Finding that perfect item for a preschool or kindergarten show and tell is weirdly stressful. You’re standing in the middle of the living room, scanning the shelves, and suddenly every object you own seems to start with the letter B or S. When it’s "I" week, the panic sets in because, let’s be honest, how many things that start with I for show and tell do you actually have lying around that won't result in a mess or a call from the teacher?
Most parents default to an ice cube or an iPad. Don’t do that. One melts into a puddle on the carpet, and the other is a high-stakes liability that probably isn’t allowed in the classroom anyway. You want something that sparks a conversation, something that makes your kid feel like the smartest person in the room for thirty seconds. It’s about more than just the letter; it’s about the "story" behind the "I" word.
Why the Letter I is Actually a Secret Weapon
The letter I is fascinating because it covers two distinct sounds—the short vowel like "igloo" and the long vowel like "ice." This is a big deal in early literacy development. When a child brings in an inchworm (plastic, please) and then someone else brings an iron, the teacher gets a perfect "teachable moment" about phonics.
But beyond the academics, I-word objects tend to be slightly more "exotic" than your standard apples or balls. We're talking about insects, instruments, and inventions. These are high-interest topics for five-year-olds. If you pick the right item, your child isn't just standing there holding a toy; they're explaining a concept. It builds confidence. It makes them the "expert" for the day.
The Classic "Short I" Hits
If your child’s teacher specifically asked for the short "ih" sound, you have to be a bit more creative. An Igloo is the gold standard here. Now, you probably don't have a block of ice shaped like a dome, but most kids have a LEGO set or a Playmobile setup with one. If not, a quick DIY project with sugar cubes or cotton balls glued to a cardboard bowl works wonders. It’s tactile. Kids love touching it.
Then there’s the Insects. This is a broad category. You can go the "creepy-crawly" route with a plastic beetle or a butterfly in a specimen jar. If you’re feeling brave and have a bug-obsessed kid, a (contained) ant farm is a showstopper. Just make sure the lid is tight. Seriously. No one wants to be the parent responsible for an ant infestation in the library.
Ink is another solid choice, though it comes with a mess warning. A fountain pen or a stamp pad allows the child to demonstrate how something works. "Look, I press this here, and it makes a mark." Simple. Effective. It’s a mechanical process that fascinates young minds.
💡 You might also like: Wire brush for cleaning: What most people get wrong about choosing the right bristles
Long I Objects That Actually Work
When you move into the long "eye" sound, the options get a bit more "real world." An Ice cream scoop is a genius move. Why? Because every kid loves ice cream. Your child can talk about their favorite flavor, how the spring mechanism in the handle works, and why it’s shaped like a sphere. It’s an everyday object that suddenly becomes interesting when you really look at it.
Instruments are also a massive win. An Igliu (an Arctic flute) is likely not in your junk drawer, but maybe you have an Igbo drum or just a simple I-themed toy guitar. Even better? An Iron. Not a hot one, obviously. An old-fashioned heavy iron or even a play version allows for a discussion about history and how people used to do chores before "smart" appliances.
The "Invisible" Problem
Sometimes, the best things that start with I for show and tell aren't things you can easily hold. Invisible ink is the ultimate "cool kid" move. You can make it at home with lemon juice and a Q-tip. The child brings in a "blank" piece of paper and explains the science. They don't even need to perform the "heat" part of the experiment at school (safety first); just explaining the secret message concept is enough to captivate a room of toddlers.
Digging Deeper: The Unexpected "I" List
Let’s get away from the basics. If you want your kid to stand out, you need to look at the "I" items that most people overlook. These are the ones that lead to the best questions from the class.
- Igneous Rock: If you have a rock collection, this is a winner. It’s a "fire rock" made from lava. That’s an instant "cool" factor of 10/10.
- Identification Card: A library card or a (voided) old ID. It’s a great way to talk about community, belonging, and who we are.
- Incandescent Lightbulb: Talk about how it gets hot and makes light. It’s a bit "retro" now that everything is LED, which actually makes it more interesting as an artifact.
- Illustrations: Bring in a favorite book and talk specifically about the pictures, not the story. Explain what an illustrator does.
- Island: A small map or a globe. Point to an island. It’s a geography lesson hidden in a show and tell session.
- Ivy: A small potted plant. It grows, it needs water, and it starts with I. Plus, it’s a living thing, which always gets kids excited.
The Strategy of the Selection
Don't just grab the first thing you see. Ask your child what they think is interesting about the item. If they can’t come up with two sentences about it, it’s the wrong item. The goal of show and tell isn't just to show; it’s to tell.
"This is my Iron Man figure" is okay.
"This is an Inhaler, and it helps me breathe when my asthma acts up" is powerful.
