You've seen the headlines when the S&P 500 starts to tank. People panic. Portfolios bleed red. But then there’s that one guy on Reddit or X boasting about a 20% gain while everyone else is losing their shirt. Usually, they're playing with short exchange traded funds. It sounds like a cheat code, honestly. If the market goes down, your investment goes up. Simple, right? Well, not exactly.
Shorting the market used to be something reserved for the big dogs at hedge funds with massive margin accounts. Now, anyone with a brokerage app can do it. You just buy a ticker like SH (ProShares Short S&P500) and suddenly you're rooting for the world to burn. But here’s the thing: these funds are basically ticking time bombs if you don't know how the math works under the hood. They aren't "buy and hold" assets. If you hold them too long, you might lose money even if the market eventually drops.
How Short Exchange Traded Funds Actually Function
Most people think of an ETF as a basket of stocks. You buy VOO, you own a piece of Apple, Microsoft, and the rest. Short exchange traded funds—often called inverse ETFs—don’t work like that. They don't own stocks. Instead, they use derivatives like swap agreements and futures contracts to track the inverse of a specific index's daily performance.
If the S&P 500 drops 1% today, a standard inverse ETF should rise about 1%. If the index goes up 1%, your fund drops 1%. It's a mirror image. This is great for a day trade. It’s fantastic if you’re hedging a specific event, like an earnings report or a Fed announcement. But the word "daily" in the prospectus is the most important part of the whole document.
The Daily Reset Trap
Here is where things get weird. Most of these funds reset their exposure every single day. This creates a phenomenon called "volatility decay" or "compounding risk." Imagine a scenario where the market is choppy.
Day one: The index drops 10%. Your short ETF goes up 10%.
Day two: The index rises 10.1% to get back to where it started.
Because of the way the math compounds, your ETF won't be back at its starting price. You’ll likely be down. In a volatile, sideways market, these funds bleed value. It's like a leaky bucket. You’re fighting against time and the very nature of how the fund rebalances itself at the end of every trading session.
✨ Don't miss: Jerry Jones 19.2 Billion Net Worth: Why Everyone is Getting the Math Wrong
Why the Pros Use Them (and Why Amateurs Get Burned)
Institutional traders use short exchange traded funds as a surgical tool. They aren't trying to get rich off them over a three-year period. They use them for "tactical hedging."
Let's say you own a bunch of tech stocks and you're worried about a specific week of high inflation data. You don't want to sell your stocks because you'd trigger capital gains taxes. Instead, you buy an inverse ETF like PSQ (ProShares Short QQQ) to offset potential losses for a few days. Once the news passes, you sell the ETF. You’ve basically bought insurance.
Amateurs do the opposite. They see a bear market coming and decide to hold an inverse ETF for six months. This is usually a disaster. Because the stock market has a historical upward bias, you are betting against the house. Over long stretches, the decay eats your principal. Even in a flat market, you lose.
The Danger of Leverage
Then there's the "ultra" stuff. Funds like SQQQ or SPXS offer 3x inverse leverage.
Crazy.
If the Nasdaq 100 drops 2% in a day, SQQQ jumps 6%. But if the Nasdaq goes up 2%, you just wiped out 6% of your position in hours. These are high-octane gambling tools. If you leave a 3x leveraged short ETF in your account and forget about it during a bull run, your balance can literally head toward zero. Fast.
Real World Examples: The 2022 Bear Market
2022 was a rare year where short exchange traded funds actually worked for longer durations because the downtrend was so consistent. Usually, markets move in "sawtooth" patterns—up, down, up, down. But 2022 saw a steady grind lower. If you held something like BITI (ProShares Short Bitcoin Strategy ETF) during the crypto crash, you did well.
🔗 Read more: Missouri Paycheck Tax Calculator: What Most People Get Wrong
But look at the 2020 COVID crash. The market fell 30% in a month. If you bought an inverse ETF at the bottom, thinking the world was ending, you got absolutely incinerated during the fastest recovery in history. The snap-back was so violent that the daily reset of the short funds couldn't keep up with the losses.
Technical Limitations and Costs
You also have to look at the expense ratios. These aren't cheap Vanguard funds that cost 0.03%. Because the managers have to constantly trade complex derivatives and swaps, the fees are high. We're talking 0.95% or more.
- Counterparty Risk: Since these funds use swaps, they rely on a bank (the counterparty) to fulfill the contract. If the bank fails, the ETF could have issues.
- Liquidity: In a massive market crash, the "spread" between what you can buy and sell for can widen, making it expensive to get out of your position.
- Tax Efficiency: These are not tax-efficient. Most gains are short-term, meaning they are taxed at your ordinary income rate rather than the lower long-term capital gains rate.
The Psychology of Shorting
It feels "smart" to be a bear. There’s an intellectual allure to predicting a crash. But the math of the universe is against you when you use short exchange traded funds.
Think about it. A stock can only go down 100%, but it can go up infinitely. When you're "long" (buying stocks), your risk is capped and your reward is unlimited. When you're "short" through these ETFs, you're fighting a mechanism designed for 24-hour cycles. You have to be right about the direction AND right about the timing. If you're right about the direction but the timing is off by a month, the decay might still kill your trade.
Actionable Steps for Using Short ETFs Safely
If you’re still dead-set on using these, don’t just wing it.
💡 You might also like: Why Amazon Stock is Down Today: What Most People Get Wrong
First, never make these a core part of your retirement portfolio. They belong in a "trading" bucket—maybe 1% to 5% of your total liquid net worth at most. Treat them like a hedge, not a lottery ticket.
Second, check the "Daily Target" in the fund's name. If it says daily, you should probably be out of the position by the time the closing bell rings. If you hold it overnight, you're officially a gambler, not a hedger.
Third, use stop-loss orders. Because these things can gap up or down so quickly, you need an automated way to get out if the market turns against you. There is no "waiting for it to come back." With an inverse ETF, it might never come back.
Finally, watch the "borrow" cost and the trend. Shorting works best when the market is in a confirmed downtrend, staying below its 200-day moving average. Trying to "catch the top" of a raging bull market with a short ETF is a great way to lose money while everyone else is celebrating.
Monitor the VIX (Volatility Index). When the VIX is extremely high, the decay on inverse ETFs accelerates. High volatility is the enemy of the daily reset. Wait for "calm" selling if you're going to play the downside.
Basically, keep your eyes open. These funds are sharp knives. They can help you carve out a profit in a bad market, but if you grab them by the blade, you're going to need a medic.
Keep your holding periods short.
Watch the fees.
Understand that "daily" means daily.
If you can do that, you're ahead of 90% of the people trading these things.