You’re standing in the Silent Library, the air thick with the smell of old parchment and necrotic magic, and you’ve got a choice to make. It’s the climax of Act 2 in Baldur’s Gate 3. Shadowheart is clutching the Spear of Night, staring down the Nightsong, and the game basically asks you: do you let her fulfill her lifelong dream, or do you talk her out of it? Honestly, deciding if should Shadowheart become a Dark Justiciar is one of the hardest narrative pivots Larian Studios ever put in the game. It isn't just about a cool armor set or a new title. It’s about whether you want to save her soul or watch her become a hollowed-out weapon for a goddess who doesn't actually care about her.
Most players feel the pressure. Shadowheart has been talking about this since the moment you pulled her out of that nautiloid pod. She wants this. Or she thinks she wants this because Shar has spent decades gaslighting her into believing her only value lies in loss and darkness. If you’re playing a "good" campaign, the choice feels obvious, but if you’re looking for raw power or a darker narrative arc, the Justiciar path is tempting.
What Really Happens if Shadowheart Becomes a Dark Justiciar
Let’s get into the weeds of the mechanics and the story consequences. If you let her kill Dame Aylin, everything changes. Instantly.
First, the immediate fallout: Last Light Inn is basically doomed. Without the Nightsong’s protection, the Shadow Curse swallows the sanctuary whole. Isobel dies or is captured, and almost every NPC you’ve spent twenty hours helping—Dammon, the tiefling refugees, Wulbren, Barcus—will either die or turn into shadow-cursed undead. It’s a bloodbath. You lose access to several questlines in Act 3 because, well, the quest givers are all dead.
From a gear perspective, the rewards are actually pretty insane. Shadowheart receives the Shar’s Spear of Evening. This thing is a beast. It gives her "Shar’s Blessing," making her immune to being blinded, and she gets a unique ability called "Shar’s Darkness" which allows her to create a cloud of magical dark while dealing extra damage to anyone inside it. She also gets the Dark Justiciar Half-Plate (Very Rare version), which provides huge buffs to her Stealth and Advantage on Constitution Saving Throws. If you’re building a specialized "Darkness" party—using Warlocks with Devil’s Sight—a Dark Justiciar Shadowheart is arguably the most powerful version of the character.
But there’s a catch. A big one.
👉 See also: Walkthrough Final Fantasy X-2: How to Actually Get That 100% Completion
Her personality shifts. She becomes colder. The "humor" she had, that little bit of snarky warmth, starts to evaporate. She fully commits to the Church of Shar, and while she’s technically your ally, she belongs to her goddess first. If you’re romancing her, get ready for some heartache. She doesn't break up with you immediately, but she makes it clear that Shar comes before any mortal love. It’s a lonely path.
The Moral Weight of the Nightsong Decision
The debate over whether should Shadowheart become a Dark Justiciar often ignores the psychological manipulation at play. Shar is the goddess of loss. She thrives on taking things away. By forcing Shadowheart to kill the Nightsong, Shar is making her destroy a literal piece of Selûne—but she’s also making her destroy her own past.
If you choose the path of the Selunite (sparing the Nightsong), you find out that Shadowheart’s memories were stolen. She wasn't born a Sharran. She was kidnapped as a child. If she becomes a Justiciar, she never truly reconciles with that. She just buries it deeper under layers of religious zealotry.
"Loss is all we have."
That’s the Sharran mantra. If you follow this through to Act 3, her personal quest ends in a way that feels objectively tragic, even if she’s technically "successful." She becomes the Cloistered High Priestess of the House of Grief, but she’s essentially a shell of the person she was.
✨ Don't miss: Stick War: Why This Flash Classic Still Dominates Strategy Gaming
Why You Might Actually Want to Go Dark
I’m not going to sit here and tell you it’s a "bad" way to play. Baldur’s Gate 3 is a masterpiece of player agency. Sometimes, a dark playthrough is what the doctor ordered.
- The Tactical Advantage: As mentioned, the Spear of Evening is one of the best weapons in the game for a Cleric or a Paladin multiclass. The ability to cast Darkness as a weapon is a game-changer for certain boss fights.
- The Narrative Depth: Seeing the "Bad Ending" for a character is part of the experience. The voice acting by Jennifer English during the Dark Justiciar path is haunting. It’s a different kind of performance—more rigid, more detached.
