Honestly, if you’re trying to put together a smalls the sandlot costume, you’re probably doing it because you want to channel that specific brand of "new kid in town" energy. We've all been there. Awkward. A little clueless. Wearing the wrong hat.
The thing about Scotty Smalls is that his look isn't just about baseball; it’s about a transformation. When he first rolls up to the sandlot, he looks like he's headed to a country club or a very boring fishing trip with his stepdad, Bill. By the end, he’s a ballplayer. Sorta.
If you want to nail the costume, you have to decide which version of Smalls you’re going for. Is it the "L7 Weenie" who doesn't know who the Great Bambino is? Or is it the kid who finally fits in with the guys? Most people mess this up by just wearing a generic baseball jersey. Don't be that person.
The "L7 Weenie" Starter Pack
Before Smalls became one of the guys, he was a walking fashion disaster for 1962. This is the version of the costume that actually gets the most laughs at parties because it's so specific.
First, you need the hat. It’s not a baseball cap yet. It’s that weird, long-billed, tan or cream-colored "fisherman" style hat. It’s stiff. It’s awkward. It’s basically a sign that says "I have never seen a baseball in my life."
Then there’s the shirt. You want a polo or a short-sleeved button-down. Think "nerdy 60s kid." The colors are usually muted—light blues or whites. It needs to be tucked in. If it’s not tucked into a pair of stiff khakis, you aren’t doing it right.
Key Elements of the Early Smalls Look:
- The Fishing Hat: Long bill, tan or white.
- The Polo: Tucked in, very clean.
- The Khakis: Straight leg, probably ironed by his mom.
- The PF Flyers: Actually, in the beginning, he’s wearing basic black or white canvas sneakers. He doesn't get the "secret weapon" shoes until later.
Why Smalls the Sandlot Costume Still Matters
It's been over thirty years since The Sandlot hit theaters in 1993, yet every Halloween, you see at least three kids (and twenty adults) dressed as the gang. Why?
✨ Don't miss: Bob Hearts Abishola Season 4 Explained: The Move That Changed Everything
Because Smalls is the ultimate underdog. Most of us weren’t Benny "The Jet" Rodriguez. We weren’t the cool guys who could steal home. We were the kids who showed up with a glove that was too big and a hat that looked like a solar panel.
The smalls the sandlot costume works because it’s recognizable but easy to DIY. You don't need a $200 replica jersey. You need a trip to a thrift store and a "You're killing me, Smalls" attitude.
Transitioning to the Ballplayer
Once Benny takes Smalls under his wing, the wardrobe changes. This is the "intermediate" Smalls.
He loses the fisherman hat. Benny gives him a real baseball cap, but it’s still a bit plain. If you’re going for this look, a simple black or dark blue baseball cap—worn slightly crooked—is the way to go.
The shirt becomes a simple t-shirt or a striped crew neck. This is where people start confusing him with Squints. Squints is the one with the thick black glasses and the striped shirt. Smalls is more basic. A plain white tee with a bit of dirt on it is more authentic for Scotty.
The Holy Grail: The Signed Ball
You cannot—I repeat, cannot—pull off a smalls the sandlot costume without the ball.
🔗 Read more: Black Bear by Andrew Belle: Why This Song Still Hits So Hard
But it’s not just any ball. It’s the "trophy" ball. The one signed by Babe Ruth. To make this look real, find a clean baseball and use a black marker to fake the signature.
"I thought you said 'The Great Bambi.'"
"THAT BEADY-EYED DEER?!"
If you’re carrying a glove, make sure it’s an old-school leather one. None of that modern neon mesh stuff. It should look like something your grandpa left in the garage.
Avoid These Common Costume Mistakes
- Too Much Polish: If your costume is perfectly clean, you aren't playing ball. Rub some actual dirt on your knees. Smudge a little on the shirt.
- Wrong Glasses: Smalls doesn't wear glasses. If you put on thick black rims, you are Squints. You've just insulted the entire fandom.
- Modern Sneakers: If I see Nikes or Yeezys under those khakis, the immersion is broken. Go for Converse Chuck Taylors or basic Keds.
The "Adult Smalls" Variant
Remember the end of the movie? Smalls is in the broadcast booth. He’s wearing a headset and a very 90s-looking blazer.
This is a deep-cut costume choice. It requires a headset with a big foam mic and a tan sports coat. If you do this, you have to be prepared for people to ask who you are all night until you say the line.
But for most of us, the 1962 version is the winner.
💡 You might also like: Billie Eilish Therefore I Am Explained: The Philosophy Behind the Mall Raid
How to Assemble the Look Today
You don't need to buy a "complete" costume in a plastic bag from a big-box store. Those usually look cheap and the sizing is weird anyway.
Hit up a local thrift shop. Look for a pair of "dad" khakis. Find a plain white or light blue polo that’s one size too small. For the hat, search for "vintage long bill cap" or "retro fishing hat."
If you want to go the jersey route, look for a #10 jersey. While Smalls didn't start with one, the #10 has become synonymous with his character in the years since the movie's release, mostly thanks to merchandise.
Your Final Checklist:
- Hat: Long bill (early) or plain dark baseball cap (late).
- Shirt: White polo or plain tee.
- Pants: Khaki trousers or classic blue jeans.
- Shoes: Canvas sneakers.
- Accessory: A baseball with "Babe Ruth" scribbled on it.
Once you have the gear, just work on your confused face. Practice saying "The Great... who?" and you’re basically there.
Check your local thrift stores first for the most authentic 60s feel, as modern "vintage" styles often get the collar shape wrong. After you've got the base outfit, use a piece of sandpaper to lightly scuff the edges of the hat and shoes to make it look like you've actually been out in the dirt.