You’re floating. The sun is a warm weight on your shoulders, and the salt water keeps you bobbing effortlessly in that turquoise space between the sky and the sand. Then, it happens. A shadow flickers. Maybe it’s just a patch of seagrass or a trick of the light hitting a wave, but your heart immediately hits your throat. Every human being has a hard-wired response to the idea of a shark in the water, and honestly, it’s not entirely our fault. We’ve been conditioned by decades of cellos playing two-note suspense themes and grainy viral footage to view the ocean as a giant bowl of soup where we are the main ingredient.
But here’s the thing. If you’ve spent any significant time in the ocean, you’ve probably been within twenty feet of a shark and never even knew it.
Dr. Chris Lowe and the team at the CSU Long Beach Shark Lab have used drones to prove this over and over again. They’ve spent years filming juvenile White sharks swimming directly underneath surfers and paddleboarders in Southern California. The sharks don't bite. They don't even deviate from their path. They just... exist. It turns out that having a shark in the water is a sign of a healthy ecosystem, not a scene from a horror movie, though try telling that to your adrenaline glands when you see a dorsal fin.
What actually happens when there is a shark in the water?
Usually? Nothing.
Most sharks are incredibly shy. If you see a shark in the water while snorkeling or diving, you'll notice they typically turn tail and bolt the moment they realize a clumsy, bubble-blowing human is nearby. We are loud. We are weird-looking. We smell like sunscreen and neoprene. To a predator that has spent 400 million years evolving to hunt specific oily fish or pinnipeds, a human is a confusing, bony biped that probably tastes like a bad decision.
According to the International Shark Attack File (ISAF) managed by the Florida Museum of Natural History, the actual risk of an unprovoked encounter is astronomically low. We’re talking 1 in 3.7 million. You are statistically more likely to be killed by a collapsing sand hole on the beach or a falling coconut than by a shark. Yet, the "Shark!" yelp still clears a beach faster than a lightning storm.
There is a massive difference between a "sighting" and an "interaction." Most sightings are just the ocean doing its thing. If you see a shark, it’s likely a Blacktip, a Spinner, or maybe a Sandbar shark depending on where you are. These species have zero interest in you. They are looking for baitfish. When you see a shark "patrolling" the shoreline, it's often just following the buffet of mullet or menhaden that moves with the tides.
🔗 Read more: Entry Into Dominican Republic: What Most People Get Wrong
The psychology of the shadow
Why do we freak out? It's called "predator stress." Our brains are still running software designed for the Pleistocene era when being eaten was a daily concern. When you are in the ocean, you are out of your element. You can’t run. You can’t see well. You’re slow.
The presence of a shark in the water strips away our status as the top of the food chain, and that's a very humbling, terrifying feeling.
Identifying what you’re seeing
Before you panic, look at the movement.
- Dolphins: They have a rhythmic, rolling motion. You’ll see the fin come up and go down in a circular arc. Usually, they travel in groups.
- Sharks: The fin stays steady. It cuts the water like a knife. It doesn't "roll." If the fin is wobbling or flopping, it might even be a Mola Mola (Sunfish), which is basically a giant floating pancake that couldn't hurt you if it tried.
- Rays: Sometimes a wingtip breaks the surface. It looks like two points moving together. Totally harmless unless you step on one in the shallows.
Why the "Jaws" myth refuses to die
Peter Benchley, the man who wrote Jaws, actually spent the later years of his life as a massive shark advocate. He felt a deep sense of regret for how his book portrayed Great Whites as vengeful monsters. He realized that the image of a shark in the water as a "man-eater" was a total fabrication.
Real sharks don't hold grudges. They don't stalk specific people.
The reality of "attacks"—a term many scientists are trying to replace with "bites" or "encounters"—is that they are almost always cases of mistaken identity or investigative biting. Sharks don't have hands. If they want to know what something is, they have to put their mouth on it. Unfortunately, when a 1,500-pound animal with serrated teeth "investigates" a human, the results are catastrophic, even if the shark realizes its mistake and swims away immediately.
💡 You might also like: Novotel Perth Adelaide Terrace: What Most People Get Wrong
How to stay safe (and keep your cool)
If you find yourself with a shark in the water nearby, there are actual, practical steps you can take. This isn't just "stay calm" advice—because staying calm is hard when you’re staring at a prehistoric predator.
First, don't splash.
Splashing sounds like a wounded fish. It creates high-frequency vibrations that sharks can pick up from far away using their lateral line—a sensory organ that detects pressure changes in the water. If you want to leave, do it with smooth, rhythmic strokes.
Maintain eye contact. This sounds crazy, right? But sharks are ambush predators. They want the element of surprise. Divers who work with sharks, like those at Tiger Beach in the Bahamas, know that if you point your body and your eyes toward the shark, they often lose interest because they’ve been "spotted."
Avoid the water at dawn and dusk. This is "feeding time," but not because sharks are more aggressive then. It's because the light is low, and it's much easier for a shark to mistake a human silhouette for a seal or a large fish. Also, stay away from river mouths after a heavy rain. The murky water makes it hard for the shark to see, increasing the chance of an accidental "test bite."
The ecological cost of our fear
We kill about 100 million sharks every year. Read that number again.
📖 Related: Magnolia Fort Worth Texas: Why This Street Still Defines the Near Southside
Whether it's for shark fin soup, accidental bycatch in commercial fishing lines, or "cullings" meant to protect tourists, sharks are in trouble. When we see a shark in the water and react with violence or calls for extermination, we are damaging the very thing that keeps the ocean alive.
Sharks are the janitors. They eat the sick, the weak, and the dying fish. Without them, fish populations explode, get sick, and eventually collapse. A reef without sharks is a reef that is dying.
In places like Palau or the Maldives, a single live reef shark is worth nearly $2 million in tourism revenue over its lifetime. Compare that to the few hundred dollars a fisherman might get for its fins. People are starting to realize that seeing a shark in the wild is actually a bucket-list experience, much like seeing a lion on safari.
Moving forward with respect, not fear
Next time you hear there’s a shark in the water, don't just think of a row of teeth. Think of a biological masterpiece that has survived five mass extinctions.
We are guests in their home. The ocean is a wild space, and while it carries risks, those risks are what make it beautiful. Respect the power of the water, understand the behavior of the animals within it, and realize that you aren't on the menu.
Actionable steps for your next beach trip:
- Check local "shark smart" apps or websites like Dorsal or Global Shark Tracker to see recent activity.
- Avoid wearing high-contrast clothing or shiny jewelry (it looks like fish scales to a shark).
- If you see a shark, stay vertical in the water. Looking like a "long" horizontal seal is the worst thing you can do.
- Support organizations like Oceana or the Sea Shepherd Conservation Society that work to end finning and protect critical habitats.
- Keep your distance from schools of baitfish—if there's a lot of food in the water, the diners aren't far behind.