Honestly, if you grew up in the late '90s, you didn't just watch Sabrina Spellman learn how to turn her teacher into a pineapple. You watched for the cat. Specifically, Salem Saberhagen, the black American Shorthair with a rapier wit and a weirdly stiff neck. He wasn't just a pet. He was a disgraced warlock, a failed dictator, and arguably the most relatable character on the ABC TGIF lineup.
Salem was the soul of Sabrina the Teenage Witch.
But there’s a lot more to him than just being a talking puppet with a penchant for eating frozen pizza. Most people remember the sarcasm, but they forget the actual lore. Salem’s history is a messy mix of 1960s comic book roots and '90s sitcom gold. He’s a guy who tried to conquer the world and ended up stuck in a body that’s basically 10 pounds of fur and bad attitude.
The Crime That Cost Him Everything
Why was he a cat? It’s the question every newcomer asks. The answer is basically the plot of a Bond villain movie that went horribly wrong.
Salem wasn't born a feline. He was a high-ranking warlock who got a little too ambitious. Specifically, he attempted to take over the world. We’re talking full-scale global domination. He had a whole manifesto and everything.
The Witches' Council—the magical version of the Supreme Court, but with more pointy hats—didn't find his coup attempt particularly funny. They sentenced him to 100 years as a cat to teach him some humility. By the time the show starts in 1996, he’d already served about 25 years of his sentence. Imagine being a powerful sorcerer one day and then suddenly having an intense urge to chase a laser pointer the next.
🔗 Read more: Cast of Troubled Youth Television Show: Where They Are in 2026
It wasn't just a solo job
He didn’t act alone, either. Salem had a whole crew. His primary accomplice, a guy named Duke, also got turned into a cat, though he didn't stick around the Spellman household.
The punishment was designed to be humiliating. He was stripped of his magic, his human form, and his dignity. He was sent to live with Hilda Spellman because she was one of his followers during the attempted takeover. In a way, the Spellman house was his halfway house.
The Man Behind the Meow: Nick Bakay
You can’t talk about Salem on Sabrina the Teenage Witch without talking about Nick Bakay. He didn't just provide the voice; he was a writer on the show.
That’s why Salem’s dialogue feels so different from everyone else’s. It’s sharper. It’s more cynical. Bakay brought a specific kind of "guy at the end of the bar" energy to a talking cat.
He once described Salem as a "megalomaniac trapped in a fur coat."
💡 You might also like: Cast of Buddy 2024: What Most People Get Wrong
The Puppet vs. The Real Cats
Maintaining the illusion of a talking cat in the '90s was a nightmare. They used a combination of three different "methods" to bring him to life:
- The Animatronic Puppet: This is the one we all remember. It had a motorized mouth and could move its head. It looked... okay for the time, but as the seasons went on, the fur started looking a bit matted. It’s famously stiff.
- Live Cats: For scenes where Salem had to actually move, walk, or jump, they used real black cats. About 13 different cats were used throughout the series. They were "specialists." One was good at jumping, another was good at sitting still, and another was basically just there to look pretty.
- CGI: Very rarely, they used early computer-generated imagery for mouth movements on the real cats. It usually looked terrifying.
Why We Still Love a Failed Dictator
Salem is surprisingly deep. Underneath the jokes about world domination and lizard flakes (his favorite snack), there’s a real sense of tragedy.
He misses being human. There are episodes where he tries to find a loophole to get his body back, and it’s usually played for laughs, but you kinda feel for the guy. He has a daughter named Annabelle who he can’t really interact with properly. He has an ex-girlfriend who he still pines for.
He’s a mentor, too.
Sabrina often goes to Salem for advice because her aunts, Zelda and Hilda, are either too strict or too flighty. Salem gives her the "real" advice—even if it’s usually motivated by how it can help him get a snack. He’s the one who tells her to use magic to cut corners, which always backfires, but hey, that’s how she learns.
📖 Related: Carrie Bradshaw apt NYC: Why Fans Still Flock to Perry Street
The Best Salem-isms
The internet is basically built on Salem Saberhagen memes now. Here are a few things he did that were peak cat-energy:
- Crying over his own reflection because he’s "too beautiful."
- Trying to become a famous singer or a professional gambler.
- Writing in Sabrina’s diary (which he claims is his "research").
- His obsession with food, specifically anything involving dairy or fish.
The Different Versions of the Character
If you’ve seen the Netflix reboot, Chilling Adventures of Sabrina, you might have been disappointed. In that version, Salem doesn't talk. He’s a "familiar," a goblin-like spirit who takes the form of a cat to protect Sabrina. He’s cool, but he’s not our Salem.
The original 1962 comics had a different Salem, too. In the early Archie Comics, he was often an orange tabby who didn't speak at all. It wasn't until the '90s show became a massive hit that the comics changed him to the black, talking warlock we know today.
There was also a short-lived animated series where he was much more of a "cartoon" villain, but it lacked the dry, adult-skewing wit that Nick Bakay brought to the live-action show.
Actionable Takeaways: How to Channel Your Inner Salem
You don't have to be a cursed warlock to live like Salem. If you're looking to bring a bit of that 90s magic into your life, start here:
- Watch the "Salem's Best Moments" compilations: They're all over YouTube. If you’re having a bad day, five minutes of a puppet cat complaining about his "diminished status" is a guaranteed cure.
- Adopt a black cat: Black cats have the lowest adoption rates in shelters because of old superstitions. Salem single-handedly tried to fix that image in the 90s. They’re actually the best.
- Check out Nick Bakay’s other work: He was a huge part of The Angry Beavers and The King of Queens. You’ll hear that iconic voice everywhere once you start looking.
- Revisit the 1996 pilot: It’s interesting to see how different he looked and sounded before the writers really found his "voice."
Salem Saberhagen remains one of the few things from '90s TV that actually holds up. He wasn't just a gimmick. He was a fully realized character who happened to be made of fiberglass and fake fur. He reminds us that even if you’re currently stuck in a "cat" phase of your life—powerless and ignored—you can still be the funniest person in the room.
He’s the king of the one-liners. He’s the warlock we deserve. And honestly, he probably would have been a better world leader than most of the people he was trying to overthrow. At least there would have been more naps.