Newark on a Tuesday night usually feels lived-in, but when the bus from Pennsylvania rolls into the Prudential Center parking lot, the air gets thin. You’ve felt it if you’ve ever sat in those red seats. It’s a specific kind of tension. Seton Hall basketball vs Villanova isn’t just a game on the schedule; it’s a culture clash that has defined the Big East for decades.
On December 23, 2025, we saw the latest chapter. It wasn’t pretty. Honestly, it rarely is. Villanova walked out with a 64-56 win, but that score doesn't tell half the story of how these two programs are currently trying to find their souls in a post-Jay Wright, post-Kevin Willard landscape.
The Night the Defense Took Over
Walking into "The Rock" two nights before Christmas, you could tell Seton Hall was looking for blood. Shaheen Holloway has built this roster in his own image: tough, slightly undersized, and relentlessly annoying on defense. They held Villanova to basically nothing for long stretches.
But then Acaden Lewis happened.
The kid is a problem. Lewis, a freshman who has been the talk of the conference, put up 16 points and grabbed three steals. He has this way of gliding through a press that makes experienced defenders look like they’re standing in sand. Villanova used a massive 16-0 run in the second half to break the Pirates' spirit. For a while, the Hall didn't score for nearly five minutes. You can't do that against a team that shoots the three as well as the Wildcats.
Why Seton Hall vs Villanova Always Feels Different
There is a psychological weight to this matchup. For years, Villanova was the "Main Line" powerhouse—polished, elite, and arguably the gold standard of college basketball. Seton Hall was the gritty neighbor from North Jersey that lived for the upset.
🔗 Read more: Inter Miami vs Toronto: What Really Happened in Their Recent Clashes
- The Willard Factor: This year added a weird layer of irony. Kevin Willard, who spent 12 seasons building Seton Hall into a consistent winner, is now the guy wearing the Villanova colors. Seeing him on the opposing sideline in Newark was surreal for the fans.
- The Identity Crisis: Seton Hall is currently one of the best defensive teams in the country, but they struggle to put the ball in the hoop. Against Villanova's 2025-26 squad, that’s a recipe for a heartbreak.
- The MSG Magic: Most people forget that the 2024-25 Big East Tournament saw Villanova bounce the Pirates in a 67-55 slog at the Garden. It’s becoming a pattern.
Breaking Down the 2025-26 Power Struggle
Right now, the Big East is a shark tank. UConn is sitting at the top like they own the place, but Villanova and Seton Hall are both hovering in that top four or five range.
Villanova has leaned heavily into the three-point shot. They’re averaging over 10 makes a game from deep. Bryce Lindsay and Matt Hodge have become the secondary punch behind Acaden Lewis. In that December matchup, they hit 43% of their threes. Seton Hall? They hit 23%.
You don't need a math degree to see why the Pirates lost.
Shaheen Holloway was visibly frustrated after the game. He mentioned that his guys looked "tired" after a physical battle with Wisconsin earlier in the month. But honestly, it’s about execution. The Pirates are great at forcing turnovers—they forced 18 from Nova—but they only turned those into a handful of points.
The Real Stats Nobody Talks About
While the box score highlights the points, the rebounding battle tells the real truth of Seton Hall basketball vs Villanova.
💡 You might also like: Matthew Berry Positional Rankings: Why They Still Run the Fantasy Industry
Seton Hall grabbed six offensive boards in the first 12 minutes of their last meeting. They were hunting for second chances. But Villanova’s interior defense, led by Enoch Boakye, eventually shut the door.
If you look at the season-long trends, Seton Hall is actually holding opponents to under 40% shooting from the field. That’s elite. It’s why they’re 14-4 overall as of mid-January 2026. They aren't a "bad" team; they just ran into a Villanova squad that finally found its rhythm under Willard.
What Most People Get Wrong About the Rivalry
People think this is a lopsided affair because of Villanova’s national titles in 2016 and 2018. It isn't.
Since the Big East reshuffled, these games are almost always within single digits. Think back to 2014 when Seton Hall stunned the Wildcats in the Big East Tournament on a Sterling Gibbs buzzer-beater. Or 2016 when Isaiah Whitehead basically willed the Pirates to a title over a Villanova team that went on to win the National Championship weeks later.
There is a mutual respect here, even if it’s buried under a lot of Newark-style "tough love" from the stands.
📖 Related: What Time Did the Cubs Game End Today? The Truth About the Off-Season
Tactical Shifts to Watch
- The Villanova Press Offense: Willard admitted his team struggled with Seton Hall’s full-court pressure late in the game. If you're betting on the rematch in February, watch how Nova handles the 94-foot heat.
- The Pirates' Scoring Droughts: Seton Hall has a habit of going "dark" for four to six minutes at a time. They need Mike Williams III or Budd Clark to become "The Guy" when the offense stalls.
- The Hodge Development: Matt Hodge is playing like a seasoned vet. His ability to stretch the floor at the four-position pulls Seton Hall’s rim protectors out of the paint, which is exactly how Lewis gets those easy layups.
What's Next for the Pirates and the Wildcats?
If you’re tracking these teams for the NCAA Tournament, both are looking like "Safe" bets, but for different reasons.
Villanova looks like a team that can get hot and make a Final Four run if their shooting holds up. They have the "NBA-ready" talent in Lewis.
Seton Hall is the team nobody wants to play in the first round. They will turn the game into a rock fight. They will make you miserable for 40 minutes. If they can just find a way to shoot 33% from the three-point line instead of 23%, they could beat anyone in the country.
The rematch is set for February 4, 2026. It’ll be back in Pennsylvania this time. Expect more of the same: heavy defense, a few "kinda" questionable calls, and a game that isn't decided until the final two minutes.
Next Steps for Fans:
Keep a close eye on the Big East injury reports heading into February. Seton Hall's depth is their greatest weapon, but if they lose a primary defender like A.J. Staton-McCray, their defensive scheme against Villanova's shooters falls apart. Also, check the mid-week standings; both teams are fighting for a top-three seed in the Big East Tournament, and a head-to-head win here is basically worth double in the eyes of the selection committee.