Long before he was kicking down doors on S.W.A.T. or charming the world as Derek Morgan on Criminal Minds, Shemar Moore was a skinny kid with a big smile in Genoa City. Most people forget that. They see the action star and think he just appeared out of thin air. Honestly, it was The Young and the Restless that built the foundation for everything he’s done since.
He wasn't just another soap actor. He was Malcolm Winters.
The Arrival of a Heartthrob
In May 1994, Malcolm Winters rolled into town. He was the "bad boy" half-brother of the straight-laced Neil Winters, played by the late, great Kristoff St. John. Back then, Moore was a former college athlete and model who hadn’t really acted before. He's often joked in interviews—most recently on The Talk—that he hadn’t even hit puberty yet when he started. He was nervous. Terrified, actually.
He didn't have the "actor's training" some of the veterans had. But he had presence. You’ve seen it—that effortless charisma that makes people stop scrolling. On Y&R, he played a photographer for Jabot Cosmetics, a role that felt weirdly meta given his real-life modeling background.
The dynamic between Malcolm and Neil became the heartbeat of the show’s diversity. It wasn't just "soap drama." It was a complex, sometimes messy exploration of brotherhood and rivalry.
✨ Don't miss: Cuba Gooding Jr OJ: Why the Performance Everyone Hated Was Actually Genius
The Scandal That Rocked Genoa City
If you want to talk about The Young and the Restless history, you have to talk about the Drucilla incident. It's the storyline that defined Malcolm Winters.
Basically, Drucilla (Victoria Rowell) was high on cold medication. She mistook Malcolm for her husband, Neil. One night of confused identity led to a pregnancy. For years, the truth about Lily Winters' paternity was the ticking time bomb of the show.
- The Reveal: When it finally came out that Malcolm was Lily’s biological father, it shattered the Winters family.
- The Fallout: It created a rift between brothers that lasted for decades of screen time.
- The Nuance: Moore played Malcolm not as a villain, but as a man torn between his love for his brother and his right to be a father.
It was heavy stuff. This wasn't just "abs and smiles." It was raw, emotional acting that eventually landed Moore a Daytime Emmy Award for Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Drama Series in 2000.
The Brotherhood Beyond the Screen
You can't talk about Shemar Moore on The Young and the Restless without talking about Kristoff St. John. They weren't just co-stars. They were brothers.
🔗 Read more: Greatest Rock and Roll Singers of All Time: Why the Legends Still Own the Mic
When Kristoff passed away in 2019, it hit Shemar hard. He’s been very open about the fact that Kristoff mentored him. He says that without Neil Winters, there’s no Malcolm. Without Malcolm, there’s no Shemar Moore. Kristoff taught him how to be a professional, how to hit his marks, and how to handle the sudden fame of being "the sexiest man on TV."
Whenever the show calls, Shemar answers. He came back in 2014, 2019 for the tribute to Kristoff, and again in 2023 for the show's 50th anniversary. He doesn't have to do it. He’s a massive primetime star. But he does it because he knows where he started.
Why He Left (and Why He Keeps Coming Back)
By 2005, Moore had outgrown daytime. He wanted to see if he could make it in "Hollywood," as if he wasn't already in it. He took a huge risk. He left a steady paycheck for the uncertainty of pilot season.
It paid off. Criminal Minds happened.
💡 You might also like: Ted Nugent State of Shock: Why This 1979 Album Divides Fans Today
But soap fans are a different breed. They don't forget. They still see him as Malcolm. Even when he’s playing Hondo on S.W.A.T., there’s a segment of the audience that’s just waiting for him to mention Genoa City.
The role was briefly recast with Darius McCrary (Eddie Winslow from Family Matters) from 2009 to 2011. McCrary is a talented guy, but it just didn't click the same way. The fans wanted Shemar. There’s a specific energy he brings—a mix of vulnerability and "cool"—that’s hard to replicate.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Aspiring Actors
If you’re looking to revisit the Malcolm Winters era or you're an actor trying to study how a "soap star" successfully transitions to primetime, here’s the blueprint:
- Watch the 2000 Emmy Reel: Find the clips from the Lily paternity reveal. It’s a masterclass in controlled emotion.
- Respect the Medium: Moore never looked down on soaps. He treated Y&R like it was Shakespeare, and that’s why the audience respected him back.
- Study the Chemistry: Notice how he used his body language to differentiate between Malcolm the "cool photographer" and Malcolm the "hurting brother."
The legacy of Malcolm Winters isn't just about the plot twists or the romance with Olivia or Sofia. It's about a young man who used a "starting role" to build a legendary career, all while maintaining a deep, genuine respect for the people who helped him get there.
Whether he’s on a red carpet or a soundstage, Shemar Moore carries a piece of Genoa City with him. And honestly? We wouldn’t have it any other way.
To truly understand the impact, go back and watch the 2019 tribute episodes for Neil Winters. It’s some of the most honest television you’ll ever see, largely because the grief on Shemar’s face wasn't acting—it was real.