Honestly, if you missed the Seattle vs Detroit Game 5 in the 2025 ALDS, you didn't just miss a baseball game. You missed a psychiatric event. It was a five-hour marathon that felt like it lasted three days, ending in a 15-inning, 3-2 victory for the Mariners that broke a 24-year drought and probably a few thousand hearts in Michigan.
It was the longest winner-take-all game in MLB history. Think about that. Since the first pitch was thrown in professional baseball, no Game 5 or Game 7 has ever dragged its exhausted, dirt-stained body across the finish line quite like this one did at T-Mobile Park.
By the 14th inning, the crowd wasn't even cheering anymore; they were just vibrating in a collective state of delirium.
Why Seattle vs Detroit Game 5 Broke the Internet (and Our Brains)
The box score looks like a typo. Most people look at a 15-inning game and assume it was a sloppy, error-filled mess. It wasn't. It was high-level, high-stress chess played by two managers, Dan Wilson and A.J. Hinch, who were basically willing to set their entire pitching staffs on fire to win.
Seattle entered this series as the "cursed" team. They hadn't touched the ALCS since 2001. Detroit, on the other hand, was the underdog story of the year, riding the left arm of Tarik Skubal, who is—let's be real—the scariest man in baseball right now.
Skubal was a monster. He struck out 13 batters in six innings. At one point, he mowed down seven Mariners in a row, which is a postseason record. If you were a Seattle fan watching those first six innings, you weren't thinking about the ALCS. You were thinking about where you left your antidepressants.
The Pitching Chaos Nobody Expected
When the game hit the 10th inning, the traditional "bullpen" concept evaporated. We saw things you just don't see in modern baseball.
- Logan Gilbert and Luis Castillo, Seattle's frontline starters, coming out of the bullpen like they were 22-year-old relievers again.
- Jack Flaherty doing the same for the Tigers, pitching through a "dead arm" period just to keep the season alive.
- Eduard Bazardo escaping a bases-loaded jam in the 12th that should have ended the game three different times.
Kerry Carpenter almost stole the show. He went 4-for-5 with two walks and a two-run homer. He reached base six times in a winner-take-all game. The only other person to do that? Babe Ruth in 1926. It’s wild that a guy can have a "Babe Ruth" night and still end up on the losing side of history.
The Jorge Polanco Moment
By the bottom of the 15th, the players looked like they’d just crawled out of a trench. J.P. Crawford, the heart of that Seattle clubhouse, poked a leadoff single. Then things got weird. Randy Arozarena got hit by a pitch. Julio Rodríguez—who had been 0-for-the-entire-night—got intentionally walked.
Bases loaded. One out. Tommy Kahnle on the mound for Detroit, throwing changeups that looked like they were falling off a table.
Jorge Polanco didn't try to be a hero. He didn't swing for the Space Needle. He just stayed back on a changeup and laced a single into right field. That was it. 15 innings. 472 pitches. A 3-2 final score.
The sound that came out of T-Mobile Park when that ball hit the grass wasn't a roar; it was an explosion. It was the sound of 24 years of frustration leaving the building all at once.
What Most People Got Wrong About the Managerial Calls
Social media was screaming at Dan Wilson for pulling George Kirby after just 66 pitches in the 6th inning. It looked like a disaster when Gabe Speier immediately gave up that home run to Carpenter.
But looking back, that aggressive move is why they won. Wilson knew Skubal was untouchable. He knew he had to play the matchups perfectly because Seattle’s offense was basically in a coma. By rotating his "army of arms" early, he kept the Tigers' hitters from seeing the same pitcher twice. It was risky, it was stressful, and it worked.
Actionable Insights for the ALCS and Beyond
If you're following the remainder of the postseason, here’s how the fallout from Seattle vs Detroit Game 5 changes the landscape:
👉 See also: Finding the Channel Sunday Night Football is on Tonight: A Fan's Real Guide
- Watch the Pitching Rotations: Both teams burned their "Game 1" starters for the next round as relievers. Seattle heads into the ALCS against Toronto with a severely depleted staff. Look for "bullpen games" early in that series.
- The Skubal Factor: Even in a loss, Tarik Skubal proved he’s the best pitcher in the American League. If you're betting on the 2026 Cy Young, he’s your lock.
- The "Vibes" Meta: Seattle is riding a wave of momentum that usually carries teams to the World Series. When a team wins a game like this, the pressure of the "drought" disappears, and they start playing loose.
The 2025 ALDS will be remembered for a lot of things, but mostly for the night that Seattle and Detroit forgot how to end a baseball game. It was grueling, it was beautiful, and it was exactly why we watch this sport.
Keep an eye on the Mariners' injury report over the next 48 hours; playing 15 innings is the equivalent of two full games of physical toll on the legs. If they can recover, they might finally bring a pennant to the Pacific Northwest.
Next Steps: You should check the updated ALCS rotation to see how Seattle plans to cover the innings lost to Gilbert and Castillo's relief appearances. Monitor the "Salmon Run" tradition at T-Mobile Park, which gained legendary status during the 13th-inning stretch of this game.