It’s an oddly specific kind of heartbreak. You’ve spent hours meticulously tagging your rare 1994 Japanese import B-sides, moving them into a folder, and syncing them to your phone so you can finally listen to them on the train. You open the app, tap the track, and instead of that sweet, nostalgic audio, you get a grayed-out title and a digital shrug: Spotify can't play this right now local files.
It’s annoying. Actually, it's infuriating because it feels like the software is gaslighting you. The file is right there. You can see it on your hard drive. You might even be able to play it in VLC or QuickTime. But Spotify? Spotify acts like it’s never seen that .mp3 in its life.
This isn't just a "restart your app" kind of problem. While a reboot fixes the occasional glitch, the "can't play this" error usually signals a deeper disconnect between how Spotify indexes your storage and how it handles DRM, file formats, and network handshakes. Honestly, the way Spotify handles local files has always felt like a secondary feature they built in 2011 and then sort of forgot to polish.
The Format Trap and the Bitrate Wall
Most people assume that if a file ends in .mp3, it’s fair game. That’s not always the case. Spotify is surprisingly picky about the "DNA" of the files you try to force into its ecosystem. If you’re trying to play an Apple Lossless (ALAC) file or a high-bitrate FLAC that hasn't been properly indexed, the player will often just give up.
✨ Don't miss: No I'm Not Human All Visitors: The Truth About Your Website Traffic
You have to look at the codecs. Spotify officially supports .mp3, .m4p (unless it contains video), and .mp4. If you have .wav files from an old recording session, they might show up in the list, but the "can't play this" error will trigger the moment you hit play because the app’s internal decoder isn't built to stream raw uncompressed audio through its standard mobile interface.
There’s also the issue of "Protected" files. If you’re trying to move old iTunes purchases from circa 2007 that still have FairPlay DRM attached to them, Spotify will reject them faster than a bad audition. It can see the metadata—the artist name, the album art—but it can't "unlock" the audio stream. To Spotify, that file is a locked door it doesn't have the key to.
Why Your Phone and Desktop Aren't Talking
The most common reason for the Spotify can't play this right now local files error happens during the sync process between your computer and your mobile device. Spotify doesn't actually upload your local files to a cloud server like Google Drive or the old school iTunes Match. Instead, it uses a peer-to-peer "handshake" over your local Wi-Fi.
This is where things get messy.
For a successful sync, both your PC/Mac and your phone must be on the exact same sub-network. If your computer is on the 5GHz band of your router and your phone is on the 2.4GHz band, they might as well be on different planets. Some routers have a feature called "AP Isolation" or "Guest Mode" that prevents devices from talking to each other even if they are on the same Wi-Fi. If that's turned on, your phone will see the placeholder for the song but won't be able to download the actual data.
Then there's the firewall. Windows Defender or macOS Sequoia’s security settings often flag Spotify’s local network activity as suspicious. You’ve got to manually ensure that Spotify has permission to communicate on "Private" networks in your system settings. If the desktop app can’t "broadcast" the file, the mobile app will just sit there with a grayed-out track list.
👉 See also: Why Very Large Air Tanker Projects Are Much Harder Than They Look
The Ghost of Metadata Past
Sometimes the error isn't about the file at all. It's about the cache.
Spotify keeps a "map" of where your local files are located. If you move that "My Music" folder from your Desktop to an external drive, or even just rename the folder, Spotify’s map becomes useless. It looks for C:/Users/You/Desktop/Music/Song.mp3, doesn't find it, and throws the error.
But here is the weird part: sometimes it keeps the old metadata in the cache even after you’ve updated the file path. You’ll see the song, you’ll click it, and the app will panic because it’s trying to pull data from a path that no longer exists.
Clearing the cache is usually the nuclear option, but it’s often the only way to force the app to re-scan your library from scratch. You go into Settings, find the Storage section, and hit "Clear Cache." Just be prepared—this will delete any songs you’ve downloaded for offline listening, so you'll have to re-download your legitimate "Streaming" playlists too. It's a pain.
The Mobile Sync "Hidden" Step
I’ve seen dozens of people get stuck because they missed a single toggle in the mobile app. You can enable "Local Files" on your desktop all day long, but if the "Show local audio files" toggle isn't flipped on your iPhone or Android, the sync will never finalize.
