Honestly, it’s wild to think about how much TV changed the moment Jennifer Morrison’s Emma Swan blew out a candle on a lonely cupcake in Boston. When we talk about the seasons of Once Upon a Time, we’re usually talking about two very different shows. There’s the tight, atmospheric mystery of the first few years in Storybrooke, and then there's the sprawling, sometimes chaotic multiverse of Disney-adjacent lore that followed.
The show didn't just adapt fairy tales; it mashed them together like a kid playing with action figures. Rumplestiltskin was also the Beast. Peter Pan was a villain. Red Riding Hood was the wolf. It was clever. It was also, at times, incredibly confusing for anyone trying to keep track of a family tree that eventually looked like a bowl of spaghetti. If you’ve ever tried to explain to a non-viewer that Henry’s step-grandmother is also his great-aunt, you know the struggle.
The Peak Years: When Storybrooke Felt Real
The first season is still a masterclass in pacing. Adam Horowitz and Edward Kitsis, who came off the success of Lost, brought that same "flashback" structure to ABC, and it worked beautifully. We had two timelines: the "real" world where everyone was miserable and forgot who they were, and the Enchanted Forest.
It was grounded.
Mary Margaret Blanchard felt like a real person, even if she was technically Snow White. The stakes were emotional. When Graham died—and let’s be real, we’re still not over Jamie Dornan leaving that early—it mattered. The seasons of Once Upon a Time that followed often struggled to recapture that specific sense of grounded stakes because the scale just kept getting bigger and bigger.
By the time we hit the second and third years, the world expanded. We went to Neverland. We dealt with the Wicked Witch. This was the "sweet spot." The show still had its core cast intact, and the villains, like Peter Pan (played with terrifying charisma by Robbie Kay), felt genuinely dangerous. You didn't just want the heroes to win; you wanted to see how the curse-of-the-week would twist the lore you grew up with.
📖 Related: Wrong Address: Why This Nigerian Drama Is Still Sparking Conversations
The Disney Expansion and the Frozen Pivot
Things shifted around Season 4. You can see the exact moment the show became a massive promotional vehicle for the broader Disney brand. The Frozen arc brought Elsa and Anna to live-action barely a year after the movie hit theaters. While Georgina Haig was a dead ringer for Elsa, some fans felt the show started chasing trends rather than building its own internal mythology.
It was a pivot.
Suddenly, we weren't just exploring the secrets of Storybrooke; we were visiting Arendelle, the Underworld, and even Camelot. The show became a "half-season" beast. The first 11 episodes would cover one villain (like the Snow Queen), and the next 11 would cover another (like the Queens of Darkness). This format kept things moving fast, but it also meant we lost the slow-burn character development that made the early seasons of Once Upon a Time so resonant.
The Underworld arc in Season 5 is a prime example of high-concept risks. Bringing back dead characters like Cora and Cruella de Vil was a treat for long-time fans, but the "logic" of the show started to strain. If death isn't permanent, do the sacrifices in Season 1 still matter? It’s a question that plagues many long-running fantasy shows, and Once wasn't immune.
The Soft Reboot: Season 7 and the New Storybrooke
If you talk to a die-hard "Oncer," they likely have strong feelings about the final season. Season 6 ended with a "Final Battle" that felt like a series finale. Emma Swan’s story was wrapped up. The curse was broken. Most of the main cast, including Ginnifer Goodwin and Josh Dallas, left the show.
👉 See also: Who was the voice of Yoda? The real story behind the Jedi Master
Then came Season 7.
Basically, it was a soft reboot. We jumped forward in time. Henry was an adult. We were in Hyperion Heights (Seattle) instead of Maine. While Lana Parrilla’s Regina (now "Roni") and Robert Carlyle’s Rumple remained the anchors, the magic was different. It felt like a spin-off masquerading as a final season.
Some people hated it. They missed the original charm. Others appreciated the attempt to tell a more mature, diverse story. It introduced a new Cinderella and a different version of Alice in Wonderland, but for many, the seasons of Once Upon a Time ended when the original cast rode off into the sunset in the Season 6 finale.
Why the Ratings Fluctuated
It’s no secret that the viewership numbers took a dive over time. Season 1 averaged nearly 12 million viewers per episode. By the end of the run, that number had dipped significantly. Why?
- Complexity Fatigue: The family tree became a meme. Keeping track of who was related to whom required a spreadsheet.
- CGI Limitations: As the show got more ambitious with locations like Olympus or the Dark Forest, the green screen effects sometimes struggled to keep up on a network TV budget.
- The "Emma Swan" Factor: When the protagonist’s journey feels complete, it’s hard to convince an audience to stick around for "Part 2."
Despite this, the show’s legacy is massive. It paved the way for the "gritty fairy tale" trend and proved that a female-led ensemble could dominate Sunday night television for years.
✨ Don't miss: Not the Nine O'Clock News: Why the Satirical Giant Still Matters
The Truth About the "Best" Order to Watch
If you’re revisiting the show, don't feel like you have to slog through every single episode. Many fans suggest the "Core Journey" approach. Watch Seasons 1 through 3, then pick and choose arcs based on which characters you like. If you love Frozen, Season 4a is your jam. If you’re a fan of Arthurian legend, Season 5a is where it’s at.
The show always worked best when it focused on Regina’s redemption. Seeing the Evil Queen go from a murderous monarch to a hero who actually earned her "Happy Ending" is arguably the best character arc in 2010s television. Lana Parrilla carried the emotional weight of the later years when the plots got a bit too "magic-macguffin" heavy.
Moving Forward: How to Experience the Lore Now
If you're done with the main show and want more, there are a few avenues that actually add value to the experience.
First, track down the short-lived spin-off, Once Upon a Time in Wonderland. It only ran for 13 episodes, but it’s a tight, self-contained story that features one of the best villains in the franchise: Jafar (the Naveen Andrews version, not the one from the main show). It feels more like Season 1 than the later years of the parent series.
Secondly, look into the "Henry’s Book" tie-in novels. They fill in some of the gaps in the Enchanted Forest timeline that the show never had the budget to film. For those who care about the "rules" of magic in the show—specifically the idea that "all magic comes with a price"—these books go deeper into the mechanics of the world.
To truly appreciate the seasons of Once Upon a Time, you have to accept it for what it is: a soap opera with magic wands. It isn't Game of Thrones. It’s a show about hope, findable happy endings, and the idea that no one is ever truly "lost" if someone is looking for them. Even when the writing got messy, the heart remained remarkably consistent.
Next Steps for Fans:
Start by re-watching the Season 1 pilot and the Season 6 finale back-to-back. You’ll see the full evolution of Emma Swan’s character from a cynical bail bonds person to a woman who believes in the impossible. If you’re looking for a fresh experience, seek out the Season 7 "alternate" versions of characters to see how the writers tried to subvert their own tropes one last time.