Walk into Sandro’s Upper East Side on any given Tuesday, and you’ll likely see a large, boisterous man in a white apron moving between tables like a neighborhood mayor. That’s Sandro Fioriti. He’s been a fixture of the New York dining scene for decades, but if you think this is just another "red sauce" joint where you go for oversized meatballs and heavy parm, you’ve got it all wrong.
Honestly, Sandro’s is more of an escape hatch to Rome than a typical Manhattan restaurant.
The Upper East Side has plenty of spots that feel like they were designed by a corporate committee to look "timeless." Sandro’s is the real deal—slightly chaotic, fiercely traditional, and entirely family-run. Since moving to its newer home at 322 East 86th Street (the old Little Frog space) in 2022, the restaurant has managed to keep that "cluttered but cozy" soul that made its previous 81st Street location a cult favorite.
The Man Behind the Pasta Pot
Sandro Fioriti is a character. You’ve probably heard the stories—he’s the guy who famously wears bright orange clogs and won’t hesitate to tell you how to eat his food. He started at the bottom, peeling potatoes in Frascati before becoming a sous chef by age 17.
He first hit NYC in 1985. Back then, most Americans thought Italian food was just spaghetti and marinara. Sandro was the one introducing jaded New Yorkers to things they’d never seen, like sea urchin ravioli or fried tulips. He’s a bit of a nomad, too. He closed his original spot in 1992 to live in the Caribbean, eventually returning to the city to reopen and solidify his status as the UES "Pasta Maestro."
Today, it’s a full family affair. His wife, Anna, is the maitre d', and their son, Sandro Jr., handles the front-of-house operations. It’s that rare place where the owners actually live and breathe the floor every single night.
What to Actually Order (and What to Skip)
Most people walk in and look for the lasagna. Don't be that person. You’re at a Roman-style trattoria; act like it.
The Iconic Spaghettini al Limone
This is the dish that put him on the map. It sounds simple—basically just lemon and cream—but it’s a logic-defying explosion of citrus. It’s rich, yet the acidity cuts through it so cleanly that you’ll finish the plate before you even realize you’re full.
The Roman Classics
If you want to test the kitchen's mettle, order the Bucatini all’Amatriciana. It’s spicy, salty, and loaded with chunky bits of guanciale (pork cheek). Most places use pancetta because it’s easier to find, but Sandro stays true to the Roman roots.
Then there’s the Carciofi alla Giudia—fried artichokes. When they’re in season, Sandro literally flies them in from Rome. They come out looking like golden, crispy sunflowers. They are, quite frankly, the best version of this dish you will find outside of the Jewish Ghetto in Rome.
💡 You might also like: Why Men's Graphic Tees Vintage Styles Are Taking Over Your Closet Again
The "Hidden" Stars
- Spaghetti al Pomodoro: I know, it sounds boring. It’s not. It’s probably the most technically perfect version of tomato sauce in the zip code.
- Veal Scaloppine al Limone: Thin, tender, and so lemony it'll make your eyes widen.
- The Grissini: They bring out these long, house-made breadsticks at the start. They are dangerously addictive.
The Atmosphere: Expect Noise
Let’s be real for a second: if you’re looking for a hushed, romantic candlelit dinner where you can hear a pin drop, Sandro’s Upper East Side might not be your first choice. The room is 56 seats of pure energy. It gets loud. People are arguing in Italian, wine is flowing, and the waiters are moving fast.
The decor is simple. White walls, some framed photos, and a bar with eight seats that is perfect for a solo dinner of pasta and a glass of Brunello. It feels like a neighborhood "secret" that everyone happens to know about.
A lot of regulars—we’re talking high-profile tennis stars and Wall Street types—love it because it’s pretentious about the food but totally unpretentious about the vibe. You might even get a complimentary splash of grappa or a shot of peach liqueur at the end of your meal if the mood is right.
Why 322 East 86th Street Matters
The move from 81st Street was a big deal. For 16 years, the old spot was a landmark. When they closed in early 2022 due to lease issues "beyond their control," the neighborhood panicked. But the reopening on 86th Street happened faster than anyone expected.
The new space actually offers a bit more room, including a private dining area and a sidewalk cafe for when the weather isn't miserable. They even have a roadway setup for outdoor dining, though nothing beats being inside near the kitchen when the smell of sautéing garlic hits the air.
Making the Most of Your Visit
If you're planning a trip to Sandro's Upper East Side, here's the lowdown on how to do it right.
- Reservations are non-negotiable: Especially on weekends. It’s a small space and the loyalty of the UES crowd is fierce.
- Ask for the Specials: Sandro is a market-driven chef. If there’s wild boar ragu or porcini mushrooms on the handwritten specials list, get them.
- The "Sandro" Experience: If you see the chef, say hello. He loves talking about ingredients. Ask him where the olive oil comes from (likely Bona Furtuna in Sicily).
- Watch the Salt: Occasionally, the kitchen can be a little heavy-handed with the salt, particularly on the braised meats. If you're sensitive to it, stick to the lemon-based dishes or the pomodoro.
- Timing: If you want it a bit quieter, go at 5:00 PM when they open. By 7:30 PM, the "neighborhood party" is in full swing.
At the end of the day, Sandro’s survives because it doesn't try to be "cool." It doesn't care about Instagram aesthetics or TikTok food trends. It cares about whether the pasta is al dente and if you feel like you've been fed by family.
Actionable Next Steps
To get the most out of your visit to Sandro's, check their Instagram for daily market specials before you head out, as Chef Sandro often features rare Italian imports like Mentuccia herbs or specific Roman artichokes that aren't on the standard menu. When booking, specifically request a table in the main dining room if you want the full "Sandro" experience, or a bar seat if you're dining solo and want to watch the service choreography. Finally, ensure you bring a hearty appetite; the portions are traditional and the complimentary sugar cookies and liqueurs at the end are part of the ritual you won't want to decline.