Shape of You: Why Ed Sheeran’s Biggest Hit Almost Didn't Happen

Shape of You: Why Ed Sheeran’s Biggest Hit Almost Didn't Happen

You’ve heard it at weddings. You’ve heard it at the gym. Honestly, you’ve probably heard it in the background of a pharmacy while buying toothpaste. Shape of You is one of those rare cultural artifacts that stopped being just a song and turned into a permanent part of the global atmosphere.

But here is the thing: Ed Sheeran didn't even want it for himself.

When Ed sat down in a studio with Steve Mac and Johnny McDaid (from Snow Patrol) in late 2016, he wasn't trying to write a career-defining anthem. He was actually trying to write a song for Rihanna. He thought the tropical house vibe and the "push and pull" lyrics fit her brand better than his own. It’s wild to think about now, but the song that spent 12 weeks at number one on the Billboard Hot 100 was almost shipped off to another superstar.

The Marimba That Changed Everything

Most pop songs start with a guitar or a piano. Shape of You started with a log drum sound on a keyboard.

Steve Mac, the legendary producer, started messing with a marimba-style riff. It was plucky. It was rhythmic. It felt "vibey" in a way that acoustic singer-songwriter music usually doesn't. Sheeran started beatboxing over it and tapping his guitar. Within ninety minutes, the skeleton of the track was done.

Usually, Sheeran writes these heart-on-your-sleeve ballads about drinking tea or crying in the rain. This was different. It was about a "club" not being the best place to find a lover, so you go to the bar. It was gritty, skeletal, and lean. There are no wasted notes here.

The TLC Controversy and the Credit Shift

If you listen to the pre-chorus of Shape of You, you might notice something familiar. "Boy, let's not talk too much / Grab on my waist and put that body on me." If those rhythms feel like 1999, it's because they are.

💡 You might also like: Why Love Island Season 7 Episode 23 Still Feels Like a Fever Dream

After the song blew up, people started pointing out the melodic similarities to TLC’s "No Scrubs." Instead of fighting a messy legal battle like the "Blurred Lines" fiasco, Sheeran’s team did the smart thing. They added Kandi Burruss, Tameka "Tiny" Cottle, and Kevin "She'kspere" Briggs—the writers of "No Scrubs"—to the official credits.

It was a proactive move. It also highlighted how pop music is often a giant recycling bin of great ideas.

Why Shape of You Dominated the Charts for So Long

There is a technical reason this song worked. It’s the "Millennial Whoop" and the "Four-Chord" trick, but stripped down.

  1. It’s a loop. The song never really changes its foundation.
  2. It uses a "pentatonic" scale. These are notes that sound good to the human ear no matter what order they are in.
  3. The lyrics are incredibly relatable. Everyone has been at a bar with friends, ended up in a taxi, and talked about nothing.

It wasn't just a UK or US hit. This thing was a monster in India, Mexico, Australia, and Germany. By the time 2017 ended, it was the best-selling song of the year globally. It currently sits with over 6 billion views on YouTube. Just let that number sink in. Six billion. That’s nearly the entire population of the planet watching Ed Sheeran dance in a boxing ring.

The Boxing Video and the "New" Ed

Speaking of the video, it was a pivot.

Before 2017, Ed Sheeran was the "guy with the guitar." For the Shape of You music video, he trained. He got in a ring. He showed off his tattoos. It was a visual rebranding that told the world he was moving from "indie-folk darling" to "global pop titan." He wasn't just a songwriter anymore; he was a brand.

📖 Related: When Was Kai Cenat Born? What You Didn't Know About His Early Life

The Math Behind the Success

Let’s talk numbers, because they are staggering.

The song was released as a "double lead single" alongside "Castle on the Hill." This was a brilliant marketing move by Atlantic Records. They gave the audience two versions of Ed: the nostalgic storyteller and the pop innovator.

While "Castle on the Hill" did well, Shape of You destroyed it in terms of streaming. It was the first song to hit 2 billion streams on Spotify. It stayed in the Top 10 for months. It basically became the blueprint for "tropical pop" that dominated the late 2010s.

Critics, however, weren't always kind. Some called it "derivative" or "too simple." But that simplicity is exactly why it worked. You can hum the melody after one listen. That is the "earworm" effect in its purest form.

Common Misconceptions About the Song

A lot of people think this was a solo Ed Sheeran production. It wasn't. Steve Mac is the secret weapon here. He’s the guy behind hits for Westlife, Pink, and Clean Bandit. He brought the "pop polish" to Ed’s raw songwriting.

Another myth? That it was written about a specific girlfriend. Ed has stated in multiple interviews that the song was more of a "functional" exercise in songwriting. He was trying to see if he could write something for someone else. The "shape of you" phrase is actually an old English saying (mostly from the North/Ireland) that refers to someone’s physical presence or their "soul" in a room.

👉 See also: Anjelica Huston in The Addams Family: What You Didn't Know About Morticia

Lessons for Aspiring Musicians

If you’re a songwriter, there is a lot to learn from how this track was built. It’s not about complexity.

  • Keep the hook simple. If a five-year-old can't sing it, it’s too complicated for a global hit.
  • Space is your friend. Notice how the song has moments of near-silence between the beats? That’s called "negative space." It makes the beat hit harder.
  • Don't be afraid to pivot. If Ed had stayed in his "acoustic guitar only" lane, he never would have reached this level of fame.

What to Do Now

To truly understand the impact of Shape of You, you have to look at what came after. It opened the door for Ed to collaborate with everyone from Beyoncé to Justin Bieber.

If you want to dive deeper into the mechanics of 2010s pop, go listen to the "acoustic" version of the song. It strips away the electronic drums and reveals just how strong the melodic structure actually is. You can also check out the "Galantis Remix" if you want to see how the song translates to a pure dancefloor environment.

The most important takeaway? Sometimes your best work is the stuff you almost gave away. Trust the process, but more importantly, trust the "vibe" of the room when you're creating.


Next Steps for Music Lovers:

  1. Analyze the Credits: Look up Steve Mac’s production discography to see how he uses "plucky" synth sounds in other hits like "Rockabye."
  2. Compare the Mix: Listen to the "No Scrubs" chorus back-to-back with the Shape of You pre-chorus to hear exactly why the songwriting credit was added.
  3. Watch the "Song Exploder" style breakdowns: Search for the "Making of" videos where Johnny McDaid explains the rapid-fire lyric writing process that happened in that London studio.