You’re tired. Honestly, you’re beyond tired. You started this business because you had a vision, but now you’re spending fourteen hours a day chasing invoices, answering basic customer emails, and wondering if you’ll ever have time to actually do the work you love again. It’s a classic plateau. You know you need help, but the thought of small business hiring first employee feels heavier than the actual workload you're carrying. It's a terrifying pivot point. One day you’re a solo operator, and the next, you’re legally responsible for another human being’s mortgage and healthcare.
Most people think hiring is just about posting a job ad on LinkedIn or Indeed and picking the person who doesn’t have typos in their resume. It isn't. Not even close. If you mess this up, you don't just lose money; you lose your sanity and potentially your company culture before it even starts.
The legal minefield you can’t ignore
Before you even think about interviewing, you have to deal with the government. They want their cut, and they want paperwork. First, you need an Employer Identification Number (EIN) from the IRS. It’s basically a social security number for your business. Don't skip this. You also need to verify that your new hire can actually work in the U.S. using the I-9 form. It feels like busywork until the Department of Labor knocks on your door.
Workers' compensation insurance is another big one. Most states require it the second you hire one person. If your new assistant trips over a power cord in your home office or a co-working space and you don't have coverage, you're personally liable for those medical bills. That's a fast way to go bankrupt. According to the U.S. Small Business Administration, failing to register for state unemployment tax accounts is one of the most common mistakes founders make. You have to report every new hire to your state’s New Hire Reporting Program. Why? Usually for child support enforcement. It’s a lot of friction, but it’s the price of growth.
Contractor vs. Employee: Don't play games with the IRS
A lot of founders try to be "clever" by hiring someone as a 1099 contractor when they are actually a W-2 employee. The IRS has a very specific "Right to Control" test. If you tell them when to show up, what tools to use, and how to do the work, they are an employee. Period. If you misclassify them to save on payroll taxes, the penalties and back taxes will dwarf whatever you thought you were saving.
Defining the "Who" before the "How"
Who do you actually need? Usually, the first hire shouldn't be a "mini-me." If you’re a visionary who hates details, don't hire another visionary. You need an integrator. You need someone who loves the spreadsheets you despise.
💡 You might also like: Dealing With the IRS San Diego CA Office Without Losing Your Mind
Write down every single task you did in the last two weeks. Circle the ones that made you want to scream. Circle the ones that anyone with a basic brain could do if you gave them a checklist. That is your job description. It’s tempting to look for a "Rockstar" or a "Ninja," but honestly, those people are usually expensive and high-maintenance. For a small business hiring first employee, you often just need a "Rock-Solid Reliable Person." Someone who shows up and follows the process.
Specifics matter. Instead of saying "must have good communication skills," say "must be able to respond to 20 customer tickets an hour with zero grammatical errors." Precision saves you from the "I thought you knew how to do this" conversation three weeks in.
The true cost of a $50,000 salary
If you think a $50k salary costs you $50k, you’re in for a rude awakening. You’ve got the employer’s share of FICA (7.65%), unemployment taxes (FUTA and SUTA), the cost of benefits, and the overhead of whatever equipment they need. A good rule of thumb is that an employee costs about 1.25 to 1.4 times their base salary.
- Base Salary: $50,000
- Taxes and Insurance: ~$6,000
- Software licenses/Laptop/Desk: ~$3,000
- Total: $59,000 minimum.
Do you have that cash sitting in a dedicated account? You should probably have at least six months of their salary set aside before you pull the trigger. Cash flow is volatile. Your employee’s paycheck shouldn't be.
Culture is what you do when things go wrong
You don't have a "culture" yet. You have a vibe. The first person you hire is the culture. If they are cynical, your company becomes cynical. If they are obsessed with quality, your company becomes synonymous with quality. This is why the "beer test" (would I want to have a drink with this person?) is actually a terrible way to hire. You aren't looking for a friend. You're looking for a partner in your mission.
📖 Related: Sands Casino Long Island: What Actually Happens Next at the Old Coliseum Site
Look for "Productive Paranoia." This is a term popularized by Jim Collins in Great by Choice. You want someone who is slightly worried about things going wrong and takes proactive steps to fix them. That trait is worth its weight in gold when you’re a tiny team.
Interviewing without being a creep or a bore
Stop asking "Where do you see yourself in five years?" Nobody knows. Instead, use behavioral questions. "Tell me about a time you had to deal with a customer who was flat-out wrong. How did you handle it without losing the sale?"
Listen to the "I" vs. "We." If they take all the credit for everything, they might be a ego-driven nightmare. If they only say "we," they might be hiding the fact that they didn't actually do much. You want a balance.
Give them a test. A real one. If you’re hiring an admin, have them organize a messy calendar or write a draft email to a difficult client. Pay them for their time—it's the ethical thing to do—but never hire someone without seeing them actually perform a task related to the job. Auditions beat resumes every single time.
Setting them up to actually succeed
The biggest mistake? The "Dump and Run." You hire them, give them a login to the email, and say "Go for it, I'll be in meetings." They will fail. Guaranteed.
👉 See also: Is The Housing Market About To Crash? What Most People Get Wrong
You need a "Day One" plan.
- 9:00 AM: Coffee and tour (even if it’s a virtual tour of your Slack).
- 10:00 AM: Tech setup.
- 11:00 AM: The "Why." Explain the mission. Why does this business exist?
- 12:00 PM: Lunch (on you).
- 1:00 PM: Their first "Quick Win." Give them a task they can finish in two hours.
Documentation is your best friend here. If you haven't recorded Loom videos of yourself doing the tasks you're handing off, start today. It feels tedious, but it prevents you from having to answer the same question fifteen times. Small business hiring first employee is as much about your ability to lead as it is about their ability to work. You are no longer just a "doer." You are a teacher.
The psychological shift
Be prepared for the "First Employee Blues." You will feel like they aren't doing it as well as you. They won't. Not at first. You've been doing this for years; they’ve been doing it for twenty minutes. You have to let go of the "perfection" drug. If they can do the task 80% as well as you can, that’s a win. Use the extra 20% of your time to grow the business so you can eventually hire a second person who can do it 100% as well as you.
Actionable Steps to Take Right Now
If you're serious about taking this leap, don't just "think about it." Start the engine.
- Get your EIN. It takes ten minutes on the IRS website. It makes the whole thing feel real.
- Audit your time. Spend three days tracking every task in 15-minute increments. This tells you exactly what you're hiring for.
- Talk to an insurance agent. Get a quote for workers' comp and professional liability. Know the numbers before you look at resumes.
- Draft the "Anti-Job Description." List the things this job is not. If it’s not a remote job, say so. If there’s no room for promotion for two years, be honest. You want to repel the wrong people as much as you want to attract the right ones.
- Set up a payroll service. Systems like Gusto or ADP are built for this. They handle the tax filings, the direct deposits, and the W-2s. Do not try to do payroll manually. You will miss a filing deadline and the IRS will fine you more than the software costs for the entire year.
Hiring that first person is the difference between owning a job and owning a business. It's uncomfortable, expensive, and risky. But staying small because you're afraid of the paperwork is the surest way to burn out before you ever reach your potential.