He’s intense. If you’ve ever watched a Colts game and seen a guy on the sidelines who looks like he just drank four espressos and is trying to solve a Rubik's Cube in high-speed traffic, that’s Shane Steichen. Since taking over as the head coach for Colts football in early 2023, Steichen hasn't just been "filling a role." He’s been trying to fix a franchise that felt like it was stuck in a spin cycle of veteran quarterbacks and "almost" seasons.
Most people look at a head coach and see a leader. I see a play-caller first. Steichen came from Philly where he helped turn Jalen Hurts into a MVP-caliber threat, and honestly, the Colts hired him because they were desperate for that same offensive wizardry. They needed a guy who could take a raw talent like Anthony Richardson and turn him into a weapon of mass destruction. It’s been a bumpy ride—injuries, close losses, and the weirdness of the AFC South—but the vision is starting to clear up.
The Steichen Identity: More Than Just a Playbook
What makes a head coach for Colts fans actually worth their salt? It’s the ability to adapt. Steichen doesn't run a "system" in the traditional, rigid sense. Most coaches have a "my way or the highway" mentality, but if you look at how he handled the 2023 season after Anthony Richardson went down, it was a masterclass in pivot-ability. He took Gardner Minshew—a guy with a completely different physical profile—and stayed in the playoff hunt until the literal final seconds of Week 18.
That’s not luck. That’s high-level sequencing. Steichen relies on a philosophy he calls "Vertical Threat Integration," though he’d probably just tell you he wants to "play fast and score points." He’s obsessed with the explosive play. If the Colts aren't taking shots downfield, Steichen isn't happy. You can see it in his eyes during the post-game pressers; he’s calculating the yards he left on the field.
He is, basically, the antithesis of the "rah-rah" coach. He’s a tactician. While guys like Dan Campbell are out there talking about biting kneecaps, Steichen is looking at a nickel defense and wondering why the safety is shaded two inches too far to the left. It’s a different kind of leadership. It’s leadership through competence.
The Richardson Factor
Let’s be real: Steichen’s legacy as the head coach for Colts players is tied to Anthony Richardson. Period. You don't draft a guy with that kind of ceiling and then play it safe. The 2024 and 2025 seasons have been a test of patience and medical reports.
When Richardson is on the field, the offense looks like a Madden glitch. Steichen uses the RPO (Run-Option) better than almost anyone in the league because he understands the math. If you have a quarterback who can run a 4.4 and throw a ball 65 yards, the defense can never be right. Steichen exploits that "wrongness" every single snap. But the challenge—and this is what experts like Nate持 from The Athletic have pointed out—is keeping that quarterback healthy while still using his best traits. It’s a tightrope. A very thin, very high tightrope.
🔗 Read more: Inter Miami vs Toronto: What Really Happened in Their Recent Clashes
Why Being a Head Coach for Colts is Different Than Other Jobs
The shadow of Peyton Manning and Andrew Luck is long. It’s huge. It covers the whole city. If you’re the head coach for Colts fans, you aren't just compared to the rest of the league; you’re compared to the "Golden Era."
Jim Irsay, the owner, is... eccentric. We know this. He’s a guy who loves rock and roll and wants a Super Bowl yesterday. Steichen has to navigate that. He has to be the bridge between Irsay’s massive ambitions and the cold, hard reality of the salary cap and roster construction. He works closely with Chris Ballard, the General Manager, but the dynamic is fascinating. Ballard is known for being conservative with free agency, while Steichen’s offense demands high-octane talent.
- The "Colts Way": It used to mean "be perfect."
- The Steichen Way: It means "be aggressive."
There was a moment in a game against the Ravens where Steichen went for it on fourth down in his own territory. People lost their minds. "It’s too risky!" "Play it safe!" But Steichen doesn't care about safe. He knows that in the modern NFL, playing safe is the fastest way to get fired. You have to take the points, sure, but you also have to take the soul of the opposing defense.
The Staff He Built
No coach is an island. Steichen brought in Jim Bob Cooter as his Offensive Coordinator. Yes, that is his real name. And honestly, Cooter is one of the more underrated minds in the game. Together, they’ve built a room that focuses on "modular play-calling." This means they can swap parts of a play out depending on what the defense shows at the line of scrimmage. It requires a high football IQ from the players, which is why you see the Colts drafting "smart" players over "flashy" ones more often than not.
On the defensive side, keeping Gus Bradley was a choice that sparked a lot of debate. Bradley’s "Cover 3" scheme is legendary but sometimes feels a bit dated. Steichen’s ability to manage a veteran coordinator like Bradley while focusing on his own offensive specialty is a testament to his maturity as a young head coach. He knows what he doesn't know.
