Look, I get it. You've probably spent the last three days staring at your fantasy lineup, moving Jayden Daniels in and out of that QB1 slot until your thumb is sore. It’s that classic fantasy football paralysis. On one hand, you’ve got the reigning NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year who basically broke the game in 2024. On the other hand, 2025 was—to put it mildly—a total mess for the Washington Commanders.
If you’re asking "should I start Jayden Daniels" right now, you aren’t just looking at a box score. You’re trying to figure out which version of the kid is showing up. Is it the dual-threat monster who put up 31 total touchdowns in his debut season? Or is it the guy we saw hobbling through a hamstring strain and a dislocated non-throwing elbow during that brutal 2025 stretch?
🔗 Read more: Tour de France Purse Money: Why the World's Toughest Race Pays Surprisingly Little
Honestly, the answer isn't as simple as "start your studs," even though we love to say that.
The Reality of the Jayden Daniels Sophomore Slump
Let's talk about the elephant in the room. The 2025 season was a reality check. After Washington's wild ride to the NFC runner-up spot in '24, the wheels kinda fell off. Daniels went from a 69% completion rate down to about 60.6%. That hurts. He threw for only 1,262 yards in the seven games he actually finished healthy.
But here is the thing: the rushing floor is still there. Even in a "bad" year, Daniels averaged nearly 40 rushing yards per game. In the world of fantasy, that’s the ultimate cheat code. It's basically like starting every game with a free passing touchdown already in your pocket.
What the Matchup Actually Tells Us
Washington is currently sitting with the No. 7 pick in the 2026 draft. They’ve had a "season from hell," as some RotoWire analysts are calling it. But when you look at the defensive splits, there’s a weird trend. Daniels actually played better against aggressive, high-blitz teams than he did against soft zones.
If the defense he's facing this week relies on a heavy pass rush, he’s going to scramble. And as PFF notes, a Jayden Daniels scramble is worth twice as much as a designed run. He had a 31.7% scramble rate in college, and while he’s tried to be more of a "pocket passer" to protect his body, he can't help himself when the lane opens up.
Why You’re Hesitating (And Why You Might Be Right)
You've seen the injury reports. The knee sprain in Week 2, the hamstring in Week 7, and that nasty elbow dislocation in Week 9. It’s been a lot. If you have a "safe" veteran like Dak Prescott or even a surging Trevor Lawrence, it is tempting to bench the kid.
- Durability concerns: He’s 210 pounds. He takes hits.
- The "Kingsbury Effect": With Kliff Kingsbury stepping away, the offensive rhythm has been... let's say "chaotic."
- The Supporting Cast: Terry McLaurin is still a beast, but with Zach Ertz out with an ACL tear and Deebo Samuel’s future in the air, the targets are getting thin.
But you have to weigh that against the ceiling. We are talking about a guy who had three games of 37+ fantasy points in his rookie year. You don't bench that kind of upside unless you have a surefire top-5 alternative.
The Verdict on Your Lineup
Basically, if you are in a 10-team league and you happened to snag a backup like Drake Maye (who was the steal of the 2025 season), you might actually have a conversation here. Maye finished as the QB2 in many formats last year.
However, in most 12-team leagues, you probably drafted Jayden Daniels in the top 40 because you wanted that 1-of-1 athleticism. You didn't draft him to play it safe. You drafted him to win you the week.
📖 Related: Purdue vs Houston Basketball: What Really Happened in That Sweet 16 Heartbreaker
The Commanders have roughly $76M in cap space heading into the 2026 offseason, and while that doesn't help you this second, it shows the organization is still all-in on him. They aren't going to "limit" him now. They need to see him finish strong.
How to Make the Final Call
Stop looking at the projected points for five minutes. Look at the weather and the spread. If Washington is a heavy underdog, that’s actually good for you. It means more garbage time, more desperation scrambles, and more deep shots to McLaurin.
If you're still on the fence, check the late-week practice reports. If he’s a full participant by Friday, you play him. Period. Don't overthink the "sophomore slump" narrative so much that you miss a 30-point explosion from a guy who can outrun 90% of the linebackers in this league.
Actionable Next Steps
- Check the Blitz Rate: Look up the opposing defensive coordinator. If they blitz more than 30% of the time, start Daniels. He thrives in the chaos.
- Verify the Offensive Line: If the Commanders are missing more than one starting tackle this week, downgrade him slightly; his "pressure-to-sack" rate was a bit high at 18.6% last year.
- Monitor the Weather: High winds kill his deep ball accuracy, which is where his "hidden" points often come from.
- Trust the Rushing: If you need a "floor" of 15 points, he’s almost certain to give it to you just with his legs and short dump-offs to Chris Rodriguez Jr. or whoever is lining up at RB this week.
Make the move, lock the lineup, and stop refreshing the page. He's too talented to stay down for long.