If you’ve seen the movie Kingdom of Heaven, you probably remember Eva Green playing a mysterious, exotic princess who hates her husband and falls for a dashing blacksmith. It makes for great cinema. But honestly? The real Sibylla Queen of Jerusalem was nothing like that. She wasn't some bored royal looking for an affair. She was a woman who actually loved her "villainous" husband so much she basically nuked her own political reputation to keep him.
History is messy.
Born around 1160, Sibylla was never supposed to be the one holding the bag when the Crusader states collapsed. She was the daughter of King Amalric and Agnes of Courtenay. Her childhood was spent in the Convent of Saint Lazarus, raised by her great-aunt Ioveta. Imagine growing up in a stone convent while your brother, Baldwin IV, is slowly being eaten away by leprosy. That was her reality. Because Baldwin couldn't have kids, Sibylla became the most important chess piece in the Middle East.
The Marriage That Broke the Kingdom
Everyone wanted a piece of Sibylla’s inheritance. Her first husband, William "Longsword" of Montferrat, died just months after they married, leaving her pregnant and widowed at barely seventeen. For three years, she stayed single while the nobles bickered over who should get her hand. Then came Guy of Lusignan.
Most history books paint Guy as a total moron. A "lightweight" who didn't understand the local politics. The local barons hated him. They thought he was an arrogant newcomer from France. But Sibylla? She was obsessed.
There’s a famous story—some call it a legend, others say it’s the only way to explain the legal loophole she used—about her coronation. In 1186, after her young son Baldwin V died, the throne was technically hers. But the High Court of Jerusalem had a condition. They’d let her be Queen, but only if she annulled her marriage to the hated Guy.
She agreed. Kind of.
She told the barons she’d set Guy aside as long as she could choose her next husband herself. The court, thinking they’d finally gotten rid of Guy, said yes. Sibylla was crowned alone. Then, she stood up, took the crown, and handed it straight to Guy. "I choose him," she basically said. You can almost hear the collective facepalm from the knights in the room.
Why Sibylla Queen of Jerusalem Stayed Loyal
Why did she do it? Most historians, like Bernard Hamilton in The Leper King and His Heirs, argue it wasn't just a political move. She was genuinely, perhaps even "hysterically," attached to him. This loyalty cost her everything.
- It split the nobility into two warring factions right when Saladin was preparing to attack.
- It put a man in charge of the army who was famously indecisive.
- It led directly to the Battle of Hattin.
In 1187, Guy led the Christian army into a literal desert trap at the Horns of Hattin. It was a slaughter. Saladin captured Guy and most of the kingdom's leadership. Jerusalem was left wide open.
While Guy was sitting in a prison cell, Sibylla Queen of Jerusalem was the one who actually stayed behind to organize the defense of the city. She worked with Balian of Ibelin (the guy she definitely wasn't dating in real life) to negotiate the surrender. She didn't flee until she had to. She even went to Saladin herself to beg for Guy's release. Saladin, being a bit of a romantic or perhaps just realizing Guy was more useful to him alive (since he was so bad at leading), eventually let him go.
The Tragic End at Acre
The end of her life is actually way sadder than the movies. After Jerusalem fell, she followed Guy to the siege of Acre. This wasn't a palace life. It was a filthy, disease-ridden military camp.
In the summer of 1190, an epidemic—likely the plague or some form of dysentery—ripped through the camp. It didn't care about royal blood. Sibylla watched her two young daughters, Alice and Maria, die in the dirt. A few days later, she died too. She was only about thirty.
When she died, Guy lost his legal right to be King. Without her, he was just some guy with a crown and no kingdom. The fact that he tried to keep ruling anyway started another massive civil war among the Crusaders.
✨ Don't miss: 36mm to Inches: The Real Size and Why It Matters for Your Gear
How to Look at Her Legacy Today
If you’re looking for a "girl boss" narrative, Sibylla is a tough fit. She made choices that were objectively bad for her country because of her personal feelings. But she also showed a level of grit that most people overlook.
She didn't abandon her husband when things got ugly. She didn't take the easy way out and marry a more popular noble to keep her throne. She was a woman who lived in a world where she was treated as a vessel for a crown, and she decided, for better or worse, to exercise her own will.
Next steps for history nerds:
💡 You might also like: Sending Poop in the Mail: Is it Actually Legal?
- Read the primary sources: Check out the Old French Continuation of William of Tyre. It’s biased as heck, but it gives you the flavor of how much the locals actually loathed Guy.
- Look at the maps: Find a map of the Battle of Hattin. You’ll see exactly why the nobles were so mad that Sibylla put Guy in charge.
- Compare the queens: Read up on her grandmother, Melisende. She was a much more effective ruler who knew how to balance power without letting her heart get in the way.
Sibylla’s story is a reminder that in the Middle Ages, love wasn't a luxury—it was a political grenade.