You see him for the first time in Rogue One: A Star Wars Story, and he looks like a walking junkyard. Metal legs, a breathing mask, and eyes that have seen way too much fire. Most moviegoers probably thought Saw Gerrera was just some crazy guy living in a cave on Jedha. But honestly? He’s the most important person the Rebel Alliance ever tried to forget.
If you've only seen the movies, you're missing the real tragedy of the guy. He didn’t just wake up one day and decide to be a "terrorist." He was a freedom fighter long before Mon Mothma even considered picking up a blaster.
The Brutal Reality of Saw Gerrera in Rogue One
When we find Saw in Rogue One, he's basically the Rebel version of Darth Vader. Seriously. Look at the parallels. He’s more machine than man, he’s paranoid, and he’s isolated himself from everyone who once cared about him. Forest Whitaker plays him with this raspy, pressurized voice that sounds like he’s literally suffocating under the weight of his own choices.
He’s leading a group called the Partisans. These guys weren't the "clean" Rebels you see in A New Hope. They weren't wearing matching orange jumpsuits and following a chain of command. They were urban insurgents. In Rogue One, they're the ones throwing thermal detonators into crowded streets in Jedha City.
The Rebel Alliance—the "respectable" part led by Mon Mothma and Bail Organa—had actually cut ties with him. Why? Because Saw didn't care about "hearts and minds." He cared about dead Stormtroopers. To him, if you weren't actively fighting the Empire, you were part of the problem. That kind of black-and-white thinking is what made him so dangerous to the cause. He was the PR nightmare the Alliance couldn't control.
Why Jyn Erso Was His Biggest Failure
The relationship between Saw and Jyn is kinda heartbreaking if you look at the lore from the novel Catalyst. Saw was the one who rescued Jyn when she was a kid after her father, Galen, was taken by the Empire. He raised her. He taught her how to survive. He gave her a knife instead of a doll.
But then, he just dumped her.
📖 Related: Gwendoline Butler Dead in a Row: Why This 1957 Mystery Still Packs a Punch
In the movie, he says he abandoned her because people were starting to realize she was the daughter of a high-ranking Imperial scientist. He claims he did it to protect her. But you can see the doubt in Jyn’s eyes. He didn't just abandon her to save her; he abandoned her because he was becoming a monster and he knew it. By the time they reunite on Jedha, the trust is gone. He’s huffing gas from a tank and using a mind-reading octopus (the Bor Gullet) to torture Imperial defectors like Bodhi Rook.
Where Did Saw Actually Come From?
Most people don't realize that Saw Gerrera is actually a George Lucas original. Before Disney even bought Lucasfilm, George was developing a live-action show called Star Wars: Underworld. It never happened because it would have cost a fortune to film, but Saw was one of the characters George created for it.
Instead of wasting a good character, they put him in The Clone Wars animated series first.
The Onderon Days
Back then, Saw was a young, handsome revolutionary on his home planet, Onderon. He and his sister, Steela, were fighting a puppet government backed by the Separatists. Here’s the crazy part: he was actually trained by Anakin Skywalker and Ahsoka Tano.
- The Jedi taught him how to be a guerrilla fighter.
- They showed him how to use explosives and hit-and-run tactics.
- They essentially built the man who would eventually become their worst nightmare.
During the battle to free Onderon, Steela died. Saw blamed himself. That was the moment his soul started to rot. He realized that "winning" always costs more than you’re willing to pay.
The Tactics That Got Him Kicked Out of the Rebellion
If you watch Andor or read the book Rebel Rising, you get a much clearer picture of why the other Rebels hated him. Saw's Partisans weren't just fighting soldiers. They were targeting Imperial infrastructure, even if it meant civilian casualties.
👉 See also: Why ASAP Rocky F kin Problems Still Runs the Club Over a Decade Later
In Andor, there’s a great scene where Luthen Rael (played by Stellan Skarsgård) tries to get Saw to work with other Rebel cells. Saw just laughs at him. He calls them "neo-republicans," "separatists," and "human cultists." He’s so pure in his hatred for the Empire that he can’t stand to be in a room with anyone who has a different political vision.
He was right about one thing, though. Saw knew the Empire was building something terrible long before anyone else believed it. He was obsessed with finding out what was happening on Geonosis. He spent years tracking "Project Celestial Power" (the Death Star). While the Senate was still trying to "negotiate," Saw was out there getting his lungs scorched and his legs blown off trying to find the truth.
The "Terrorist" Label
Was he a terrorist? By our standards, yeah. He targeted non-combatants if they were Imperial sympathizers. He used torture. He didn't follow the "rules of war" because he believed the Empire had already broken those rules by existing.
The Rebel Alliance needed him to do the dirty work, but they didn't want him at the victory party. It’s a messy, grey area that Star Wars usually avoids, but Saw Gerrera forces you to look at it.
The Death of a Radical
Saw's end in Rogue One is fitting. He’s tired. He’s broken. When the Death Star fires its single-reactor shot at Jedha, he refuses to run.
"I will run no longer," he tells Jyn.
✨ Don't miss: Ashley My 600 Pound Life Now: What Really Happened to the Show’s Most Memorable Ashleys
He dies in the very blast he spent his whole life trying to prevent. It’s poetic, in a dark way. He passed the torch (and the hologram from Galen Erso) to Jyn, and she’s the one who eventually finishes the job. Without Saw, the Death Star plans never get to the Rebellion. Without Saw, the Empire wins.
But if Saw had survived? He probably would have hated the New Republic just as much as he hated the Empire. Men like him are built for the fight, not the peace.
What You Should Do Next
If you want to see the full evolution of Saw Gerrera, don't just stop at Rogue One.
- Watch The Clone Wars (Season 5, Episodes 2-5): This is the Onderon arc. You see the "hero" version of Saw before the trauma took over.
- Watch Andor: Forest Whitaker’s scenes in this show are some of the best acting in the entire franchise. It explains the political rift between the different Rebel factions perfectly.
- Play Jedi: Fallen Order: Saw actually shows up in this game as a younger, slightly less "cyborg" version of himself, leading a mission on Kashyyyk.
Seeing the character across different eras makes his death on Jedha hit way harder. He wasn't just a crazy old man; he was a guy who gave up everything—his body, his sister, and his sanity—to stop a monster. He just didn't realize he was becoming one in the process.
Next Step: Watch the "Onderon" arc in The Clone Wars to see how Anakin Skywalker's training directly influenced the tactics Saw uses in Rogue One.