You’ve probably heard that everyone is magnesium deficient. It’s the "it" mineral of the decade. People are spraying it on their feet to sleep, tossing back capsules to ease anxiety, and drinking powders to stay regular. We’re told we need more. Always more. But honestly, you can have too much of a good thing, and while your kidneys are usually rockstars at filtering out the excess, they aren't invincible.
Hypermagnesemia. That’s the clinical term for having way too much magnesium in your blood. It’s rare, sure, but it’s becoming more common as people treat supplements like candy.
The signs of too much magnesium often start out looking like a minor stomach bug. You might feel a little "off" or spend an extra ten minutes in the bathroom. But if those levels keep climbing, things get weird. Your heart rate might skip a beat. Your muscles might feel like lead. It’s a spectrum that ranges from "annoying digestive issues" to "emergency room visit."
Why your kidneys usually save you (until they don't)
Most of us don't need to worry about the magnesium in our spinach or almonds. Your body is incredibly efficient at maintaining homeostasis. When you eat a big bowl of pumpkin seeds—which are packed with magnesium—your small intestine absorbs what it needs and your kidneys flush the rest down the toilet. Literally.
But here is where it gets tricky. If you have any level of chronic kidney disease (CKD), that filtration system slows down. It’s like a clogged drain. Even a standard supplement dose can suddenly become toxic because it has nowhere to go. This is why doctors like Dr. Vinay Prasad or specialists at the Mayo Clinic emphasize checking kidney function before starting heavy supplementation.
It isn't just about the kidneys, though. Some people take massive doses of antacids or laxatives containing magnesium hydroxide or magnesium citrate. If you’re Downing Milk of Magnesia every single day, you’re bypassing your body’s natural intake limits. You’re flooding the system.
The early red flags: Digestion and Lethargy
The very first signs of too much magnesium are almost always gastrointestinal. Why? Because magnesium is an osmotic laxative. It pulls water into the intestines.
💡 You might also like: Can I overdose on vitamin d? The reality of supplement toxicity
Diarrhea is the classic "canary in the coal mine." If you start a new supplement and your stools become watery or urgent, that’s your body screaming that it can’t process the load. It’s not a "detox." It’s malabsorption. Along with the bathroom trips, you might feel nauseous. Some people describe a dull, cramping ache in the upper abdomen that feels different from hunger or gas.
Then comes the fatigue. Not just "I stayed up too late watching Netflix" tired. It’s a heavy, systemic lethargy. Since magnesium plays a role in muscle relaxation, too much of it starts to suppress the central nervous system. You might feel like your limbs are weighted. Your brain might feel foggy. You’re essentially sedating yourself from the inside out.
When it gets serious: The neurological and cardiac shift
As magnesium levels in the serum rise above 1.7 to 2.3 mg/dL (the normal range), the symptoms shift from annoying to alarming.
- Loss of deep tendon reflexes. If a doctor taps your knee with that little rubber hammer and nothing happens, that’s a major red flag for hypermagnesemia.
- Low blood pressure (Hypotension). Magnesium relaxes the walls of your blood vessels. Too much of it causes them to dilate so much that your blood pressure drops. You might feel dizzy every time you stand up or feel like you’re about to faint.
- Respiratory distress. In extreme cases, magnesium slows down the muscles responsible for breathing. It’s a terrifying sensation of not being able to take a full breath.
Let's talk about the heart. This is the part that actually kills people, though it’s incredibly rare. Magnesium and calcium work in a delicate dance to make your heart beat. Magnesium relaxes; calcium contracts. When magnesium dominates the dance floor, the heart's electrical signals get confused. This can lead to bradycardia—a dangerously slow heart rate—or even cardiac arrest.
The "Supplement Trap" and unexpected sources
People often think "natural" means "safe." But your body doesn't care if the magnesium came from a high-end organic brand or a cheap drugstore bottle; it only cares about the elemental load.
A 2017 case study published in BMJ Case Reports detailed an elderly man who developed severe magnesium toxicity simply from taking too many over-the-counter antacids for his indigestion. He wasn't trying to "optimize his health"—he just had heartburn.
📖 Related: What Does DM Mean in a Cough Syrup: The Truth About Dextromethorphan
Then there’s the Epsom salt trend. While soaking in a tub is generally fine for most, there have been documented cases of magnesium toxicity from people ingesting Epsom salts as a "liver flush" or "colon cleanse." This is dangerous. Don't drink your bath salts. Just don't.
Who is actually at risk?
- The "Biohacker" community: People stacking multiple supplements (ZMA for sleep, a multivitamin, and a magnesium drink mix) can easily exceed 1,000mg a day.
- Elderly individuals: Kidney function naturally declines with age, making it harder to clear excess minerals.
- People with GI disorders: Sometimes, a damaged gut lining can lead to unpredictable absorption rates.
What to do if you suspect you've overdone it
Stop.
That’s the first step. If you’re experiencing the signs of too much magnesium, the very first thing to do is cut out all supplemental sources. This includes fortified cereals, "sleep" drinks, and those flavored water drops.
Hydrate. If your kidneys are healthy, drinking plenty of water helps them filter the excess magnesium out of your bloodstream more effectively.
If you’re feeling the more severe symptoms—the slow heart rate, the extreme muscle weakness, or the inability to catch your breath—you need an ER, not a blog post. In a clinical setting, doctors often use intravenous calcium gluconate. Remember that dance between calcium and magnesium? The calcium helps counteract the effects of the magnesium on your heart and muscles, essentially acting as an "antidote."
Actionable steps for the savvy supplementer
Don't let the fear of toxicity stop you from maintaining healthy levels, but be smart about it.
👉 See also: Creatine Explained: What Most People Get Wrong About the World's Most Popular Supplement
Check your labs first. Ask for a serum magnesium test, but keep in mind that only about 1% of your body's magnesium is in your blood. A Red Blood Cell (RBC) Magnesium test is often considered a more accurate reflection of your long-term status.
Watch the "Elemental" dose. Look at the back of your bottle. If it says "Magnesium Citrate 1,000mg," look for how much of that is elemental magnesium. Often, the actual mineral content is much lower than the total compound weight. The Tolerable Upper Intake Level (UL) for supplemental magnesium for adults is generally 350 mg per day, unless otherwise directed by a physician.
Rotate your sources. Instead of relying solely on pills, focus on magnesium-rich foods like Swiss chard, almonds, and dark chocolate. It is almost physically impossible to reach toxic levels of magnesium through food alone because the fiber and other nutrients slow down the absorption and your satiety signals kick in.
Monitor your "Bathroom Baseline." Use your digestion as a guide. If your stools are consistently loose after taking your supplement, you’ve reached your personal threshold. Back off by 100mg and see if things stabilize.
Magnesium is an essential mineral for over 300 biochemical reactions in your body, from DNA repair to muscle contraction. It’s vital. But respect the potency of what you’re putting in your body. More isn't always better; sometimes, "just enough" is exactly where the magic happens.
If you are worried, talk to a pharmacist or a GP. They can look at your full list of medications—including those "innocent" antacids—to see if you're accidentally doubling or tripling up on your dose. Be honest about everything you take, even the "natural" stuff.