Honestly, if you walked into the 2024 HBO series The Penguin expecting a straightforward mob drama about Oz Cobb, you probably walked away talking about someone else entirely. Her name is Sofia Gigante. Or Sofia Falcone, depending on which episode you’re stuck on.
She isn't just a side character. She’s the emotional, terrifying, and deeply broken heart of the show. While Colin Farrell’s Oz is busy waddling through the slush of Gotham’s underground, Cristin Milioti’s Sofia is burning the whole thing down. Literally.
Sofia Gigante and the Rebirth of a Gotham Icon
Most people see the name "Gigante" and think it’s just a random alias. It’s not. In the comics, Sofia Falcone was massive—a literal giant of a woman who was as physically imposing as she was cruel. But the show did something much smarter. It took that "Gigante" name and turned it into a weapon of identity.
Sofia Gigante is the name she chooses after realizing her father, Carmine Falcone, wasn't just a mob boss; he was a serial killer who framed his own daughter to protect his legacy. When she ditches the Falcone name, she isn't just changing a line on a driver's license. She is erasing the man who stole ten years of her life in Arkham Asylum.
The Arkham Factor
You can't talk about Sofia Gigante without talking about Arkham. It changed her. She went in as a somewhat naive socialite and came out as a "hot wire," a fuse ready to explode. The show spends a lot of time on the trauma of her incarceration, and rightfully so. It’s what makes her sympathetic. You almost want her to win, even when she’s gassing her entire family at a dinner table.
🔗 Read more: Blink-182 Mark Hoppus: What Most People Get Wrong About His 2026 Comeback
That scene in the fourth episode, "Homecoming," is where everything shifts. She stops being the victim. She becomes the predator. By the time she adopts the name Sofia Gigante—her mother’s maiden name—she has fully embraced the monster Gotham made her.
What Most People Get Wrong About the Hangman
If you’re a comic book nerd, you know Sofia as "The Hangman." In the Dark Victory run by Jeph Loeb and Tim Sale, she’s a serial killer targeting cops. But the show pulls a fast one on us.
In the HBO universe, Sofia Gigante was falsely labeled the Hangman by the media and her father. She didn't kill those women. Carmine did. He used her as a scapegoat, letting her rot in a cell while the world called her a monster.
- The Misconception: Sofia is a born-and-bred killer.
- The Reality: She was the most "innocent" Falcone until the system and her family broke her.
- The Twist: Her villainy is a choice made for survival, not a personality trait she started with.
It’s a tragic inversion. Usually, we see villains "fall" into darkness. Sofia was pushed into a pit and spent a decade learning how to climb out using the bones of her enemies.
💡 You might also like: Why Grand Funk’s Bad Time is Secretly the Best Pop Song of the 1970s
The Relationship With Oz Cobb
The dynamic between Sofia Gigante and the Penguin is basically a masterclass in toxic workplace relationships, but with more stabbings. Oz was her driver. He was the one who ratted her out to Carmine. He’s the reason she lost a decade of her life.
There is this weird, lingering respect between them, or at least a recognition of each other’s hustle. Oz wants power because he wants to be loved. Sofia wants power because she has nothing left to lose.
Why She’s More Compelling Than Oz
Let’s be real. Oz is a classic narcissist. He’s fun to watch, but he’s predictable. Sofia Gigante is a wildcard. You never know if she’s going to offer you a drink or a bullet. Cristin Milioti plays her with these massive, unblinking eyes that make you feel like she can see right through the screen.
She overshadows Oz because her stakes feel higher. When she loses, it’s heartbreaking. When she wins, it’s terrifying.
📖 Related: Why La Mera Mera Radio is Actually Dominating Local Airwaves Right Now
The Ending and That Mysterious Letter
By the time the finale rolls around, Sofia Gigante finds herself back where she started: Arkham. It feels like a defeat, but then there's that letter.
The show drops a massive hint about her future by mentioning a half-sister. Comic fans know exactly who that is: Selina Kyle, a.k.a. Catwoman. This connection opens up a huge world for the future of the "Batverse." It suggests that even though she’s locked up, Sofia Gigante isn't done. She has an ally on the outside.
How to Understand the Sofia Gigante Legacy
If you want to really get why this character resonated so much with audiences, you have to look at the themes of the show. It’s about the people Gotham discards.
- The Gender Flip: Taking a character known for physical size and making her power come from psychological resilience.
- The Name Change: Moving from Falcone (the father’s shadow) to Gigante (the mother’s memory).
- The Sympathy Gap: Making a mass murderer the most relatable person in the room.
Sofia Gigante represents the "broken" parts of the city that refuse to stay hidden. She isn't just a villain in a penguin show; she's a survivor who decided that if the world was going to treat her like a monster, she might as well be the best one they've ever seen.
To fully appreciate the nuance of this character, it’s worth revisiting the Long Halloween and Dark Victory comics to see just how much the showrunners deviated from the source material to create something more modern and grounded. Keep an eye out for any news regarding a second season or a spin-off movie, as the "Gigante" story is clearly far from over. If you haven't yet, watch the "Homecoming" episode again—it's the definitive turning point for the character and arguably the best hour of television produced in 2024.