The Misconceptions About the Colts' Progress
Some people think the Colts are underperforming. I think those people aren't watching the tape.
💡 You might also like: Matthew Berry Positional Rankings: Why They Still Run the Fantasy Industry
Winning in the NFL is hard. Winning with a rotating door at quarterback is impossible. What Steichen has done is create a floor. The Colts don't get blown out often. They are always in it. That’s the sign of a well-coached team. They don't beat themselves with dumb penalties or botched substitutions—usually.
Wait, I should clarify. Every team has "those" games. But under Steichen, the "mental errors" have dropped significantly compared to the end of the Frank Reich era. The team feels disciplined. They feel like they have a direction. Even if that direction is sometimes "let's see if our giant quarterback can jump over three people," it's still a plan.
Facing the AFC South Gauntlet
The division has changed. The Texans found C.J. Stroud. The Jaguars have Trevor Lawrence. The Titans are always a physical headache. Being the head coach for Colts in this environment means you can't have an "off" week.
Steichen’s record in the division is where he’ll eventually be judged. You can beat the NFC North all you want, but if you can’t handle DeMeco Ryans’ defense in Houston, you aren't winning the South. Steichen’s approach to these "rivalry" games is surprisingly low-key. He doesn't do the big speeches. He does the big film sessions.
Critical Success Factors for the Near Future
If we're looking at what actually matters for the next 18 months of Colts football, it comes down to three specific areas.
First, the offensive line has to stay elite. Bernhard Raimann and Quenton Nelson are the anchors. If they aren't creating the "lanes of opportunity" Steichen needs for his RPO game, the whole thing falls apart. Steichen has been very vocal about the game being won in the trenches, which is a bit of a cliché, but for his specific vertical offense, it’s 100% true.
📖 Related: What Time Did the Cubs Game End Today? The Truth About the Off-Season
Second, the secondary needs a pulse. Steichen is an offensive guy, but as the head coach for Colts, he's responsible for the whole roster. There have been games where the offense puts up 30 points and the defense gives up 31. That’s a coaching failure, or at least a resource allocation failure. Steichen needs to lean on Ballard to get him some shutdown corners, or he needs to figure out a way to scheme around the lack of elite talent in the backfield.
Third, and most importantly, is the "Clutch Factor." Steichen has been involved in a lot of one-score games. His decision-making in the final two minutes of the half and the game is scrutinized more than his actual play-calling. Does he use his timeouts correctly? Does he know when to kick the field goal versus going for the throat? So far, he’s been better than average, but to be "great," he needs to be flawless in those high-leverage moments.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Analysts
If you're following the trajectory of the head coach for Colts, don't just look at the win-loss column. That’s surface-level stuff. To really understand if the Steichen era is working, watch these specific markers:
- Red Zone Efficiency: Steichen’s "Philly" roots mean he should be creative near the goal line. If the Colts are settling for field goals, the system is breaking down.
- Anthony Richardson’s Completion Percentage: It doesn't need to be 70%, but it needs to be "efficient." Look for Steichen to design "easy" throws (shallow crosses, screens) to build rhythm before taking the deep shots.
- Third Down Creativity: This is where Steichen earns his paycheck. Watch how he uses Josh Downs or Michael Pittman Jr. in "must-have" situations. If he’s finding ways to get them open against man coverage, he’s winning the coaching battle.
- In-Game Adjustments: If the Colts look better in the second half than the first, it means Steichen and his staff are identifying the opponent’s "tells." This is the hallmark of a top-tier NFL coach.
The reality is that being a head coach for Colts is a high-pressure, high-reward gig. Shane Steichen has the temperament for it. He’s got the "football nerd" energy mixed with a "tough guy" exterior that players seem to respect. He isn't trying to be your friend; he’s trying to win a ring. Whether the roster can keep up with his brain remains to be seen, but for the first time in a long time, it feels like Indianapolis has a guy who isn't afraid of the moment.
To track this properly, keep an eye on the weekly "Advanced Stats" reports from sources like Pro Football Focus or Next Gen Stats. Look for "Expected Points Added" (EPA) per play. If Steichen’s offense is consistently in the top 10 for EPA, the wins will follow, regardless of the noise on social media. The process is there. Now, we just wait for the results to solidify.
Go watch the next game. Look at Steichen on the sideline when a play goes wrong. He isn't screaming at the refs—usually. He’s already looking at his play sheet for the next fix. That’s the guy you want leading your team. He's already three plays ahead of everyone else.