You’ve definitely heard her music. Even if the name doesn’t immediately ring a bell, the melodies are practically baked into the DNA of the late sixties and early seventies. It’s one of the weirdest paradoxes in pop history: Laura Nyro was the architect of a dozen massive hits, yet she remained a ghost in the machine of her own fame.
Most people know the "supper-club soul" versions of her work. They know the 5th Dimension’s shimmering take on "Wedding Bell Blues" or Three Dog Night’s bombastic "Eli’s Comin’." But honestly? Those polished covers are just the surface. If you really want to understand the raw, jagged, and beautiful reality of songs by Laura Nyro, you have to go back to the source.
The Teenager Who Outwrote the Giants
It’s almost annoying how talented she was at seventeen. While most kids were worrying about prom, Nyro was writing "And When I Die." It’s a song about mortality that feels like it was written by someone who had lived three lifetimes. She sold it to Peter, Paul and Mary for $5,000—a fortune in 1966—and it eventually became a juggernaut for Blood, Sweat & Tears.
Think about that for a second.
A teenager from the Bronx, the daughter of a jazz trumpeter, was crafting philosophy-heavy soul-folk that rivaled Dylan and Mitchell. She didn't just write hooks; she wrote "mini-operas." Her songs didn't follow the rules. They changed tempos mid-verse. They dropped beats. They went from a whisper to a gospel shout-up in three seconds flat.
Nyro was basically the poet laureate of the New York subway. She grew up singing doo-wop on street corners, but she was also obsessed with Debussy and Ravel. That mix is why her music sounds so strange and familiar at the same time. It’s got the grit of the street and the sophistication of a conservatory.
✨ Don't miss: Why ASAP Rocky F kin Problems Still Runs the Club Over a Decade Later
Why the Covers Missed the Point
Don’t get me wrong, Barbra Streisand’s "Stoney End" is a vocal masterclass. But when Streisand sings it, it’s a pop song. When Laura Nyro sings it, it’s a spiritual crisis.
There’s a specific "stoned soul" energy in Nyro’s own recordings that the big bands of the era couldn't quite replicate. They smoothed out the edges to make the music "palatable" for AM radio. They took the "blue" out of her passion. Critics at the time sometimes dismissed her as a "showbiz" writer because her songs were so successful in the hands of others, but that was a total misreading of who she was.
She was a radical.
The "Holy Trinity" of Albums
If you’re looking to get into the heart of her catalog, you start with three specific records. These aren't just albums; they’re emotional landscapes.
- Eli and the Thirteenth Confession (1968): This is the one. It’s a coming-of-age story told through jazz, soul, and avant-garde pop. It’s got "Stoned Soul Picnic" and "Sweet Blindness," but it also has "The Confession," which was shockingly frank about female sexuality for 1968.
- New York Tendaberry (1969): This is her masterpiece, but it’s a dark one. It’s mostly just Laura and her piano. It’s intimate, haunting, and a little bit scary. If Eli is a party, Tendaberry is the long walk home through a cold city.
- Christmas and the Beads of Sweat (1970): She went to Muscle Shoals for this one. It’s funkier and more political. You’ve got "Christmas in My Soul," where she’s calling out the "sins of politics" and name-checking the Chicago Seven.
She wasn't interested in being a star.
🔗 Read more: Ashley My 600 Pound Life Now: What Really Happened to the Show’s Most Memorable Ashleys
In fact, she famously bombed at the 1967 Monterey Pop Festival. She showed up in a black gown with backup singers while everyone else was wearing tie-dye and playing fuzzy guitars. The crowd didn't get it. She felt so rejected that she almost quit. Thankfully, David Geffen—who was just starting out—became her champion and got her the deal at Columbia Records that gave us these classics.
The Secret Influence on Your Favorite Artists
The list of people who worship songs by Laura Nyro is basically a Who’s Who of music royalty.
Elton John has explicitly said that he idolized her. He told anyone who would listen that his early style—the piano-driven soul of "Burn Down the Mission"—was a direct attempt to capture the Nyro magic. Todd Rundgren changed his entire songwriting approach after hearing her. Joni Mitchell, Rickie Lee Jones, Kate Bush, Tori Amos... the lineage is endless.
She was the first "confessional" singer-songwriter who didn't come from the folk scene. She didn't play a guitar and sing about the mountains; she played a piano and sang about the pavement.
The Mid-Career Pivot
By 1971, Nyro was over the industry. She was twenty-four and had already written enough hits for a lifetime. She released Gonna Take a Miracle, an album of soul covers with the group Labelle, and then she basically walked away.
💡 You might also like: Album Hopes and Fears: Why We Obsess Over Music That Doesn't Exist Yet
She moved to the country, had a kid, and focused on her life. When she did come back with albums like Smile (1976) and Mother’s Spiritual (1984), the fire was still there, but it was warmer. She started writing about motherhood, the environment, and feminism. She wasn't chasing the charts anymore—not that she ever really was.
Actionable Insights for the Modern Listener
If you want to actually "get" Laura Nyro, don't just put her on as background music while you're cleaning the house. It won't work. Her music demands that you sit down and pay attention to the shifts.
- Start with the "Eli" album but listen to the mono versions if you can find them. They have a punch that the stereo mixes sometimes lose.
- Watch the (rare) live footage. Seeing her at the piano explains everything. Her hands move like she's wrestling with the instrument.
- Compare the covers to the originals. Listen to the 5th Dimension's "Save the Country" and then listen to her version on New York Tendaberry. It’s a completely different emotional experience.
- Check out "Emmie." It’s often cited as one of the first pop songs to openly celebrate a woman-to-woman connection, years before that was "acceptable" in the mainstream.
Laura Nyro died of ovarian cancer in 1997 at the age of 49. It was the same age her mother was when she passed from the same disease. It’s a tragic ending for a woman who gave so much life to the American songbook. But her influence is actually growing. In a world of "perfect" digital pop, her messy, soulful, tempo-shifting genius feels more necessary than ever.
To truly appreciate her, you have to embrace the dissonance. You have to be okay with a song that doesn't stay in its lane. That was the whole point of Laura Nyro. She wasn't writing for the radio; she was writing for the soul, and the soul doesn't always have a catchy chorus.
Practical Next Steps:
- Create a "Laura Nyro: Originals vs. Covers" playlist. Include the 5th Dimension, Blood, Sweat & Tears, and Barbra Streisand tracks alongside Laura's own versions to hear the structural brilliance of her writing.
- Read the lyrics as poetry. Songs like "Gibsom Street" or "Map to the Treasure" hold up as literature even without the music.
- Explore her later work. Don't stop at 1971. Walk the Dog and Light the Light (1993) shows a mature artist still at the top of her game, proving she wasn't just a "sixties phenomenon."