You've probably heard that if you want a decent lower body, you have to do squats and lunges. It’s basically the law of the gym. But honestly? Most people are doing them in a way that’s either totally wasting their time or, worse, slowly grinding their patellar tendons into sawdust. I’ve seen it a thousand times. Someone loads up a barbell, drops down halfway, their knees cave in like a folding chair, and they wonder why they need ibuprofen by Tuesday.
It doesn’t have to be like that.
These two movements are the bread and butter of human locomotion. Squats are how we sit and stand; lunges are how we move through space. If you look at the research, like the stuff coming out of the Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research, these isn't just about getting "toned" or whatever marketing word is popular this week. It’s about force production and joint integrity. But there’s a massive gap between "doing the move" and actually mastering the mechanics.
The Squat Myth That Won't Die
Let’s talk about the "knees over toes" thing. For decades, well-meaning trainers told everyone that letting your knees pass your toes during exercise squats and lunges was a one-way ticket to surgery. That’s just wrong.
🔗 Read more: Vent Settings Cheat Sheet: What Most People Get Wrong in the ICU
In 2003, researchers at the University of Memphis looked into this. They found that when you restrict the forward movement of the knee, you actually end up leaning forward more at the hips. This increases the internal torque on your lower back by over 1,000%. Your knees might feel "safe," but your L5-S1 disc is screaming for help.
The truth is, your knees should move forward. It’s natural. Look at a toddler picking up a toy. Their butt is an inch off the floor, and their knees are way past their toes. They have perfect mobility because they haven't spent twenty years sitting in an office chair that tightens their hip flexors into guitar strings.
Depth is non-negotiable
If you aren't going to at least parallel, you're leaving about 50% of the benefits on the table. When you stop high, you put the maximum amount of shear force on the knee joint. By descending lower—into what we call "the hole"—you actually engage the glutes and hamstrings more effectively to help stabilize the joint.
It’s counterintuitive. People think deep squats are dangerous. Actually, partial squats are often the culprit for "gritty" feeling knees. If you can’t get low, it’s usually not a knee problem; it’s an ankle mobility problem. If your calves are tight, your heels lift, your weight shifts to your toes, and everything falls apart. Try putting your heels on a couple of small weight plates. Suddenly, you’re hitting depth like an Olympian. That’s a diagnostic tool, not just a "hack."
Why Lunges are Actually Harder (and Better)
Lunges are the meaner, more sophisticated cousin of the squat. While the squat is a bilateral movement—both feet planted—the lunge is unilateral. This introduces a nasty little variable called lateral instability.
When you're doing exercise squats and lunges, the lunge is what exposes your weaknesses. Your hips want to wiggle. Your core has to fight to keep you upright. If you have a weak glute medius (the muscle on the side of your hip), your knee will dive inward. We call this valgus collapse. It’s the primary way people tear their ACLs.
🔗 Read more: Looking at an 8 week fetus photo: What you’re actually seeing and why it’s so confusing
The "Train Track" Rule
Most people try to lunge like they’re walking on a tightrope. They put one foot directly in front of the other. Of course you’re wobbling! You have no base of support.
Instead, think about train tracks. Your feet should stay hip-width apart even as one steps forward or back. This gives your pelvis room to stay level. It sounds simple. It’s surprisingly hard to remember when you’re ten reps deep and your quads are on fire.
The Science of Muscle Recruitment
We need to talk about what’s actually happening under the skin. A squat is a "knee-dominant" or "quad-dominant" lift depending on your bar path, but it’s really a full-body expression of tension. When you brace your core—using the Valsalva maneuver where you breathe into your belly and hold it—you create intra-abdominal pressure. This turns your torso into a rigid pillar.
Without that pressure, you’re a wet noodle.
Lunges, specifically the reverse lunge, tend to be a bit more "posterior chain" focused. They hit the hamstrings and glutes harder because of the angle of the shin. If you want to grow your glutes, stop doing those weird kickback machines and start doing heavy lunges. Dr. Bret Contreras, often called "The Glute Guy," has shown through EMG studies that unilateral leg work often produces higher levels of activation in the gluteus maximus than traditional bilateral squats.
Variation Matters
Don't just do the same move forever.
- Goblet Squats: Hold a kettlebell at your chest. It forces you to stay upright. Great for beginners or people with back pain.
- Bulgarian Split Squats: This is the one everyone hates. You put one foot back on a bench and squat on the other leg. It’s brutal. It’s also the fastest way to fix muscle imbalances between your left and right sides.
- Lateral Lunges: We spend our whole lives moving forward and backward. We rarely move side-to-side. Lateral lunges strengthen the adductors (inner thighs) and help prevent groin strains.
Common Mistakes You’re Probably Making
Stop looking at the ceiling. Seriously.
People think looking up helps them stay upright. It doesn't. It just puts your cervical spine into hyper-extension. Pick a spot on the floor about six feet in front of you. Keep your neck "packed"—think about making a double chin. This keeps your entire spine in a neutral line from your head to your tailbone.
Also, check your feet. Your feet are your foundation. If your arches are collapsing, your knees are going to follow. Imagine your foot is a tripod: your big toe, your pinky toe, and your heel. "Screw" your feet into the ground. This creates external rotation torque in the hip, which keeps your knees tracking perfectly over your mid-foot.
Making it Work for Your Body
Not everyone is built for a back squat. If you have a really long femur (thigh bone) and a short torso, you’re going to have to lean way forward to keep your center of gravity. That’s just physics. You might find that front squats or lunges feel way more natural.
That’s fine.
There is no "perfect" form that applies to every single human being. There is only "optimal" form for your anatomy. The goal of exercise squats and lunges is to challenge the tissue without destroying the joint. If a move hurts—not "muscle burn" hurt, but "stabbing joint" hurt—stop doing it. Change the stance width. Turn your toes out a bit. Adapt the movement to your bones, don't try to force your bones to match a YouTube video.
Actionable Next Steps
To actually see progress without ending up in physical therapy, follow these steps over the next two weeks:
- Audit your ankle mobility. Stand facing a wall with your toes 5 inches away. Try to touch the wall with your knee without your heel lifting. If you can't, your "squat problem" is actually a tight calf problem. Spend 2 minutes a day stretching your soleus.
- Switch to Reverse Lunges. If forward lunges hurt your knees, try stepping backward instead. It keeps the front shin more vertical and takes the "braking" force off the patella.
- Master the "Hinge" first. Before you squat, you must hinge. Practice pushing your hips back like you're trying to close a car door with your butt while your hands are full of groceries. That’s the start of a good squat.
- Tempo over Weight. Stop bouncing at the bottom. Take 3 seconds to go down, hold for 1 second at the bottom, and explode up. You’ll find that "light" weights suddenly feel incredibly heavy, and your joints will feel much smoother.
- Record yourself from the side. You think you’re going deep. You’re probably not. Check the video. Look for "butt wink"—where your lower back rounds at the bottom. If that happens, stop just an inch above that point until your hip mobility improves.
Mastering exercise squats and lunges isn't about being a gym rat; it's about maintaining the ability to move through the world with power and without pain. Fix the mechanics, respect the anatomy, and the results will take care of themselves.