Look, the Sea of Thieves fish grind is a nightmare if you don't know the specific biomes. You’re sitting there on your sloop, staring at the water, hoping for a trophy, and instead, you keep pulling up Splashtails. It’s frustrating. Most players think fishing is just a side activity for when the wind is against you, but if you’re trying to hit Pirate Legend or just want that "Legendary Hunter of the Sea of Thieves" title, you need a strategy. This isn't just about clicking when the line vibrates. It’s about understanding bait logic, regional spawns, and the sheer RNG madness that Rare baked into the game.
The Brutal Reality of Sea of Thieves Fish Spawns
The game doesn't tell you that different fish require specific environmental triggers. You can’t just fish anywhere. If you’re in The Wilds, you’re getting Wildsplashes. In The Ancient Isles? Ancientscales. It sounds simple until you realize that some of the most valuable fish, like the Cloudy Plentifin or the Bone Ancientscale, have such low encounter rates that you might spend four hours and see zero.
Let's talk about the Stormfish. These are the kings of the frying pan. To catch them, you literally have to sail into the middle of a storm. Your boat is filling with water, lightning is trying to kill you, the compass is spinning like a top, and you’re trying to keep a line steady. It’s chaos. Honestly, it’s the most "Sea of Thieves" experience you can have. But here’s the kicker: if you want the Shadow Stormfish, which is basically the holy grail for Hunter's Call reps, you have to be in the storm and have incredible luck.
Why Your Bait Choice Is Probably Wrong
Most players just throw a hook in. Big mistake.
Earthworms, grubs, and leeches are your primary currencies here. If you are looking for Plentifins, you need earthworms. They only show up in The Shores of Plenty. If you use those same worms in The Wilds, you’re just wasting bait on common fish.
🔗 Read more: Amy Rose Sex Doll: What Most People Get Wrong
Leeches are for the Ancientscales. You find these in the south. Grubs? Those are for Wildsplashes in the murky, green waters of the northeast. If you aren't digging up the right bait for the right zone, you're basically just feeding the local Splashtail population for free.
The Secret Economy of the Hunter's Call
Merrick and his family at the Seaposts are picky. They don't just want raw fish; they want it "perfectly cooked." This is where most people mess up. If you undercook it, you lose gold. If you burn it, it’s worthless. You have to watch the eyes. When the fish's eyes turn white and the steam starts really billowing off the pan, that’s your window.
Pro tip: Trophy fish take longer to cook than regular ones. If you’re used to the timing of a small fish, you’ll pull the trophy off too early and end up with a "Rare" fish that's actually just raw and disappointing.
Finding the Rare Variants Without Going Insane
Every species has five variants. Usually, it's a common, a semi-rare, a location-specific, a night-specific, and the "Rare."
💡 You might also like: A Little to the Left Calendar: Why the Daily Tidy is Actually Genius
- Splashtails: The Ruby is everywhere. The Umber is the one you’ll rarely see.
- Pondies: You find these in fresh water, like the little lake at Hidden Spring Keep. The Bright Pondie is the rare one here, and it glows like a neon sign.
- Islehoppers: These don't need bait. At all. But they only spawn near specific islands. If you’re at Shipwreck Bay, you’ll find Moss Islehoppers. If you’re at Discovery Ridge, you’re looking for Stone Islehoppers. The Raven Islehopper is the rare one, and it’s notoriously annoying because it looks a lot like a common fish in low light.
Battling the RNG: Battlegills and Wreckers
If you want the real high-value hauls, you have to put yourself in danger. Battlegills only spawn near active Skeleton Ships or Forts. You’re literally fishing while cannons are screaming over your head. It’s high-stress, high-reward. You need grubs for these.
Then there are Wreckers. These only spawn near shipwrecks. You’ll need worms. The Snow Wrecker is arguably one of the rarest fish in the entire game. Many players have spent years on the seas without seeing a single one. It’s white, it’s elusive, and it’ll break your line if you blink.
The Midnight Fishing Strategy
Night fishing is a whole different beast. Some fish, like the Moonlight Lunker (a variant of the Splashtail) or any of the "glowing" variants, are much easier to spot when the sun goes down. However, it also makes you a massive target for other crews. A ship sitting still at a Seapost with its lights off is a universal signal for "I have a storage crate full of valuable fish, please sink me."
Always fish with your back to the open sea. Keep your eyes on the horizon. If you see a sail, get that fish in your pocket. You can keep five fish on your person, and those are safe even if your ship goes to the bottom of the Davy Jones’ locker.
📖 Related: Why This Link to the Past GBA Walkthrough Still Hits Different Decades Later
Advanced Tactics for the Legendary Hunter
If you're serious about finishing the Hunter's Call commendations, you need a crew. Fishing solo is a slow death. A four-man galleon can have four lines in the water. That quadruple's your chances of an RNG rare spawn. Plus, one person can stay on "cook duty" while the others keep the supply of fish coming in.
Also, check every shipwreck barrel you find. Seriously. A huge chunk of my rare fish collection didn't come from a rod; it came from looting the food barrels of sunken ships. Sometimes a crew will sink with a Forsaken Devilfish in their hold, and you can just scoop it up.
Dealing with the Kraken and Megalodons
Technically, these aren't "fish" you catch with a rod, but they are part of the Hunter's Call. Meat from a Kraken or a Megalodon is worth a fortune compared to a standard fish. If you kill one, cook the meat. It provides two "heals"—it fills your health bar and then gives you a secondary health reserve that regenerates over time. It's the best food in the game for PvP.
Actionable Steps for Your Next Session
Stop aimlessly throwing your line into the water at an outpost. If you want to actually progress, follow this workflow:
- Pick a target fish. Don't try to catch everything at once. Decide today is "Wrecker Day" or "Plentifin Day."
- Stock the right bait. Spend 10 minutes digging on an island before you start. Earthworms for Plentifins/Wreckers, Leeches for Ancientscales/Stormfish, Grubs for Wildsplashes/Battlegills.
- Head to the specific zone. Go to the Wilds for Wildsplashes or stay in the center of the map for Splashtails.
- Use the "Storage Crate" trick. Carry a storage crate to the end of a dock. It makes transferring fish and bait way faster than running back and forth to your ship's barrels.
- Check the Seapost barrels. Every time you sell at a Seapost (like North Star or The Finest Trading Post), check the barrels nearby. Sometimes the game spawns rare bait or even cooked fish right there.
- Patience is a resource. If a fish spawns and it’s a common one you already have, right-click to pull your line back in before they bite. It saves your bait and your time.
The grind to level 50 in Hunter's Call is the longest in the game, but it’s also the most relaxing if you embrace the pace. Just keep an eye out for those white fins.