Growing up in the 90s, you didn't just watch the Atlanta Braves. You felt them. Specifically, you felt the crushing inevitability of their starting rotation. It didn’t matter if it was a Tuesday in May or Game 1 of the NLCS; you knew exactly what was coming. It was three first-ballot Hall of Famers—John Smoltz, Tom Glavine, and Greg Maddux—taking turns dismantling lineups with the cold precision of a Swiss watch.
Honestly, looking back at it now, the sheer longevity of it is what’s most offensive to modern baseball fans. We live in an era of "openers" and five-inning limits. These guys threw complete games like they were bored. Between 1993 and 2002, they weren't just a rotation. They were a decade-long psychological experiment on the National League.
How the Big Three Built a Dynasty (and Broke the League)
Most people think these three were just "born" in Atlanta, but the way they came together was actually kinda messy. Tom Glavine was the homegrown lefty, drafted back in '84. John Smoltz came over in a trade with the Tigers that Detroit fans still have nightmares about (Doyle Alexander, anyone?). Then, in 1993, the Braves pulled off the ultimate flex by signing Greg Maddux away from the Cubs right after he won his first Cy Young.
Basically, the Braves collected aces like Pokémon cards.
👉 See also: Tom Brady Throwing Motion: What Most People Get Wrong
The result was a ten-year run where the National League East was essentially a closed shop. From '91 to 2005, the Braves won 14 straight division titles. You've gotta realize how insane that is. That’s an entire generation of kids in Georgia who grew up thinking first place was just the default setting for existence. While other teams were scrounging for a decent number-two starter, Bobby Cox was deciding which future Hall of Famer to start on three days' rest.
Smoltz Glavine and Maddux: The Three Different Flavors of Dominance
What made Smoltz Glavine and Maddux so terrifying wasn't just that they were good. It was that they were good in completely different ways. You couldn't "get a rhythm" against this staff because the guy you faced today looked nothing like the guy you’d face tomorrow.
- Greg Maddux (The Professor): Maddux was the guy who barely threw 90 mph but somehow made the best hitters in the world look like they were swinging underwater. He didn't just pitch; he manipulated. Tony Gwynn once said Maddux could put the ball in a teacup. He won four straight Cy Youngs (1992–1995) and didn't walk anybody. Seriously. In 1995, he threw 209 innings and walked 23 guys. You’ve probably seen more walks in a single Little League inning.
- Tom Glavine (The Artist): If Maddux was about movement, Glavine was about the outside corner. He was a master of the "expanding strike zone." He’d throw a changeup three inches off the plate, get the call, and then throw the next one five inches off. By the seventh inning, hitters were swinging at pitches in the dugout just because they knew the umpire was going to call it a strike anyway. He won two Cy Youngs of his own and 305 career games.
- John Smoltz (The Powerhouse): Smoltz was the outlier. He had the "stuff." High-90s heater, a slider that disappeared, and an intensity that made you think he might actually charge the plate. He’s the only player in MLB history with 200+ wins and 150+ saves. Think about that. He was a Cy Young starter in '96, blew his arm out, got Tommy John surgery, became an elite closer, and then went back to the rotation to win 14 games at age 40.
The One Championship Problem
You’ll always hear the critics say it: "Only one World Series?"
✨ Don't miss: The Philadelphia Phillies Boston Red Sox Rivalry: Why This Interleague Matchup Always Feels Personal
Yeah, it’s the big asterisk. Despite the 14 division titles and the seven Cy Youngs between them in the 90s, they only hoisted the trophy in 1995. You’ve got to acknowledge the disappointment there. They ran into the 90s Yankees juggernaut, the '97 Marlins (and Livan Hernandez's "strike zone"), and some bad luck.
Smoltz famously said that the 1996 World Series loss to the Yankees was the "biggest gut punch" of his career. They were up 2-0 and heading home to Atlanta. They should have had a dynasty of rings, not just a dynasty of stats. But does that make them less great? Kinda doesn't. You can't look at 355 wins for Maddux and 305 for Glavine and tell me they weren't the greatest collective force in the modern era.
Why We Won’t See This Again
The "Big Three" era ended in 2002 when Glavine left for the Mets (which still looks weird in photos). Maddux followed him out the door back to Chicago in 2004. Smoltz stayed the longest, the last man standing in a changing game.
🔗 Read more: The Eagles and Chiefs Score That Changed Everything for Philadelphia and Kansas City
We won't see this again because the game changed. Pitchers today are taught to throw max effort for 90 pitches and hand it to the bullpen. Maddux, Glavine, and Smoltz were "pitchability" experts. They knew how to navigate a lineup three or four times. They didn't need 100 mph because they had 100% control.
Actionable Insights for Modern Baseball Fans
If you want to truly appreciate what Smoltz Glavine and Maddux did, don't just look at the back of their baseball cards. Do these three things to understand the craft:
- Watch "The Professor" on YouTube: Find a "Maddux Greg 1995 highlights" video. Watch how the ball starts at the hip of a lefty and ends up on the outside corner. It’s physics as art.
- Study the 1995 World Series Game 6: This was Tom Glavine’s masterpiece. One hit over eight innings against a Cleveland Indians lineup that was absolutely loaded (Thome, Lofton, Ramirez). It’s the blueprint for big-game pitching.
- Check the "Smoltz 200/150" Stat: Look up the list of pitchers with 200 wins and 150 saves. It’s just him. Understanding that versatility explains why his Hall of Fame case was so airtight.
The Braves of the 90s didn't just win games; they defined an era of pitching that feels like ancient history in today's high-velocity world. They were three distinct masters working in the same gallery, and we were just lucky to have seats.