarterfinals, which, in a bit of cosmic irony, was the same FDU team that went on to stun No. 1 Purdue in the NCAA Tournament days later.
While the players were still processing the loss, the Board of Trustees was looking at the books. The school was moving to a new, modern campus at 179 Livingston Street. The catch? The new spot didn't have a gym. No gym means no home court, and renting space in New York is a nightmare. Combine that with the "SFC Forward" plan, and the Terriers were suddenly out of a home and out of a job.
👉 See also: Ja Morant Height: Why the NBA Star Looks Bigger Than He Actually Is
Why the Cut Happened (The Non-Corporate Version)
The official statement mentioned "increased operating expenses" and "plateauing enrollment." Basically, the school decided that being a Division I powerhouse was a luxury they couldn't afford if they wanted to stay afloat as a tuition-driven college.
- The Relocation Factor: Moving from their historic Brooklyn Heights home to a high-rise office building meant losing their infrastructure.
- The COVID Hangover: Like many small private colleges, the pandemic drained their reserves.
- The NIL/Portal Era: Staying competitive in D1 now requires a massive financial commitment that SFC simply didn't have.
A Legacy of "Almost" and "The First"
If you’re a real hoops junkie, you know the tragedy of st francis bk basketball. They are famously one of the "Original Five" D1 programs that have never made the NCAA Tournament. It’s a stat that followed them like a shadow. They came this close so many times.
In 2015, the atmosphere in Brooklyn was electric. Under coach Glenn Braica, they won the NEC regular-season title. They hosted the championship game against Robert Morris. The Pope was packed. People were standing in the aisles. But they fell short, losing 66-63. That was the closest they ever got to the Big Dance.
✨ Don't miss: Hulk Hogan Lifting Andre the Giant: What Really Happened at WrestleMania III
The 1956 NIT Run
Back in the 50s, the NIT was actually a bigger deal than the NCAA Tournament in New York. The 1956 Terriers were absolute legends. They made it all the way to the semifinals at Madison Square Garden, finishing fourth in the country. That team, led by guys like Dan Lynch (who the gym was later named after), proved that a tiny school from Brooklyn could hang with anybody.
Where Are the Terriers Now?
When a program folds, the players don't just stop playing. The "Great Migration" of 2023 saw dozens of student-athletes hit the transfer portal.
- Zion Bethea: One of the last stars for SFC, he took his talents to Delaware State.
- Josiah Harris: Ended up at La Salle to keep his D1 dreams alive.
- The Coaches: Glenn Braica, who spent 13 seasons at the helm, was the heart of the program. Seeing him on the sidelines somewhere else just feels wrong to most Brooklynites.
Surprisingly, the Terrier name still lives on in the pro ranks. You’ve got alumni like Jalen Cannon and Max Egner playing overseas in leagues in Italy and Poland. Even without a home base, the "Brooklyn Tough" style of play is still being represented on courts across the globe.
🔗 Read more: Formula One Points Table Explained: Why the Math Matters More Than the Racing
Is There Any Hope for a Comeback?
Kinda, but don't hold your breath. The school mentioned that athletics could return if they hit a "stronger financial position," but in the current landscape of college sports, going from zero to Division I is almost impossible. Most likely, if they ever bring sports back, it’ll be at the D3 or club level.
It’s a cautionary tale. Small, private colleges are feeling the squeeze. Just look at St. Francis University in Pennsylvania (the "Red Flash")—they recently announced a move down to Division III starting in 2026 because the costs of D1 are just too high.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Alumni
If you’re missing the Terriers or just want to keep the spirit of Brooklyn basketball alive, here’s what you can actually do:
- Support the Alumni: Follow the "Terrier Trust" or alumni groups on social media. Many former players are still active in the NYC basketball community.
- Visit the New Campus: Check out 179 Livingston Street. It’s a different vibe, but the school’s Franciscan mission is still there, even if the jump ball isn't.
- Watch the NEC: The Northeast Conference is still one of the grittiest mid-major conferences. Teams like LIU (the old rival) still carry the Brooklyn torch.
- Archival Digging: The SFC library holds a ton of history on the basketball program. If you’re a history buff, it’s worth a look to see the 1950s rosters and old game programs.
The story of st francis bk basketball is a reminder that tradition isn't always enough to beat a balance sheet. But for those who spent cold February nights in the "Pope" gym, the Terriers will always be New York's original team.