Scotty The Ultimatum Ethnicity: Why Everyone Is Guessing
Honestly, the internet has a weird obsession with trying to pin down exactly where people come from the second they pop up on a Netflix reality show. Scotty Lewis from The Ultimatum: Marry or Move On Season 3 is the latest target of this deep-dive detective work. Since the season dropped in late 2024, fans have been scouring his Instagram and re-watching episodes just to find a crumb of info about his background.
You've probably seen the Reddit threads. Some people are convinced he’s Ethiopian because they think he looks like a "Temu version of The Weeknd" (their words, not mine!). Others are betting money he’s West Indian—specifically Guyanese or Trinidadian—citing his features and "vibes." Then there’s the theory that he’s half Sri Lankan and half Black American.
The reality? Scotty hasn't actually come out and handed everyone a DNA kit result. He’s 30, an influencer, and he definitely knows how to keep a polished image, but he hasn't made his specific heritage the centerpiece of his brand.
The Cultural Mystery vs. The Reality TV Drama
While everyone is busy arguing over Scotty The Ultimatum ethnicity, they're kind of missing the bigger picture of who he is on the show. He was one of the few guys to actually issue the ultimatum to his girlfriend, Aria De’Westbrooks. Usually, it's the other way around.
💡 You might also like: Songs by Tyler Childers: What Most People Get Wrong
Scotty identifies as Black, and throughout the show, his identity is centered within the Black American experience. However, the nuance of his specific ancestry—whether there’s South Asian, East African, or Caribbean blood in the mix—remains a topic of fan speculation rather than confirmed fact. On Reddit, users from the Guyanese and Trini communities have pointed out that he shares a "look" common in the Indo-Caribbean diaspora, which often features a blend of South Asian and African heritage.
Why the confusion?
People love to categorize.
- The Weeknd Comparisons: This is the big one. Because Abel Tesfaye is of Ethiopian descent, fans naturally jump to the conclusion that his look-alikes must share that Habesha background.
- The "Little Indian Boy" Comment: There was a super controversial moment on the show where Zaina’s original partner, J.R., made a comment about Scotty looking like a "little Indian boy." It was widely slammed as a micro-aggression, but it also sent search traffic for his ethnicity through the roof.
- Vague Social Media: Scotty’s Instagram is mostly high-end lifestyle shots, gym pics, and promotional content. He doesn't post much about "home" or family traditions that would give away a specific cultural heritage.
What We Actually Know About Scotty Lewis
Let’s stick to what’s actually on the screen and in the public record. Scotty is a 30-year-old influencer who was living long-distance from Aria (she’s an aesthetic nurse) before the show started. He’s very big on "traditional" roles, which became a massive point of contention. He wanted Aria to move to his city and basically fit into his life, while she was hesitant to drop her successful career.
📖 Related: Questions From Black Card Revoked: The Culture Test That Might Just Get You Roasted
During his trial marriage with Zaina Sesay, things got... intense. We saw a lot of what fans called "red flag" behavior—getting upset over her eating without him, lashing out during a game of beer pong, and that whole cryotherapy date disaster.
A Quick Profile of Scotty:
- Age: 30 (as of the 2024 filming).
- Occupation: Influencer / Reality TV Personality.
- Relationship Status: He proposed to Aria on the show, but they broke up literally the next day. At the reunion, they confirmed they were done for good.
- Hometown/Base: He’s been linked to the Atlanta area, which is a hub for many The Ultimatum and Love Is Blind cast members.
The South Asian and Caribbean Theories
If you look at the stats of the Caribbean diaspora in the U.S., a huge percentage of people from Guyana and Trinidad have "dougla" heritage—a mix of African and Indian ancestry. This would explain the features that have fans so curious.
Then you have the Sri Lankan theory. There was a comment on a popular reality TV blog suggesting he is "half Sri Lankan and half Black American," but again, there’s no birth certificate or interview where Scotty confirms this. It’s basically "internet lore" at this point.
👉 See also: The Reality of Sex Movies From Africa: Censorship, Nollywood, and the Digital Underground
Moving Past the Ethnicity Debate
At the end of the day, Scotty’s ethnicity doesn't change the fact that he became the "villain" of Season 3 for many viewers. Whether he’s Guyanese, Ethiopian, or just a Black American with a diverse gene pool, his actions on the show are what stuck with people. He admitted during an interview with Today after the show aired that he needs to go on a "journey of healing" and handle his "apprehension towards therapy."
That’s probably a better thing to focus on than trying to guess his DNA percentages.
What to do if you're still curious:
- Check the Reunion: The Season 3 reunion on Netflix gives the most "real" look at him post-show, though it focuses more on his breakup with Aria than his family tree.
- Follow the "Healing" Journey: If he actually follows through on that therapy promise, he might open up more about his childhood and background on his social channels.
- Watch for Brand Deals: Often, influencers will do heritage-based partnerships (like for Black History Month or AAPI Month) which usually clears up these questions once and for all.
The best way to get the truth is to wait for the man himself to speak. Until then, it's all just digital noise.