When Shannon Sharpe walked onto the set of First Take on September 4, 2023, the air felt different. It wasn't just another guest host filling a seat. It was a massive moment in sports media history. After a messy, highly publicized breakup with Skip Bayless over at FS1, Sharpe didn't just find a new job. He found a massive platform where his personality—and his cognac-sipping, cigar-lighting "Unc" persona—could actually breathe.
Honestly, the move was a masterstroke by Stephen A. Smith. Smith didn't just want a debater; he wanted a peer. For years, First Take had felt like Stephen A. vs. a rotating cast of characters who were sometimes just happy to be there. Sharpe changed that dynamic instantly.
The "LeBron" Effect and the Ratings Boom
People didn't just watch; they obsessed. Sharpe’s debut pulled in 727,000 viewers, making it one of the highest-rated shows of that year. Why? Because the chemistry was organic. You've got two guys who genuinely respect each other but are willing to yell until they're blue in the face about whether LeBron James is better than Michael Jordan.
Sharpe brought his "Club Shay Shay" energy to the ESPN desk. He wasn't just quoting stats. He was talking about "the GOAT James" and using phrases like "stay off the weed" back at Stephen A. It felt like a barbershop conversation with a $20 million production budget.
💡 You might also like: Why Isn't Mbappe Playing Today: The Real Madrid Crisis Explained
By May 2024, the show was celebrating its 22nd consecutive month of year-over-year growth. That's unheard of in linear television right now. While other shows were bleeding viewers, First Take was averaging over 500,000 people a morning. The "Sharpe Effect" was real. ESPN saw enough value that by June 2024, they locked him into a multi-year contract extension. This wasn't just a "football season" gig anymore. It was a permanent fixture.
When Things Got Complicated
You can't talk about Shannon Sharpe on First Take without mentioning the bumps in the road. In late 2024, Sharpe accidentally went live on Instagram during a private, intimate encounter. It was a mess. The internet exploded. Sharpe, to his credit, owned it. He didn't hide behind the "I was hacked" excuse for long. He admitted he messed up, called his bosses at ESPN, and was back on the air the following Monday.
But the real challenge hit in early 2025.
📖 Related: Tottenham vs FC Barcelona: Why This Matchup Still Matters in 2026
In April 2025, news broke regarding a lawsuit involving rape allegations from an ex-girlfriend. This was heavy. It wasn't just a viral "oops" moment; it was a serious legal situation. Sharpe elected to "step aside temporarily" to deal with the legal fallout and spend time with family. Stephen A. Smith, ever the loyal friend, went on his own podcast to defend Sharpe’s character while acknowledging he didn't know the specifics of the case.
Why the Partnership Matters
Despite the drama, the partnership redefined what a "debate show" looks like in the 2020s. Here is what makes the Shannon Sharpe and First Take pairing unique:
- Peer-to-Peer Respect: Unlike the Skip Bayless era, where the tension often felt personal and toxic, Smith and Sharpe feel like brothers. They can "go there" without it feeling like a HR violation.
- Multi-Platform Dominance: Sharpe’s success with Club Shay Shay and Nightcap (with Chad Ochocinco) fed into First Take. It created a feedback loop where his viral podcast moments drove people to watch him on ESPN the next morning.
- Cultural Currency: They don't just talk about the Cowboys. They talk about life, HBCUs, and the "business" of being an athlete.
What Really Happened with the "Successor" Talk?
There has been a lot of chatter about whether Shannon is being groomed to take over First Take entirely. Stephen A. Smith has been vocal about his own ambitions. He wants the late-night slot. He wants to talk politics. He wants to be the highest-paid guy at the network.
👉 See also: Buddy Hield Sacramento Kings: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
If Stephen A. moves on, Sharpe is the only person with enough gravity to keep that seat warm. He’s already proven he can carry the ratings. He’s already proven he has the "stardom" that matches Smith.
Actionable Insights for the Sports Media Fan
If you're following the evolution of sports media, keep an eye on these three things regarding Shannon Sharpe:
- Contractual Leverage: Watch how Sharpe uses his podcasting empire to negotiate his next move at ESPN. He doesn't need the network as much as they need his audience.
- Legal Resolutions: The outcome of his 2025 legal hurdles will dictate if he remains the "face" of the morning or stays in a secondary role.
- The "Nightcap" Synergy: Observe how ESPN starts to integrate more of Sharpe’s digital-first content into their linear broadcasts. The walls between YouTube and TV are officially gone.
Shannon Sharpe didn't just join First Take; he saved it from becoming repetitive. He brought a Hall of Fame resume and a podcasting juggernaut’s mindset to a show that desperately needed a fresh spark. Whether he’s debating the Lakers' playoff chances or explaining a viral mistake, he’s made himself unmissable.
To stay ahead of the curve, pay attention to the guest lineups during Sharpe's "off" days. You'll see ESPN testing who can match his energy, but so far, nobody has quite hit that "Unc" level of charisma. Watch the 10:00 AM ET window on Mondays and Tuesdays; that's where the real needle moves.