If you’ve spent any time scrolling through reality TV blogs or watching Love & Hip Hop: Miami, you know that Shay Johnson doesn't usually do things the quiet way. But when she announced her pregnancy back in early 2022, the "Buckeey" we all knew from Flavor of Love suddenly became a master of mystery. For months, the internet was basically a digital detective agency. Everyone wanted to know: who is Shay Johnson baby daddy?
People were throwing out names like they were winning lottery numbers. Some swore it was Lil Scrappy—mostly because Momma Dee was acting like a proud grandmother at the baby shower. Others thought it might be a secret athlete or a wealthy businessman hidden away in Atlanta.
Honestly, the truth turned out to be much more complicated than a simple name reveal. It wasn't just about a name; it was about a relationship that would eventually explode on national television, leaving fans divided and Shay’s own family at odds.
Shay Johnson Baby Daddy: The Reveal We Waited For
For the longest time, Shay kept him off the grid. She’d post photos of her daughter, Shajiyah, but her man’s face was always cropped out or covered with an emoji. It was a smart move for privacy, but let's be real—it just made people more curious.
Finally, the curtain dropped. His name is Fabian, though most people know him as Fabo.
He isn't a massive superstar or a household name like Scrappy, but he definitely brought the drama once he stepped in front of the cameras. He first started appearing more prominently in 2023, and by then, the "mystery man" allure had been replaced by the reality of a very tense co-parenting (and sometimes romantic) dynamic.
Who is Fabian?
Fabian is an entrepreneur who, according to Shay, had been in her life for quite some time before they had Shajiyah. She’s described him as someone who is "a little controlling" but also "experienced" when it comes to raising kids. Apparently, he had children from previous relationships, which gave him a bit of an edge in the daddy department—at least in Shay's eyes early on.
The Momma Dee and Scrappy Confusion
You can't talk about Shay Johnson’s baby daddy without mentioning the Lil Scrappy rumors. This was a whole mess.
Because Shay and Scrappy have a history that goes back over a decade, and because Momma Dee (Scrappy’s mom) has always been Shay’s biggest cheerleader, the math seemed to add up for fans. Momma Dee was literally at the gender reveal. She was at the baby shower. She was posting Shajiyah like she was her own flesh and blood.
The internet went wild.
"That baby looks just like Scrappy!"
"Why is Momma Dee there if it's not his?"
Eventually, Shay had to shut it down. She confirmed that while Momma Dee is basically family, she isn't Shajiyah’s biological grandmother. It was just a case of deep loyalty between a reality TV legend and her "god-daughter" figure.
Why the Relationship With Fabo Got So Messy
Everything seemed okay until Love & Hip Hop: Miami cameras started rolling on their actual lives. That’s when we saw the friction.
If you watched the show in late 2023 and early 2024, you saw things get ugly between Fabian and Shay’s mother, Sandra Sims. It wasn't just a small disagreement; it was a full-blown war of words.
There was a specific incident involving a dog that became a huge flashpoint. Fabian was caught on camera being incredibly disrespectful to Sandra, even using profanity and telling her to put a dog in a shelter. It was uncomfortable to watch. Shay’s brother, Emjay Johnson, almost came to blows with Fabian over it.
This is where the public perception of the Shay Johnson baby daddy situation shifted. People went from "Who is he?" to "Why is she with him?"
- The Breakup: Shay actually announced on Instagram Live that she had kicked Fabian to the curb after the disrespect toward her mother.
- The Pregnancy Scare/Loss: In a heartbreaking turn of events in early 2024, Shay revealed she was pregnant again by Fabian but sadly suffered a miscarriage. This process was publicized and showed a much more vulnerable side of their connection.
- The Current Status: As of 2026, the two seem to be in a perpetual state of "it's complicated." They have been seen together on social media, leading fans to believe they are still trying to make it work for the sake of their daughter, despite the past drama with Shay’s family.
Navigating the Reality of Co-Parenting
Shay has been very vocal about the fact that motherhood changed her. She’s a "doting mom" through and through. But the co-parenting side? That’s a work in progress.
She admits that Fabian is a present father. He’s there for Shajiyah, and he calls her his "little princess." But the friction between him and Shay’s support system—specifically her mom and brother—makes things nearly impossible.
It’s a classic reality TV dilemma. Do you choose the father of your child or the family that has always had your back? Shay has tried to do both, and it hasn't always worked out smoothly.
What You Should Know About the Rumors
There’s always some gossip that Fabian was engaged to another woman when he started things up with Shay. Shay claimed she thought he was single. Whether that’s true or just reality TV "storyline" fodder is still up for debate, but it added another layer of "loser" labels from the fans.
Despite the noise, Shay continues to post him occasionally, usually with a caption that suggests she doesn't care about the backlash. She’s even joked about it, writing "Y'all Mad Mad" to the trolls who criticize her for staying with him.
✨ Don't miss: Sabrina and Barry Break Up: What Really Happened Between the Pop Star and the Actor
Real Talk on What Happens Next
If you're following Shay's journey, the takeaway isn't just about the identity of the father. It’s about the struggle of setting boundaries in a very public relationship.
If you find yourself in a similar co-parenting mess, here is what the Shay/Fabian saga teaches us:
- Family loyalty is a double-edged sword. Shay’s loyalty to her mom is why she originally dumped Fabian, but her desire for a two-parent household keeps bringing him back.
- Public opinion doesn't pay the bills. Shay has learned to ignore the "exposed" videos on YouTube. If she’s happy or if the co-parenting is working behind closed doors, that’s what she focuses on.
- Documentation matters. Whether it's on a reality show or in a private journal, seeing the patterns of behavior (like the disrespect shown to her mother) is usually what leads to long-term change.
For now, the man behind the mystery is firmly out in the open. Fabian is the father, and whether he stays the "villain" in the eyes of the fans depends entirely on how he treats the Johnson family moving forward.
Check Shay’s official Instagram for the most recent updates on their family dynamic, but keep a skeptical eye on the comments section—it’s a wild place. Focus on the facts of their shared history rather than the speculation of the "Scrappy" truthers who still won't let the past go.