You’ve probably seen the scores. 45-0. 52-7. They play a schedule that looks more like a college conference than a high school slate, traveling from Baltimore to Texas, Florida, and California just to find someone willing to strap up against them. St. Frances Academy football isn't just a program; it’s a lightning rod. Depending on who you ask in the Maryland high school football scene, they are either the gold standard of modern prep sports or the "super team" that ruined local parity.
Honestly, the reality is a lot more complicated than a Twitter highlight reel.
It’s about a school founded by Mother Mary Lange in 1828—the oldest continuously operating Black Catholic school in the U.S.—that was on the brink of closing its doors not too long ago. Then came the football. And with the football came the controversy, the national rankings, and a pipeline to the NFL that defies the school's modest physical footprint in East Baltimore.
The Local Boycott That Changed Everything
Back in 2018, something weird happened. The Maryland Interscholastic Athletic Association (MIAA) A Conference basically fell apart. Why? Because the other powerhouse private schools—places like Calvert Hall, Loyola Blakefield, and Mount St. Joseph—decided they’d had enough. They cited "player safety" concerns, arguing that St. Frances Academy was too big, too fast, and too physically dominant for their kids to compete with safely.
Critics called it a duck. Supporters of those other schools called it common sense.
The result was a de facto boycott. St. Frances was essentially kicked out of its own neighborhood. They were a team without a league. Most programs would have folded or dialed back the recruiting. Instead, the Panthers went global. Since they couldn't play the school down the street, they started playing IMG Academy, Mater Dei, and St. John Bosco. They became a national independent traveling circus, and they started winning.
If you look at the 2024 and 2025 rosters, the depth is staggering. We aren't just talking about one or two D1 prospects. We’re talking about 20-plus kids with offers from Georgia, Alabama, and Ohio State on a single squad. It’s an arms race, and Biff Poggi—the former hedge fund manager turned coach (and later Charlotte 49ers head coach)—was the one who supplied the initial fuel.
✨ Don't miss: Liechtenstein National Football Team: Why Their Struggles are Different Than You Think
How the Panther Pipeline Actually Works
People think it’s just about money. It’s not. It’s about the "Panther Walk." It’s about a culture that treats 16-year-olds like professional athletes in waiting.
Messay Hailemariam, who has been a central figure in the program’s rise, understands the optics. He knows people see them as a "football factory." But if you spend ten minutes on Eager Street, you see a school that provides a sanctuary in a neighborhood that has been historically underserved. For many of these athletes, football is the literal ticket out.
Look at the names that have come through here:
- Blake Corum: The Michigan legend and national champion.
- Chris Braswell: A terror off the edge for Alabama.
- Demon Clowney: Related to Jadeveon, a physical specimen in his own right.
The training regimen at St. Frances is famously brutal. They don't have the sprawling 100-acre campuses of the California private schools. They work with what they have. They utilize local parks, rented facilities, and a weight room that feels more like a dungeon than a spa. That chip on the shoulder? It’s real. They play like a team that feels unwanted by their own city, which makes them dangerous.
Why the 2024 Season Was a Reality Check
If you followed the team recently, you know it hasn't been all undefeated seasons and trophies. The 2023-2024 stretch was a gauntlet. They took some lumps. They lost games to teams like East St. Louis and Kahuku. For the first time in a long time, the "invincibility" tag took a hit.
This is actually good for the sport. It showed that even a "national" roster can struggle with the logistics of traveling 2,000 miles every other weekend. Jet lag is real, even for five-star recruits. But the bounce back in late 2024 and heading into 2025 proved the foundation was solid. They didn't panic. They just adjusted the strength and conditioning and tightened up the defensive schemes.
🔗 Read more: Cómo entender la tabla de Copa Oro y por qué los puntos no siempre cuentan la historia completa
One thing most people get wrong is the "recruiting" narrative. Yes, they get kids from everywhere. But they also lose them. In the era of the Transfer Portal and NIL, even high schoolers are looking for the next best thing. St. Frances has had to fight to keep their own talent from being poached by schools in Florida or Georgia.
