You know that feeling when you watch a movie and just can’t imagine anyone else in those roles? That’s Sanam Teri Kasam. But honestly, the story of how Inder and Saru actually ended up on screen is almost as dramatic as the film’s tear-jerking climax. It wasn't some smooth corporate selection. It was a mess of missed deadlines, accidental auditions, and a massive gamble on two faces nobody in Bollywood really knew at the time.
Most people think Harshvardhan Rane was the first choice. He wasn’t.
The Inder that almost wasn't: How Harshvardhan Rane beat Vicky Kaushal
Let’s get into the nitty-gritty of the sanam teri kasam casting for the male lead. Directors Radhika Rao and Vinay Sapru were actually looking at a completely different roster. They had already shortlisted Ehan Bhat—who even trained for three months—and were literal hours away from a poster shoot.
Then Harshvardhan Rane walked in. He was four months late.
Basically, the casting was closed. Done. Dusted. The "guy" who was supposed to play Inder was actually sitting in the next room reading the script. Rane has openly admitted he had to "beg and plead" just for a chance to show them what he could do. He didn't care if they rejected him; he just wanted to perform.
💡 You might also like: Songs by Tyler Childers: What Most People Get Wrong
When he finally got his two minutes, he did that now-famous scene where he sheds his shirt in the elevator. The directors were floored. Vinay Sapru actually had tears in his eyes. They told Rane he'd "caused a lot of loss" because they had to scrap all the existing costumes and reschedule everything, but the role was his. Interestingly, one of the other actors who auditioned for the role and didn't make the cut was Vicky Kaushal. Imagine how different the movie would have felt with a pre-Uri Vicky instead of Rane’s raw, brooding Inder.
Why Mawra Hocane? The Saru decision
Casting Saraswati Parthasarathy was its own hurdle. The directors wanted someone who felt "pure" and deeply rooted in traditional values, inspired by the Sati character from the Shiva Puran. They weren't looking for a typical high-glam Bollywood star.
They chose Mawra Hocane, a Pakistani actress who had zero prior footprint in Indian cinema.
It was a risky move. People asked why they wouldn't just pick an Indian actress. But the directors were adamant that Mawra had this specific "vulnerability" that made the nerdy, introverted librarian Saru believable. She wasn't just playing a character; she was Saru. Her transformation from the girl-next-door to the tragic heroine is what gave the film its soul.
📖 Related: Questions From Black Card Revoked: The Culture Test That Might Just Get You Roasted
The supporting cast that grounded the tragedy
While the leads get all the glory, the sanam teri kasam casting of the supporting actors is why the emotional beats hit so hard.
- Manish Chaudhari as Saru’s father: His stern, almost frighteningly traditional portrayal created the perfect "curse" that drives the plot.
- Vijay Raaz: He brought that brief but essential touch of humanity and humor as Mushtaqeen Bhai.
- Murali Sharma: Always reliable, he played the inspector who, despite the law, felt the weight of Inder and Saru’s tragedy.
The 2026 Sequel: Why the original pair might never return
Fast forward to today, January 2026. The film is a certified cult classic, but the casting for the sequel has become a PR nightmare. Harshvardhan Rane has officially confirmed he's back for Sanam Teri Kasam 2, but there’s a massive catch.
He refused to work with Mawra Hocane again.
This isn't just about "creative differences." It’s political. Following some controversial remarks Mawra reportedly made about India's military operations, Rane took to social media to state he wouldn't share the screen with her if the original cast was repeated. It’s a messy situation that has left fans divided. Some want the Inder-Saru magic back at any cost, while others respect Rane's stance on national pride.
👉 See also: The Reality of Sex Movies From Africa: Censorship, Nollywood, and the Digital Underground
What we know about the new faces
The rumor mill is currently churning out names like Shraddha Kapoor for the lead in the sequel. While the directors have confirmed a "romantic saga" for Valentine's Day 2026, the producer, Deepak Mukut, has been vocal about owning the IP rights, leading to some internal friction.
If you're looking for the original "Inder-Saru" magic, you're likely only going to find it in the 2016 original. The sequel seems to be heading toward a fresh story with a new dynamic, even if Rane remains the anchor.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Aspiring Actors:
- Watch the 2016 original first: If you haven't seen the first one, the sequel's emotional weight won't land. The re-release in 2025 actually outperformed its original run, so the hype is real.
- Follow the official production handle: With the dispute between the directors and producer Deepak Mukut, only news from Soham Rockstar Entertainment is currently "official" regarding the sequel's cast.
- Study Rane’s audition story: For actors, Harshvardhan’s journey is a lesson. He wasn't the first choice, he was late, and he was an outsider. Sometimes, "begging for a chance" actually works if you have the talent to back it up.
The legacy of the original sanam teri kasam casting remains a rare example of a film that failed at the box office but won the internet years later because the actors were just that right for the roles.