- The Evil Run: If you’ve already recruited Minthara and you’re leaning into a "Burn the World" vibe, having a Dark Justiciar at your side fits the aesthetic perfectly. It feels weird to have a redeemed Shadowheart in a party full of murder-hobos.
One thing people get wrong is thinking they can "fix" her later. Once that spear goes through the Nightsong, the bridge is burned. You can’t turn her back to Selûne in Act 3. You’ve committed to the darkness, and the game respects that choice by locking you into the consequences.
The Selûnite Alternative: Sparing the Nightsong
If you’re still on the fence about whether should Shadowheart become a Dark Justiciar, you have to look at what you get on the other side. Sparing the Nightsong feels like the "canonical" heroic path.
Shadowheart throws the spear away. She defies the goddess who has controlled her entire life. It’s a moment of incredible bravery. Mechanically, she loses the Spear of Evening but eventually gains the Spear of Night/Selûne’s Spear of Night, which is a powerful weapon in its own right, granting Truesight and high-level moon spells.
More importantly, she starts to remember who she is. Her hair changes (the iconic white hair look), and she begins a journey of healing. You get to meet her parents in Act 3. You get a romance that is actually fulfilling and grounded in mutual respect rather than religious servitude. You also get the Nightsong as an ally in the final battle, and let’s be honest, Dame Aylin is a powerhouse who can carry some of the hardest fights in the game.
🔗 Read more: Solitaire Games Free Online Klondike: What Most People Get Wrong
Comparing the Two Paths
| Feature | Dark Justiciar Path | Selûnite (Redeemed) Path |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Weapon | Shar's Spear of Evening (Blindness Immunity) | Selûne’s Spear of Night (Wisdom Saves/Moonbeam) |
| Last Light Inn | Everyone dies. Total annihilation. | Everyone lives (if you saved them). |
| Shadowheart's Hair | Stays black / braided. | Changes to white / shorter style. |
| Romance Outcome | Cold, distant, goddess comes first. | Warm, intimate, hopeful future. |
| Act 3 Allies | Viconia DeVir and the Sharran Cloister. | Dame Aylin and Isobel. |
The Verdict on the Dark Justiciar Path
So, should Shadowheart become a Dark Justiciar?
If this is your first playthrough, honestly? No. You miss out on too much. You lose too many NPCs, you lose the emotional payoff of her redemption, and you lose the chance to see her actually happy. The "good" path provides a much more robust amount of content in Act 3.
However, if you are on a second or third run, or if you are specifically playing a character who values power at any cost, do it. The game becomes a different beast when the Shadow Curse isn't lifted. The atmosphere of Act 3 changes when you’re leading a cult rather than a group of heroes.
It’s worth noting that your approval rating with her matters, but even with high approval, the game gives her the choice if you stay silent. If you’ve been a "good" person throughout the game, she might actually choose to spare the Nightsong herself without you saying a word. If you’ve encouraged her darker instincts, she’ll kill the Nightsong without hesitation.
Actionable Next Steps for Your Playthrough
If you’re currently at the Verge of the Shadows and can’t decide, here is how you should handle the next ten minutes of gameplay:
- Save your game. This is the biggest branching point in the entire game. You want a way back if you regret the outcome.
- Check your inventory. Make sure Shadowheart has the Spear of Night equipped or in her bags. She can’t complete the ritual without it.
- Think about your Act 3 goals. Do you want to see the Tiefling story conclude? If yes, you cannot let her become a Dark Justiciar.
- Consider your party composition. If you rely on Dammon for gear (like the Flawed Helldusk set), buy everything you need before entering the Shadowfell, because he won't survive the night if Shadowheart turns.
- Listen to the dialogue. Pay attention to what the Nightsong says to her. She mentions Shadowheart’s past, the "scent of orchids," and her childhood. If those details interest you, the Selûnite path is the way to go to uncover those mysteries.
Ultimately, the choice defines who Shadowheart is. Is she Jenuelle, the girl who loved flowers and animals, or is she the Dark Justiciar, the nameless shadow of a dying goddess? The spear is in your hands—well, hers—but you’re the one who has to live with the world that’s left behind.