📖 Related: Images of Thanksgiving Holiday: What Most People Get Wrong
The latter teaches empathy and health literacy. It turns a medical device into a tool of empowerment. Similarly, bringing in an Invitation from a birthday party can lead to a discussion about kindness and friendship.
Avoid the "I" Traps
There are a few things that seem like good ideas but usually fail.
- Ice: It will be a puddle before the first kid finishes their turn.
- Ipad/iPhone: Most schools have strict rules against these, and honestly, it’s not "showing" anything other than a screen.
- Important stuff: Don't send the heirloom Ivory carving your great-grandmother brought from overseas. It’ll get dropped. It’ll get lost. It’ll get sticky.
Making the "I" Presentation Pop
Once you've picked the object, do a "dry run" at the breakfast table. Have your child tell you three things about it.
- What is it?
- Where did it come from?
- Why do they like it?
If they’re bringing an Inch-tape (measuring tape), have them measure your toast. If it’s an Inflatable toy, let them show how it squishes. The more "doing" there is, the less "staring" there will be from the other kids.
According to Dr. Alice Sterling Honig, a professor emerita of child development at Syracuse University, show and tell is a critical milestone for developing "narrative competence." It’s the first time kids have to structure a story for an audience. Using a slightly unusual "I" word—like Imprint (show a fossil or a handprint in clay)—gives them a stronger narrative hook than a standard toy.
Thinking Outside the (Toy) Box
Let’s talk about Ingredients. This is a sleeper hit for show and tell. Bring in a jar of Italian seasoning. The kids can smell it. It’s sensory. It’s different. Or perhaps an Infuser for tea. It looks like a little space capsule or a cage. It’s mechanical, it’s visual, and it’s definitely not something every other kid is going to have in their backpack.
👉 See also: Why Everyone Is Still Obsessing Over Maybelline SuperStay Skin Tint
Then there’s the Imaginary friend. Okay, this is a bit of a gamble. Some teachers love the creativity of a child "holding" an invisible friend and describing them. Others might find it a bit disruptive. Use your best judgment on that one, but for a high-creativity kid, it’s a legendary move.
Real-World Examples of "I" Success
I once saw a kid bring in an Inner tube from a bike tire. He talked about how it holds air and what happens when it gets a "pouch" (a puncture). The class was mesmerized. Why? Because it was something they’d all seen but never really looked at. It wasn't a "thing start with I," it was a piece of the world explained.
Another great one was an Incubator thermometer. The child’s family raised chickens. Bringing in that tiny piece of equipment allowed her to talk about life cycles and heat and waiting for eggs to hatch.
Quick Reference List for Last-Minute Panic
If you’re reading this at 7:00 AM on a Tuesday and the bus is coming in twenty minutes, here is your "no-fail" list. Grab one and go.
- Ice tray: Plastic, durable, and easy to explain.
- Icon: A small religious or cultural symbol.
- Index card: Write a "secret code" on it.
- Insoles: Pull them out of a shoe. Gross? Maybe. Interesting? Totally.
- Instrument: Any whistle, bell, or shaker.
- Interlocking blocks: Standard LEGOs, but use the "big" word.
- Ivy leaf: Pluck it from the garden.
Actionable Steps for a Better Show and Tell
Before you shove that I-object into a backpack, do these three things to ensure success:
- Check the "Vibe": Does the object match your child's personality? A shy kid might prefer a "shield" like an I-themed book to read from, while an outgoing kid might want a "prop" like an Inflatable sword.
- Label Everything: Seriously. Use a Sharpie. "I" items like Insects (plastic ones) tend to look like everyone else's.
- Focus on the Phonics: Remind your child that "I" makes two sounds. Ask them which one their object makes. This little bit of prep makes them look like a total rockstar when the teacher asks.
Show and tell isn't about having the most expensive toy. It's about that tiny moment of connection between a child and their peers. Picking a thoughtful "I" item—something that invites curiosity rather than just a "cool" glance—is the easiest way to make that happen. Skip the iPad. Grab the Incandescent bulb or the Ice cream scoop. Your kid (and their teacher) will thank you.
To make the morning even smoother, try to find a small box or bag for the item. It creates a sense of "mystery" when they first stand up. They can ask, "I start with the letter I, and I help you eat something cold... what am I?" It turns the presentation into a game, and in the world of five-year-olds, games are everything.
Check your kitchen junk drawer right now. I bet there’s an Inbus key (Allen wrench) or an Instruction manual for something weird in there. Even the most boring "I" item can be the star of the show if you give your child the right words to describe it. Forget the "Ultimate List" mindset and just look for something that tells a story. That’s where the real magic of show and tell happens.