You probably recognize the name from The Irishman. In Martin Scorsese's mob epic, Salvatore Sally Bugs Briguglio is the guy with the thick glasses who gives Frank Sheeran a hard time about a fish in a car. He’s played as a bit of a quirky, high-strung enforcer. But the real-life Sal Briguglio wasn't just a movie sidekick. Honestly, he was one of the most feared hitmen in the Genovese crime family, and if you talk to the right FBI agents or historians, they'll tell you Frank Sheeran didn't kill Jimmy Hoffa.
Sal did.
Most people get the story wrong because of Hollywood. They think the "Irishman" pulled the trigger in a house in Detroit. But the evidence? It points toward a short, wiry guy from New Jersey who knew how to make people disappear. Briguglio was a business agent for Teamsters Local 560 in Union City, but that was just his day job. His real work happened in the shadows.
The Ruthless Reality of Sally Bugs
Briguglio wasn't some bumbling mobster. Born in Union City, New Jersey, in 1930, he served in the Army during the Korean War before finding his way into the Genovese family. He became the right-hand man for Anthony "Tony Pro" Provenzano. If Tony Pro had a problem, Sal fixed it.
He didn't just kill people. He reportedly tortured them. Some estimates suggest he was responsible for over 50 hits. One of the most gruesome was the murder of Anthony Castellitto in 1961. Castellitto was a union rival who had the nerve to get more votes than Provenzano. Briguglio allegedly beat him with a lead-filled rubber hose and strangled him. Then, he reportedly put the body through a woodchipper.
That’s the kind of man we’re talking about. Brutal. Efficient. Total silence.
🔗 Read more: How Much Did Trump Add to the National Debt Explained (Simply)
Why the Hoffa Case Always Leads Back to Sal
When Jimmy Hoffa vanished from the Machus Red Fox restaurant on July 30, 1975, the FBI started looking at the "New Jersey faction." Hoffa was supposed to meet Tony Pro to bury the hatchet.
The "Hoffex Memo," which is basically the FBI's internal bible on the case, names Salvatore Sally Bugs Briguglio as a primary suspect. The theory isn't that Sheeran did it. The theory is that Sal, his brother Gabriel, and Thomas Andretta were the ones in the car.
- The Car: A 1975 Mercury Marquis.
- The Driver: Chuckie O’Brien (Hoffa’s foster son).
- The Muscle: Sal Briguglio.
Investigative reporter Dan Moldea, who has spent decades on this, is convinced Sal was the trigger man. He argues that Sheeran was just a "friendly face" used to lure Hoffa into the car. Once they got to the house, Sal took over.
The Little Italy Rubout
If you live by the sword, you know how the rest goes. By 1978, the walls were closing in on the Teamsters and the Genovese family. Sal was facing a massive federal trial for the Castellitto murder. There were rumors. There are always rumors in that world.
The bosses were worried. Would Sal flip to save himself?
💡 You might also like: The Galveston Hurricane 1900 Orphanage Story Is More Tragic Than You Realized
On March 21, 1978, at about 11:15 PM, Sal was walking toward the Andrea Doria Social Club on Mulberry Street in Manhattan’s Little Italy. Two men came out of the shadows. They didn't say a word. They knocked him to the ground and shot him five times—four in the face and one in the chest.
He died on the sidewalk in a brown leather jacket and a plaid shirt. He was 48.
The killers ran to a light blue Mercury—ironic, right?—and vanished. To this day, nobody has been charged with his murder. It was a classic mob hit. Clean. Professional. Dead men don't testify.
Fact vs. Fiction in The Irishman
It’s worth noting where the movie gets it wrong. In the film, Sal is killed in 1979. In reality, it was March '78. Also, the movie makes it look like Frank Sheeran was involved in Sal’s hit. There is zero evidence for that. Most experts believe the Genovese family handled their own "house cleaning."
Also, the glasses. In the movie, they are a character quirk. In real life, Sal really did wear those thick frames. He looked more like an accountant than a guy who would put you in a woodchipper. That was part of what made him so dangerous.
📖 Related: Why the Air France Crash Toronto Miracle Still Changes How We Fly
What This Means for the Hoffa Mystery Today
Even though Salvatore Sally Bugs Briguglio has been dead for nearly 50 years, his name comes up every time a new "lead" appears in the Hoffa case. When the FBI dug up a field in Jersey or searched under a bridge, they weren't looking for Sheeran’s ghost. They were looking for Sal’s work.
Here is what we actually know:
- Sal was in Detroit the day Hoffa vanished.
- He had the motive (loyalty to Tony Pro).
- He had the "skill set" for high-profile executions.
- His own family eventually saw him as a liability.
The mystery of Jimmy Hoffa might never be "solved" with a body, but for those who have studied the files, the trail ends at Sal. He was the enforcer who didn't seek the spotlight, which is exactly why he was so good at his job.
Lessons from a Mob Life
If there’s an "actionable insight" here, it’s about the reality of organized crime versus the glamour we see on screen. Briguglio’s life wasn't a series of cool dialogues. It was a life of paranoia, brutal violence, and an inevitable end on a cold sidewalk in Little Italy.
For those researching the Teamsters' history or the Genovese family, focus on the Local 560 records and the Castellitto murder trial. That is where the real Sal Briguglio exists—in the court transcripts and the FBI surveillance logs, not just in a Netflix stream.
To dig deeper into this era of American history, look for Dan Moldea’s book The Hoffa Wars. It’s widely considered the gold standard for understanding how guys like Sal operated. You can also review the declassified FBI "Hoffex" files, which are now accessible through various freedom of information archives. They provide a much grittier, less "Hollywood" version of how the most famous disappearance in American history likely went down.
Next Steps for Research:
- Examine the 1976 indictment papers for the Anthony Castellitto murder.
- Compare the "Hoffex Memo" suspects with the narrative presented in I Heard You Paint Houses.
- Visit the Mob Museum’s digital archives for photos of the Andrea Doria Social Club crime scene.