The Under-the-Radar Stats
Let's talk numbers, but not the ones you see on MaxPreps.
- Over 90% of their senior players over the last five years have signed to play college ball.
- The average travel distance for a "home" game is often over 100 miles because local teams still won't play them.
- The tuition assistance for non-athletes at the school has actually increased alongside the football program's prominence.
The Biff Poggi Legacy and the New Guard
You can't talk about St. Frances Academy football without mentioning Biff Poggi. The guy is a character. Wears a sleeveless shirt on the sidelines in November. Speaks his mind. He put his own money into the program when it was struggling. He saw it as a social mission.
When he left for the college ranks, people expected the program to crater. It didn't. That’s because the infrastructure—the "St. Frances Way"—was already baked in. The current coaching staff has doubled down on the "us against the world" mentality. They know that every time they step on a field in Texas or Florida, the home crowd wants to see the "Baltimore bullies" lose.
The Ethics of the Super Team
Is it fair? That’s the question that haunts every Reddit thread and sports bar conversation about this team.
If you are a 165-pound linebacker at a traditional Baltimore Catholic school, playing St. Frances feels like playing a semi-pro team. It’s scary. It’s potentially dangerous. That’s a valid point.
💡 You might also like: Ohio State Football All White Uniforms: Why the Icy Look Always Sparks a Debate
On the flip side, if you are a generational talent living in a zip code where the graduation rate is sub-50%, and St. Frances offers you a rigorous curriculum and a path to a $10 million NFL contract, are you supposed to say no just to keep the local league "fair"? Probably not.
The compromise has been the independent schedule. By playing a national schedule, St. Frances has found its level. They are playing their peers now. Schools like Bishop Gorman and Chaminade-Madonna. That’s where they belong.
What to Watch for Next
The program is currently eyeing a move toward even more specialized athletic facilities. There’s always a rumor about a new stadium or a dedicated practice bubble. But honestly, the "dirt and grit" of their current setup is part of the brand. It keeps the players grounded.
If you’re scouting them this year, keep an eye on the defensive line. It’s always the D-line. They recruit size that you simply don't see in high school football outside of maybe South Georgia or the North Jersey private loop. They play a gap-discipline style that forces quarterbacks into bad decisions, and their secondary is usually fast enough to erase any mistakes.
Actionable Steps for Players and Fans
If you're a parent or a player looking at the St. Frances model, or just a fan trying to keep up, here is how to navigate the noise.
- Audit the Schedule: Don't just look at their record. Look at who they played. A 7-3 record at St. Frances is often more impressive than a 12-0 record at a standard public school.
- Verify the Academic Path: If you're a recruit, look at the NCAA Clearinghouse track record. St. Frances has become very efficient at ensuring their players are academically eligible, which is a hurdle many "football factories" fail.
- Attend the "Neutral" Games: If you want to see what the hype is about, catch them at an event like the Maryland State Youth Football Alliance showcases or national kickoff classics. The atmosphere is different. It’s electric.
- Follow the Undercard: The most interesting stories at St. Frances aren't the five-stars; they are the three-star "project" players who transform their bodies over four years and end up with full rides to mid-major schools. That’s where the real coaching happens.
The "Baltimore vs. Everyone" hoodie isn't just a fashion choice for this team. It's a business plan. Whether you love them or hate them, St. Frances Academy has forced high school football to grow up. You can't put the genie back in the bottle. They are the new reality of the sport.
Watch the film. Check the rosters. The Panthers aren't going anywhere.
Next Steps for Deep Diving:
To truly understand the impact of this program, research the MIAA A Conference split of 2018. It provides the necessary context for why the program operates as an independent today. Additionally, tracking the Class of 2026 player rankings will show you exactly which St. Frances prospects are currently dictating the recruiting cycles for the Big Ten and SEC.