Sinéad O’Connor: What Most People Get Wrong About Her Life and Legacy

You probably remember the tear. That single, perfect drop of salt water rolling down her cheek in the "Nothing Compares 2 U" video. Or maybe you remember the white shards of paper falling like snow on the set of Saturday Night Live after she shredded a photo of Pope John Paul II.

For decades, the world tried to pin Sinéad O’Connor into a very specific box. She was the "crazy" Irish girl. She was the "shaved-head" radical. She was the pop star who "ruined" her career on live television.

But honestly? Most of that narrative is total garbage.

Sinéad wasn't a pop star who lost her way; she was a protest singer who accidentally got famous. If you want to understand what really happened with her life, her conversion to Islam, and her sudden death in 2023, you have to look past the headlines and the 1990s tabloid cruelty.

The SNL Incident: It Wasn't About "Hating" Religion

When people talk about Sinéad O’Connor, they always go back to October 3, 1992. She stood on the SNL stage, sang an a cappella version of Bob Marley’s "War," and ripped up the Pope's picture while telling the audience to "fight the real enemy."

The backlash was instant and brutal. Joe Pesci threatened to smack her. Madonna mocked her. People literally crushed her CDs with steamrollers in Times Square.

Here is what most people get wrong: they thought she was attacking faith.

📖 Related: Is Men in Black Okay for Kids? A Men in Black Parents Guide to What’s Actually Inside

In reality, she was a prophet. She was screaming about the systemic cover-up of child abuse within the Catholic Church a full decade before the Boston Globe "Spotlight" investigation made it undeniable. She didn't pick that photo at random, either. It was the same photo that had hung on her mother's wall—the mother who, by Sinéad's own account in her memoir Rememberings, had physically and psychologically abused her for years.

Ripping that photo wasn't a career suicide note. For her, it was an exorcism. She later wrote that having a number-one record was what actually "derailed" her career, and tearing the photo put her back on the right track. She wanted to be a musician, not a product.

The Many Names of Sinéad O’Connor

Identity was never a static thing for her. She grew up in a Dublin that felt like a "torture chamber" sometimes, spent time in a Magdalene Asylum as a teenager for shoplifting, and spent the rest of her life trying to find a version of herself that felt safe.

In 2017, she legally changed her name to Magda Davitt. She said she wanted to be "free of patriarchal slave names."

Then came 2018. She converted to Islam and took the name Shuhada’ Sadaqat.

Predictably, the internet had a meltdown. But if you listen to her interviews from that time, she sounded more at peace than she had in years. She called her conversion the "natural conclusion of any intelligent theologian’s journey." She continued to perform as Sinéad because that’s the name the world knew, but Shuhada was the person who actually lived in her skin.

👉 See also: Jack Off Jill Songs: Why the Riot Goth Legends Still Matter in 2026

What Really Happened in 2023?

When news broke on July 26, 2023, that she had been found unresponsive in her London home, the rumors started flying immediately. Given her very public struggles with mental health and the devastating loss of her 17-year-old son, Shane, just a year prior, many assumed the worst.

It took a while for the facts to catch up.

In early 2024, the coroner finally confirmed that Sinéad O’Connor died of natural causes. Specifically, her death certificate noted that she passed away from an "exacerbation of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) and bronchial asthma," along with a respiratory infection.

She was 56.

It’s a heavy realization. She didn't "give up." Her body, which had carried the weight of so much trauma and so much song, simply gave out.

Beyond the "Nothing Compares 2 U" Shadow

If you only know her through that Prince cover, you’re missing out on some of the most haunting music of the last forty years.

• The Lion and the Cobra (1987): She recorded this while she was pregnant, defying her record label who wanted her to look "pretty" and feminine. Instead, she shaved her head and screamed.
• Universal Mother (1994): A raw, tender exploration of motherhood and healing.
• Throw Down Your Arms (2005): A full-blown reggae album recorded in Jamaica. It's surprisingly great.

She was also a massive advocate for others. She spoke up about Black Lives Matter and police brutality in her song "Black Boys on Mopeds" back in 1990. She talked about fibromyalgia, bipolar disorder, and PTSD long before "mental health awareness" was a trendy hashtag.

She was always too early. That was her curse.

How to Honor Her Today

Sinéad didn't want your pity. She wanted people to listen—really listen—to the truth, even when it’s uncomfortable.

If you want to actually engage with her legacy, start by reading her book, Rememberings. It’s funny, heartbreaking, and weirdly hopeful. Then, go find a copy of her 2022 documentary Nothing Compares. It contextualizes her "controversies" through a modern lens and shows just how much the industry tried to break her.

✨ Don't miss: Why Cry of the City Still Matters: The Gritty Noir That Predicted Modern Crime Drama

Don't remember her as a victim. Remember her as a woman who refused to be quiet when everyone else was whispering.

Next Steps for the Listener:

• Listen to her 1994 album Universal Mother to hear a side of her voice that isn't just "protest."
• Watch the Nothing Compares documentary to see the archival footage of the SNL backlash and decide for yourself if she was "crazy" or just right.
• Support mental health organizations that focus on trauma survivors, as this was the cause closest to her heart.