The experiment in Cleveland has reached its first major crossroads. Honestly, if you’d told anyone two years ago that Shedeur Sanders would be a fifth-round pick fighting for a starting job on a 5-12 Browns team, they probably would’ve laughed you out of the room. But here we are. It’s January 2026, and the chatter surrounding Shedeur Sanders latest news isn’t about Heisman trophies or Boulder hype anymore. It’s about survival in a league that eats young quarterbacks for breakfast.
The Reality of the Rookie Wall
Let’s look at the numbers because they don't lie, even if they're a bit ugly. Sanders stepped into the vacuum left by a Joe Flacco trade and a struggling Dillon Gabriel. He started the final seven games of the 2025 season.
The result? A 3-4 record as a starter.
He threw for 1,400 yards, which isn't terrible for seven starts. However, the 10 interceptions compared to just 7 touchdowns tell a story of a kid trying to do way too much behind a shaky offensive line. He was sacked 23 times in that short span. Imagine getting hit that often and still trying to maintain your "Grown Man" composure. It's tough. You've seen the clips—he still has that lightning-quick release, but the "situational awareness" GM Andrew Berry keeps mentioning is clearly a work in progress.
Basically, Shedeur is learning that NFL windows close faster than a laptop at 5:00 PM on a Friday.
🔗 Read more: Buddy Hield Sacramento Kings: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
Why the Browns GM is Playing it Cool
Earlier this month, Andrew Berry held his end-of-season press conference. He didn't exactly hand Shedeur the keys to the city. When asked if Sanders is the guy for 2026, Berry was noncommittal. "We’re going to do our work on the quarterback market," he said. That’s GM-speak for we might draft someone at No. 6 or sign a veteran who won't turn the ball over three times against the Bears.
It’s a weird spot. Sanders has shown flashes. He led a gritty win against the Raiders in his first start. He looked like a legitimate star for exactly one half against the Titans, throwing for 364 yards and three scores. But then you have the Baltimore game where he posted a 13.5 passer rating. You can’t win in the AFC North with a 13.5 rating. You just can't.
The Coaching Carousel Factor
The biggest hurdle right now isn't actually Shedeur’s arm. It’s the fact that Kevin Stefanski is gone. The Browns fired their head coach, which means Shedeur is about to learn his second or third offensive system in less than twelve months. For a young QB, that is usually a death sentence for development.
The new coach—whoever that ends up being—didn't draft Shedeur. They have no "ego investment" in making him work. If the new regime wants to use that 6th overall pick on a fresh start, Shedeur becomes one of the most talented backups in the league overnight.
💡 You might also like: Why the March Madness 2022 Bracket Still Haunts Your Sports Betting Group Chat
NIL Wealth vs. NFL Poverty (Relatively Speaking)
There’s a hilarious irony in Shedeur’s current situation. Most fifth-round picks are grinding because they need the paycheck. Shedeur? He walked into the Cleveland locker room with more career earnings from NIL deals than half the veterans on the roster.
- College Earnings: Estimates put his NIL valuation at Colorado north of $4 million.
- Draft Reality: As a fifth-rounder (No. 144 overall), his base salary is a fraction of what he was making in Boulder.
Does that change his hunger? People love to claim he’s "disinterested" or "unprofessional"—rumors that allegedly caused his draft slide from a projected first-rounder to Day 3. But if you watch the film from the Buffalo Bills game in December, you see a guy taking hits and getting back up. You don't do that if you're just there for the vibes.
What Really Happened with the "Draft Slide"?
Everyone wants to know why he fell. It’s the million-dollar question. In the spring of 2025, the narrative was that he was a lock for the top ten. Then the Combine happened. Anonymous scouts started leaking stories about him being "aloof" in interviews.
Then there was the sack rate.
📖 Related: Mizzou 2024 Football Schedule: What Most People Get Wrong
At Colorado, he took 54 sacks in 2024. Scouts blamed him for holding the ball too long. In Cleveland, he’s doing the same thing. He trusts his talent so much that he refuses to throw the ball away, believing he can escape. In the PAC-12 (and later Big 12), he could. Against Myles Garrett in practice? Not so much.
What’s Next: The 2026 Roadmap
If you're a fan of the kid, the next few months are going to be stressful. The Browns have Deshaun Watson’s contract still looming like a dark cloud, though everyone knows that ship has mostly sailed. They have the 6th pick. They have a new coaching search.
Here is what Shedeur needs to do to keep his job:
- Master the "Boring" Play: He needs to learn that a 3-yard checkdown is better than a 10-yard sack.
- Win the Locker Room: With a new coach coming in, he has to be the first one in the building. No more "Grown" branding until the wins outpace the picks.
- Survive Free Agency: If Cleveland signs a mid-tier vet like a Sam Darnold or a Geno Smith type, Shedeur is officially in a "bridge" situation.
Honestly, Shedeur Sanders is the most interesting "project" in football right now. He’s got the pedigree, the money, and the arm. What he doesn't have is a guarantee.
To really track where he's headed, keep an eye on the Browns' offensive coordinator hire. If they bring in a "West Coast" system guy who demands quick timing and rhythm, Shedeur will have to fundamentally change how he plays. If they go with a vertical, play-action heavy scheme, he might actually thrive. Either way, the "Rookie" label is about to fall off, and the "Starter" label is currently held on by Scotch tape.
Check the 2026 NFL Draft order as it finalizes after the Super Bowl; if Cleveland stays at No. 6 and doesn't trade down, Shedeur’s time as the "future" might be shorter than we thought. For now, he's the incumbent, but in the NFL, that and five bucks will get you a coffee.