Walk into any sports bar in Northeast Ohio right now and you’ll see it. The orange and brown. The mesh. But the name on the back isn't Kosar or Mayfield. It's Sanders. Specifically, the Shedeur Sanders jersey Browns fans have been scooping up since he landed in Cleveland as a fifth-round steal. It’s kinda wild how fast things move in this league. One minute he’s the polarizing "Prime Time" heir at Colorado, and the next, he’s the guy keeping the seat warm—or maybe taking the throne—in the Dawg Pound.
Honestly, nobody expected this. When the 2025 NFL Draft rolled around, the "experts" had Shedeur going much higher. Then he slipped. And slipped. Until Andrew Berry and the Browns pulled the trigger at pick 144. Now, heading into 2026, that jersey isn't just a fashion statement. It’s a symbol of a massive quarterback identity crisis in Cleveland.
The Number 12 Shift: What Most People Get Wrong
If you’re looking for a Shedeur Sanders jersey Browns edition, you might notice something different right away. He isn't wearing the number 2. He famously wore 2 at Jackson State and Colorado, but in Cleveland, he made a pivot. He’s rocking number 12.
Why the change? During the Rookie Premiere in May 2025, Shedeur was pretty vocal about it. He basically told everyone, "Don't call me 2 anymore." It was about a fresh start. A lot of fans think he chose 12 because of some hidden meaning or a nod to a legend. In reality, it was about carving out a professional identity that wasn't just "Coach Prime’s son." He wanted to leave the "2Legendary" brand in the college ranks and start something new in the pros.
📖 Related: Why the March Madness 2022 Bracket Still Haunts Your Sports Betting Group Chat
Where to Actually Find One
Right now, the demand is surprisingly high for a guy who was a fifth-rounder. You can find the Shedeur Sanders jersey Browns version on Fanatics and the official NFL Shop for about $129.99. They have the standard Nike Game jerseys, but if you want the "Alpha Dawg" version or the 1946 collection alternate, you're looking at closer to $170.
People are buying them. Like, a lot. There was even a viral video of an elderly Browns fan breaking down in tears after getting a Sanders jersey for Christmas. It sounds crazy given his rookie stats, but that's the power of the Sanders name.
The 2026 QB Room: Sanders vs. The Contract
Let’s get real about the situation on the field. Buying the jersey is one thing; seeing it on the field as a starter is another. The Browns are in a weird spot. They still have Deshaun Watson and his massive $230 million contract looming like a dark cloud. Watson is entering the final year of that deal in 2026.
👉 See also: Mizzou 2024 Football Schedule: What Most People Get Wrong
Here’s the breakdown of the current room:
- Deshaun Watson: Still on the roster because cutting him is a financial nightmare.
- Shedeur Sanders: Started the final seven games of 2025.
- Dillon Gabriel: Also in the mix after being drafted in the third round.
Shedeur’s rookie numbers weren't exactly Hall of Fame material. He threw for 1,400 yards, 7 touchdowns, and 10 interceptions. He went 3-4 as a starter. But—and this is a big but—he was playing behind a decimated line and didn't get first-team reps until late in the year. Analysts like Mel Kiper Jr. are still banging the drum for him, saying he should be the Week 1 starter in 2026.
Why the Jersey Still Matters (Even if He’s QB2)
You’d think fans would be hesitant to buy the jersey of a guy who might be a bridge quarterback. But Cleveland fans are different. They love an underdog, and despite the "Prime" lineage, Shedeur became an underdog the moment he fell to the fifth round.
✨ Don't miss: Current Score of the Steelers Game: Why the 30-6 Texans Blowout Changed Everything
There’s a segment of the fan base that wants to move on from the Watson era so badly they’ll latch onto anything with potential. Shedeur has that "it" factor. He’s got the swagger. Even when he’s struggling, he looks like a leader. Plus, let's be honest, the jersey just looks good. The brown Nike tricot fabric with the orange 12 pops.
The New Coach Factor
The Browns fired Kevin Stefanski after the 2025 season. As of mid-January 2026, the team is hunting for a new head coach. Names like John Harbaugh and Mike McDaniel have been floating around. Whoever takes the job is going to decide if that Shedeur Sanders jersey Browns fans are wearing stays relevant or becomes a back-of-the-closet relic. If a coach like Harbaugh comes in, he might want his own guy, especially since the Browns have the 6th and 24th picks in the 2026 draft.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Collectors
If you’re on the fence about picking up the jersey or just following the Shedeur saga, here is how you should play it:
- Watch the 2026 Draft: If the Browns use that #6 pick on a quarterback like Fernando Mendoza or Ty Simpson, Shedeur’s time as a potential starter is likely over. The jersey becomes a "cool era" souvenir rather than a long-term investment.
- Check the Number: Make sure you're getting the official #12. Some third-party sites are still selling #2 mockups from before he officially chose his pro number. Don't get caught with the wrong digits.
- Follow the Coaching Hire: A coach who likes a mobile, "point guard" style QB will favor Sanders. A traditional "pro-style" coach might lean toward a veteran bridge or a high-round rookie.
- Monitor the Resale: Surprisingly, the "Draft Night" editions of his jersey are already becoming collector's items. If you see one of those, grab it.
The Shedeur Sanders jersey Browns hype isn't just about football; it's about hope. In Cleveland, that's a dangerous thing, but it's all the fans have right now. Whether he's the future or just a fascinating footnote, number 12 is the most interesting jersey in the city.