You’ve seen the headlines. Probably daily. They tell you your brain is rotting because you can't stop scrolling. They say Google is making us stupid and that our attention spans are shorter than a goldfish's. It's a scary narrative. But honestly? It's mostly wrong.
Back in 2013, a journalist named Clive Thompson decided he’d had enough of the "techno-pessimism." He wrote a book called Smarter Than You Think: How Technology is Changing Our Minds for the Better. It wasn't just a rebuttal; it was a manifesto. Even now, over a decade later, the core arguments in Smarter Than You Think Clive Thompson are more relevant than ever.
We aren't becoming "dumb." We’re becoming something different. Something augmented.
The Myth of the "Rewired" Brain
Everyone loves to use the word "rewired." It sounds scientific. It sounds permanent. But Thompson points out something crucial: neuroscientists don't even fully understand how the brain is "wired" in the first place.
Trying to map the political dynamics of a whole state by looking out an airplane window at 30,000 feet? That’s how Gary Marcus, a leading psychologist, describes our current understanding of the brain. We're guessing.
Thompson argues that we’ve always been "cyborgs." Not with titanium limbs, but with tools. We’ve been outsourcing our thinking since we first scratched symbols into clay.
The printing press was supposed to destroy our memory. The telegraph was supposed to make us shallow. Sound familiar? It’s the same panic, just a different century.
The Rise of the Centaurs
One of the most famous stories in the book involves chess. In 1997, Garry Kasparov lost to IBM’s Deep Blue. It was a dark day for humanity. Or was it?
Kasparov didn’t give up. Instead, he started "Advanced Chess." This is where a human and a computer play as a team. He called them Centaurs.
Here’s the kicker: A Centaur is better than a human. It's also better than a computer alone.
Thompson highlights a 2005 tournament where "relative newbies"—not grandmasters—won the whole thing. They weren't the best players, and they didn't have the fastest computers. They were just better at cooperating with the machine. They knew when to trust the AI's "brute force" calculations and when to override it with human intuition.
This is us today. You’re playing "Advanced Chess" every time you use a calculator, a GPS, or a search engine. You’re not replacing your brain; you’re expanding its reach.
Thinking in Public
We used to think in private. You’d write in a diary or just mumble to yourself. Now? We think out loud.
We blog. We tweet. We post on Reddit.
Thompson calls this "public thinking." When you write for an audience—even a tiny one—you think more clearly. You check your facts. You anticipate counter-arguments.
There’s also this thing called "ambient awareness." It’s that weird, ESP-like feeling where you know what your friends are doing because you’ve seen their status updates. It sounds trivial. But on a global scale, it’s powerful.
Take the 2008 story of Chinese students who used the internet to shut down a $1.6 billion toxic copper plant. They didn't have a central leader. They just had a shared, ambient awareness of an injustice, and they organized in real-time.
✨ Don't miss: How to take Ring doorbell off without breaking the mounting bracket or losing your mind
Why Your Memory Isn't Actually Dying
"I don't know anyone's phone number anymore!"
Yeah, me neither. But who cares?
Thompson introduces us to people like Gordon Bell, a Microsoft researcher who "life-logged" everything. He recorded every conversation, every photo, every document.
This is the "Extended Mind." Our brains are great at some things—like finding patterns and being creative. They suck at others—like remembering exactly what you said in a meeting on Tuesday, October 14, 2014.
By offloading the boring, "storage" stuff to our devices, we free up mental RAM for the hard stuff. It's not "digital amnesia." It’s strategic outsourcing.
The Literacy Paradox
We are writing more than ever. Seriously.
Before the internet, the average person barely wrote anything after they finished school. Maybe a few letters or a grocery list.
Today, we write billions of words every day. Emails, texts, comments, threads. We are a "literacy-heavy" society now.
Sure, some of it is garbage. A lot of it is. But the sheer volume of "thought-to-text" is unprecedented in human history. We are practicing the art of persuasion and communication constantly.
The Real Problems Thompson Acknowledges
Look, the book isn't all sunshine and rainbows. Thompson isn't a "techno-utopian." He knows there are dark sides.
- Distraction: It's real. The "pings" are designed to hijack our dopamine.
- The Filter Bubble: We tend to talk to people who already agree with us.
- Power Dynamics: Governments and corporations use these same tools for surveillance.
The point isn't that technology is "good." It’s that it’s a tool. A hammer can build a house or break a window.
How to Be Smarter (Practical Steps)
If you want to actually use these ideas to get an edge, you have to be intentional. You can't just let the algorithms feed you.
1. Become a Better "Driver"
Like those chess players, don't just accept what the computer tells you. Use it as a starting point. Ask "why" the algorithm suggested that.
2. Practice "Public Thinking"
Don't just consume content. Create it. Even if it's just a thoughtful comment on a forum or a short blog post. The act of writing for others will sharpen your own logic.
3. Use the "Extended Mind" for Search, Not Just Storage
Don't just bookmark things. Tag them. Organize your digital life so you can find information quickly. Use tools like Notion, Obsidian, or even just a well-organized set of folders.
4. Balance Ambient Awareness with Deep Work
You need the "pings" for connection, but you need silence for focus. Set boundaries. Use "Do Not Disturb" modes.
Smarter Than You Think Clive Thompson tells us that we’re in the middle of a massive cognitive shift. It’s messy. It’s loud. It’s confusing.
But we aren't losing our humanity. We’re just upgrading it. The machines aren't winning; they're joining the team.
Next time you feel guilty for "googling it," remember: you aren't being lazy. You're being a Centaur. And the Centaur always beats the human.