Sending India to America money: Why you are probably paying too much

Sending India to America money: Why you are probably paying too much

You’re sitting in Bangalore or Mumbai, staring at your banking app, trying to figure out why a simple transfer feels like a math exam. Sending india to america money should be easy. It isn't. Not really. Most people just click "send" on their HDFC or ICICI portal and assume the bank is giving them a fair shake because, well, it’s a big bank.

They aren't.

Banks are businesses, and their favorite way to make money is through the "spread." That’s the gap between the interbank rate—the one you see on Google—and the rate they actually give you. If Google says 1 USD is 83.50 INR, but your bank offers 84.80, you’ve just lost a massive chunk of change before the transfer even starts. It’s annoying. Honestly, it’s bordering on predatory if you're moving large sums for tuition or property.

The LRS trap and why the RBI cares about your transfers

The Liberalised Remittance Scheme (LRS) is the big boss here. The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) basically says you can send up to $250,000 per financial year out of India. That sounds like a lot. For most of us, it is. But the paperwork involved in staying under that cap while navigating the Tax Collected at Source (TCS) rules is where the headache starts.

Back in 2023, the Indian government hiked the TCS on foreign remittances to a whopping 20% for amounts over 7 lakh INR.

Wait.

🔗 Read more: Shangri-La Asia Interim Report 2024 PDF: What Most People Get Wrong

Don't panic. If you’re sending money for education or medical treatment, the rates are much lower (0.5% or 5%). But if you're just sending a gift to your sister in New Jersey or investing in US stocks? You’re hitting that 20% mark. You get that money back eventually as a tax credit when you file your ITR, but who wants to give the government an interest-free loan for a year? Nobody.

Breaking down the TCS math

Imagine you want to send 10 lakh INR to your US brokerage account. The first 7 lakh is "free" of TCS. The remaining 3 lakh gets slapped with a 20% tax. That’s 60,000 INR you have to cough up upfront. It’s a cash-flow killer. You need to be very specific with your bank about the "purpose code." If you use the wrong code, you’re paying the high rate. Every. Single. Time.

Stop using "Big Banks" for India to America money transfers

Seriously. Just stop.

I know it’s convenient. You already have the account. Your salary goes there. But traditional banks in India often charge a flat "cable charge" or "outward remittance fee" that can range from 500 to 2,000 INR, plus that hidden exchange rate margin I mentioned earlier. When you add it all up, you’re often losing 3% to 5% of your total value.

Think about that. On a $10,000 transfer, you might be throwing $500 into a black hole.

💡 You might also like: Private Credit News Today: Why the Golden Age is Getting a Reality Check

Fintech has basically disrupted this entire space, but people are slow to change. Platforms like Wise (formerly TransferWise), Vested, or BookMyForex actually play the game differently. They often use the mid-market rate and show you a transparent fee. It’s cleaner. It’s faster. Sometimes the money lands in a US Chase or Wells Fargo account in under four hours.

Why the "Fixed vs. Natural" rate matters

Some services let you "lock" a rate. This is huge when the Rupee is volatile. If the RBI is intervening to support the INR, or if US Fed Chair Jerome Powell says something hawkish about interest rates, the Rupee can swing 50 paise in an afternoon. If you’re moving 50 lakhs to buy a condo in Texas, that swing represents a lot of BharatBenz truckloads of cash.

The documentation nightmare: Form 15CA and 15CB

If you are a business or if you’re sending money that isn’t "personal gifts," you’re going to meet Form 15CA and 15CB. These are the banes of the Indian expat's existence.

15CA is a declaration you fill out. 15CB is a certificate from a Chartered Accountant (CA) saying you’ve paid all your taxes in India before sending the money out. You can’t skip this if the amount is taxable. Most retail users sending money to kids in college don't need the 15CB, but if you’re an NRI selling a house in Delhi and moving the proceeds to San Francisco? Yeah, you’re going to be calling your CA.

The complexity here is real. The Income Tax portal is famously... temperamental. You need to ensure your PAN is linked to your Aadhaar and that your bank has your current KYC. If your KYC is even slightly out of date, the bank will freeze the outward remittance mid-stream. Then you're stuck in "compliance limbo" for two weeks while your US landlord or the university bursar sends you "where's my money?" emails.

📖 Related: Syrian Dinar to Dollar: Why Everyone Gets the Name (and the Rate) Wrong

How to actually get the best deal

Don't just look at the fee. Look at the "Landing Amount."

That is the only number that matters. Ask the provider: "If I give you 100,000 INR, exactly how many USD will land in the recipient's bank account after all fees?"

  • Step 1: Check the Google Rate. This is your baseline.
  • Step 2: Check the TCS requirement. Is this education? Use the right code.
  • Step 3: Compare at least three platforms. Use a bank, a dedicated forex player (like Orient Exchange), and a fintech app.
  • Step 4: Negotiate. If you are sending more than $25,000, call your bank's relationship manager. Tell them you have a better quote from a competitor. They can—and often will—narrow the spread for you.

Nuances of the US side (The receiving end)

We talk so much about getting the money out of India that we forget about the US side. US banks sometimes charge an "incoming wire fee." It’s usually $15 to $30. It’s small, but it’s another bite out of your sandwich.

More importantly: FBAR and FATCA. If you’re a US person (citizen or Green Card holder) and you have more than $10,000 in Indian accounts at any point in the year, you have to report it. Sending india to america money doesn't trigger a tax in the US usually (it’s a transfer of capital, not income), but if it’s a gift over a certain threshold ($18,000 in 2024), the sender doesn't pay US tax, but the receiver might have to report it on Form 3520.

It’s not a "tax" per se, it’s an "information return." But the penalties for forgetting are brutal. Like, $10,000 minimum penalty brutal. Don't mess with the IRS. They have no sense of humor.

Timing the market?

Don't try to time the INR/USD pair unless you're a professional forex trader. You’ll lose sleep and probably still get it wrong. The Rupee has historically depreciated against the Dollar over long periods. If you need to send money, send it. Trying to wait for an 82.50 rate when it’s at 83.10 is usually a losing game of chicken.

Actionable steps for your next transfer

  1. Verify your PAN status. Ensure your PAN is "Inoperative" if you haven't linked Aadhaar, because if it is, the bank will flat-out refuse the transfer or charge the highest possible tax rate.
  2. Use specialized portals. For education, platforms like Flywire or Global Spread are often integrated directly with universities. For general transfers, Wise or BookMyForex usually beat the big three banks by a mile.
  3. Check the "Purpose Code." Ensure your bank marks it correctly. S0014 is for family maintenance; S0305 is for travel. Picking the wrong one can mess up your TCS recovery later.
  4. Keep the SWIFT advice. Once the transfer is done, download the SWIFT copy. It’s your only proof if the money goes missing in the ether of intermediary banks.

The reality of moving money from India to America is that it’s getting more transparent, but the tax rules are getting tighter. Stay compliant, avoid the "convenience" of your default mobile banking app, and always calculate the total cost including the spread. Your wallet will thank you.