You’ve seen the show. You’ve heard the rumors. Honestly, the drama surrounding the scheana shay engagement ring has more plot twists than a Vanderpump Rules season finale. When Brock Davies finally popped the question on that rose-petal-covered balcony in Los Angeles, fans weren't just looking at the romance. They were staring at the massive, glowing pink rock on her finger.
It was huge. Like, "how do you even lift your hand" huge.
But immediately, the internet did what the internet does. People started nitpicking the stone, the price, and even how Brock paid for it. Let's get into the real story of this piece of jewelry, because there’s a lot of noise out there that just isn’t quite right.
The 12.74-Carat Elephant in the Room
Most people think a celebrity engagement ring has to be a diamond. If it’s not a diamond, it’s a "fake," right? Wrong. Scheana’s ring is a 12.74-carat rectangular cushion-cut rare pink morganite.
Morganite isn't some "mall kiosk" glass. It’s a variety of beryl—the same family that gives us emeralds and aquamarines. Kyle Chan, a close friend of the VPR cast and a legit celebrity jeweler, designed it specifically for her. He’s gone on record saying the stone represents "unconditional love."
Breaking Down the Specs:
- Center Stone: 12.74-carat rare pink morganite.
- The Band: 14-karat white gold.
- The Sparkle: 12 small diamonds embedded in the band itself.
- The Shape: A perfect rectangular cushion.
Scheana actually spoke out about this on Twitter because she was tired of the shade. She told fans she literally didn’t want a diamond. She wanted something different, something with "meaning." And let's be real—a 12-carat diamond of that color and clarity would cost more than most people’s houses.
The Three-Card Controversy: Was It a Joke?
This is where things get kinda messy. During the episode where Brock picks up the sparkler, we see him using multiple credit cards to finalize the purchase.
💡 You might also like: CSI Las Vegas Season 7: Why This Era Still Hits Different
The price tag? Around $25,000.
Fans dragged him for it. Hard. They pointed to his past issues with child support and questioned if he could actually afford a five-figure ring. Scheana later claimed it was an "Aussie humor" thing—that Brock thought it would be funny to put a little bit on each card.
Critics weren't buying it. Most people felt it looked like someone struggling to hit a credit limit. Whether it was a poorly timed joke or a genuine financial juggle, it became one of the most talked-about moments in VPR history.
The Mystery of the Ring "Upgrade"
Wait, did she swap it?
🔗 Read more: Drums of Autumn: Why This Outlander Installment Changes Everything
If you look at more recent photos or episodes, that giant pink morganite isn’t always there. Scheana eventually started wearing a 4-carat emerald-cut diamond ring.
This sparked a whole new wave of gossip. Did the morganite break? Did she hate it?
Actually, the morganite is just massive. It’s a "cocktail" style ring that isn't exactly practical for changing diapers or doing everyday tasks. She’s mentioned that the new diamond is her "daily" ring. It’s more traditional, sure, but it also reflects a different stage of their marriage.
💡 You might also like: What the Hell Avril Lavigne: Why This 2011 Hit Still Matters
Why This Ring Still Matters for Jewelry Trends
Regardless of the TV drama, Scheana’s choice actually signaled a huge shift in the wedding industry. We’re seeing more people move away from the "must-have diamond" rule.
- Color is in: Pink stones, sapphires, and emeralds are becoming mainstream for brides who want to stand out.
- Size vs. Stone Type: Brock chose a 12-carat morganite over a 1-carat diamond for the same price. For some, the "wow" factor of the size matters more than the mineral composition.
- Customization: Working with a jeweler like Kyle Chan allowed them to create something that fit Scheana’s specific aesthetic—flashy, pink, and impossible to miss.
What You Should Know Before Buying a Morganite
If you’re looking at Scheana’s ring and thinking you want something similar, there are some practical things to keep in mind. Morganite is beautiful, but it’s not a diamond.
- Hardness: On the Mohs scale, morganite is a 7.5 to 8. It’s durable, but it can scratch more easily than a diamond (which is a 10).
- Cloudiness: Morganite attracts oils. If you don't clean it constantly, it starts to look dull or "milky."
- Refraction: It has a different kind of "fire." It glows more than it sparkles.
The scheana shay engagement ring might be polarizing, but it’s 100% on-brand for her. It’s loud, it’s pink, and it forced everyone to have a conversation about what an engagement ring "should" look like.
If you are considering a non-traditional stone like morganite, focus on the "saturation" of the color. The deeper the pink, the more valuable the stone. Scheana’s was "rare" because it had a distinct pink hue without the orange undertones often found in cheaper versions. Check the settings carefully too; a stone that large needs a very secure 14k or 18k gold mount to stay in place.