You're staring at the grid. The ink is drying, or maybe the digital cursor is just blinking rhythmically, mocking you. You’ve got a five-letter gap or maybe a seven-letter one, and the prompt is simple: crossword clue more dreadful. It sounds easy. It feels like the answer should just pop out, but your brain is stuck in a loop of synonyms that don't fit the boxes.
Crosswords are weird. They aren't just about vocabulary; they are about the specific brand of logic used by the person who constructed the puzzle. When you see "more dreadful," you might think of horror movies or a bad date. But in the world of the New York Times, LA Times, or The Wall Street Journal, the answer usually leans toward a very specific linguistic transformation.
Why Comparative Clues Are So Annoying
Most of the time, the answer is DIRE. Or rather, DIRER.
Think about it. We don't actually use the word "direr" in real life. If a situation gets worse, we say it’s "more dire." We almost never tack on that extra 'r' at the end unless we’re trying to sound like a Victorian novelist or someone who spends way too much time filling out grids on a Sunday morning. But crossword constructors love it. It’s a short word with common letters—D, I, R, E—which makes it the ultimate "glue" word to connect more interesting long-form answers.
📖 Related: Stitch Braids in a Ponytail: Why Yours Probably Aren’t Lasting
It’s about the suffix. Crossword editors like Will Shortz or Mike Shenk often use the "more [adjective]" format to signal that the answer must end in "-er." If the clue is "more dreadful," they are looking for a comparative adjective.
The Usual Suspects for More Dreadful
Honestly, depending on the grid size, you’re usually looking at one of a few common culprits. If you have five letters, DIRER is the heavy favorite. It shows up constantly. It’s the bread and butter of Monday and Tuesday puzzles because it’s easy to cross with common vowels.
But what if that doesn't fit?
Sometimes the constructor is feeling a bit more descriptive. You might be looking at GRIMMER. It’s a bit more "human" in its usage. If a landscape or a prognosis is more dreadful, it’s grimmer. This one is trickier because of the double 'm', which can be a nightmare if you don't have the crossing vertical clues settled.
Then there is AWFULER. Okay, let’s be real: this is a terrible word. Most editors try to avoid it because it feels clunky and "un-English," but you’ll still see it in some indie puzzles or "punny" grids. It’s technically a word, but using it feels like eating a dry cracker. It’s more common in puzzles that lean into colloquialisms rather than high-brow vocabulary.
🔗 Read more: Why Just Eat It: A Food Waste Story is Still Making Us Cringe at Our Own Fridges
Breaking Down the Wordplay
Don't just look at the literal meaning. Sometimes "more dreadful" isn't a comparative adjective at all. You have to watch out for the "rebus" or the "hidden indicator."
Is there a question mark at the end of the clue? If the clue is More dreadful?, the question mark is a giant red flag. It means there’s a pun involved. In this case, "More" might be a proper noun. Is it referring to Sir Thomas More? Or maybe the actor Roger Moore? If it’s Roger Moore, the answer could be related to his roles, like a specific Bond film reference that was particularly "dreadful" or scary.
It's also worth checking if "dreadful" is an anagram indicator. In cryptic crosswords—the ones that look like they were written by a codebreaker from Bletchley Park—the word "dreadful" usually tells you to scramble the letters of a nearby word. If the clue says "More dreadful (4)," you might be looking for an anagram of the word "more," which could lead you to ROME.
Context is everything.
The Semantic Shift of Fear
We should talk about the word DREAR. Or DREARIER.
📖 Related: Pic of the Biggest House in the World: What Most People Get Wrong
"Drear" is one of those words that exists almost exclusively in poetry and crosswords. Nobody walks into a coffee shop and says, "Man, the weather is quite drear today." But in a 15x15 grid? It’s gold. If "more dreadful" refers to a sense of gloom or boredom rather than active terror, DREARIER is your best bet. It’s an eight-letter beast that can anchor a whole corner of the puzzle.
You also have to consider the source. A New York Times puzzle on a Saturday is going to be significantly more obtuse than a USA Today puzzle on a Monday. On a Saturday, "more dreadful" might lead you to something like EGREGE, though that’s rare. More likely, it could be ILLER, though that usually has a "slangy" indicator.
Real Examples from the Archives
If you look back at historical puzzle databases like XWord Info, "More dreadful" has appeared dozens of times.
- DIRER: This is the champion. It has appeared hundreds of times across various publications.
- GRIMMER: Often used when the clue is "More forbidding" or "More dreadful."
- WORSENED: Occasionally, the clue is used to describe a state of being rather than a direct adjective, though "more dreadful" usually points to a comparative.
- MACABRER: This is a rare one, but it’s a favorite for "spooky" themed puzzles around October. It’s hard to spell, and it’s even harder to fit into a grid, but it satisfies that "dreadful" requirement perfectly.
How to Get Unstuck Right Now
If you're currently staring at a blank spot in your puzzle and "DIRER" isn't working, stop trying to find a synonym. Look at the letters you do have.
If you have an 'S' at the end, the clue might be a plural noun acting as an adjective, though that's rare for "more dreadful." More likely, if you have an 'R' at the end, you are definitely in comparative territory.
Try this: say the word out loud. Sometimes hearing the clue helps bypass the visual block in your brain. "More... dreadful." Does it feel like "scarier"? SCARIER is a very common answer for this clue, especially in puzzles aimed at a general audience. It’s simple, it’s seven letters, and it’s a word people actually use.
Insights for the Grid
- Check the Tense: "More" almost always means the answer ends in -ER.
- Count the Boxes: Five boxes is usually DIRER. Seven is often GRIMMER or SCARIER. Eight is likely DREARIER.
- Look for Slang: If the puzzle is "modern" or "edgy," the answer could be something like NOTIT. (As in, "that's not it," though that's a stretch for this specific clue).
- The "ER" Rule: If you are truly stuck, just pencil in "ER" at the end of the space. It’s a gamble, but in about 80% of "more [adjective]" clues, those last two letters are a lock. It narrows your search significantly and might help you solve the vertical clues that cross it.
Crosswords are a battle of wits between you and the constructor. When they use a clue like "more dreadful," they are counting on you to think about the meaning of the word rather than the structure of the word. Once you realize they are just looking for a comparative adjective, the puzzle usually falls apart in your favor.
Next time you hit this wall, check the crossing vowels first. If there's an 'I' in the second position and an 'E' in the fourth, you've got DIRER in the bag. Move on to the next one and don't let the grid win.