Even when it is on, you have to "Like" the local files or add them to a specific playlist. You then have to set that playlist to "Downloaded" on your mobile device. Only then will the app attempt to pull the files from your computer. If you see a spinning arrow that never finishes, or a "Waiting to download" message, your local file error is likely a network timeout.
One trick that sounds like tech-support voodoo but actually works: turn off your cellular data entirely while trying to sync. Sometimes the phone gets confused and tries to "find" the local file over the 5G network instead of the local Wi-Fi. Force it to stay on the Wi-Fi, and the transfer usually kicks in.
Software Versions and the "Legacy" Problem
Software updates often break local file support because, frankly, it's not a priority for Spotify's developers. They want you streaming from their servers—that’s how they track data and pay (or don't pay) artists. Local files are a legacy bridge for power users.
If you’re running an "Alpha" or "Beta" version of the Spotify app via TestFlight or the Google Play Beta program, local file support is frequently the first thing to glitch out. If you’re seeing Spotify can't play this right now local files consistently after an update, you might need to roll back to a stable release or wait for a hotfix.
📖 Related: Is SpaceX Launch Today? Everything You Need To Know About NROL-105 and Upcoming Missions
Also, check your storage. If your phone has less than 1GB of free space, Spotify will often refuse to "buffer" a local file. It needs a little bit of breathing room to unpack the audio data before it hits your speakers.
Technical Checklist for a Permanent Fix
If you're tired of staring at gray text, follow this specific sequence. Don't skip steps, because the order matters for the handshake to work.
- Audit the File Path: Open Spotify on your desktop. Go to Settings > Local Files. Toggle "Show Local Files" off and then back on. Ensure the folder listed is exactly where your music lives. If you use a cloud drive like Dropbox or OneDrive for your music, make sure the files are set to "Available Offline" on your computer first.
- Match the Versions: Ensure your desktop app and mobile app are both updated to the latest version. Mismatched versions often have different encryption protocols for the local sync.
- The Firewall Pass: On Windows, go to "Allow an app through Windows Firewall" and make sure both "Private" and "Public" are checked for Spotify. On Mac, check your "Files and Folders" permissions in System Settings to ensure Spotify has "Full Disk Access" or at least access to your Music folder.
- The "Same Network" Test: Ping your phone from your computer to make sure they can actually see each other. If you can’t "see" the device on your network, Spotify won't either.
- The Re-Sync: Delete the "Local Files" playlist from your mobile library. Close the app. Re-open it. Create a new playlist on your desktop, drop 5 local songs into it, and set it to "Download" on your phone. If those 5 work, the issue was a corrupted index in your previous playlist.
A Word on Hardware Limitations
Sometimes, the hardware is the bottleneck. If you're using a very old MicroSD card in an Android phone, the read speeds might be too slow for Spotify to register the file as "playable." The app times out waiting for the card to wake up and send the data. If you're on Android, try moving a few files to the internal storage instead of the SD card to see if the error disappears.
Also, be wary of "Cleaning" apps. Programs like CCleaner or built-in "Phone Boosters" often delete Spotify’s temporary index files to save space. This effectively "unlinks" your local files, leading back to that same old error message.
Actionable Next Steps
To get your library back in order, start by narrowing down the culprit.
First, try to play the local file on your desktop app specifically. If it doesn't play there, the file is corrupted, the format is unsupported (like a 24-bit FLAC), or the path is broken. If it plays on the desktop but not the phone, the issue is 100% your local network or sync settings.
Second, verify your file extensions. If you have files labeled as .wav, use a free tool like Handbrake or an online converter to turn one into a 320kbps .mp3. Drop that new file into your local folder. If the .mp3 plays and the .wav doesn't, you've found your format limitation.
Third, check for "Duplicate" tracks. If you have a local version of a song that is also available on Spotify’s streaming servers, the app sometimes gets "confused" about which license to use. Try renaming your local file slightly (e.g., "Song Name (Local)") to see if that forces the app to treat it as a unique entity.
Finally, if you’re using a VPN on either your computer or your phone, turn it off. A VPN creates a virtual tunnel that completely hides your device from the local network, making the sync process impossible. Once the files are successfully downloaded to your phone's internal storage, you can turn the VPN back on and play them offline without an issue.