Football is a funny game. We talk about tactical masterclasses and billion-pound squads like they’re the only thing that matters, but then a match like Saints vs Man City happens and rips up the script. It’s the ultimate David vs. Goliath, except David sometimes shows up with a tactical possession game that makes Goliath look a bit confused.
If you look at the 2024/25 season, Southampton were literally battling to avoid being named the worst team in Premier League history. They were sitting on 11 points—the same as that infamous Derby County side—before they faced Pep Guardiola’s Manchester City in May 2025. On paper? A slaughter. In reality? A 0-0 draw that saw City fire 26 shots without finding the net.
That’s the thing about this fixture. You can never quite trust the form book.
The Night the Logic Died at St Mary's
Honestly, the most recent clash in May 2025 was a fever dream for any Saints fan. City were chasing a top-five spot for Champions League qualification, and Southampton were effectively already relegated. But interim manager Simon Rusk did something Russell Martin had refused to do all season: he parked the bus.
It was ugly. It was "anti-football" according to Rúben Dias. But it worked.
Aaron Ramsdale was a man possessed, making save after save while Taylor Harwood-Bellis and Jan Bednarek played like their lives depended on every block. City had 72% possession. They had the expected goals (xG). They had Erling Haaland back from an ankle injury. Yet, they couldn't buy a goal.
📖 Related: Australian Open Tennis Tickets 2025: Why Most People Pay Too Much
Why Erling Haaland struggles against Southampton
It sounds crazy to say the world's best striker struggles against a relegated side, but the numbers are weirdly specific. In that 0-0 draw, Haaland had just five touches in the first half. Five.
When teams sit that deep, there’s no space for him to sprint into. He becomes a target man in a crowded box, and if the delivery isn't inch-perfect, he gets swallowed up.
- Shot count: 26 for City, 2 for Saints.
- Result: 0-0.
- The Upset: Omar Marmoush almost won it for Southampton at the death, hitting the crossbar in stoppage time.
Imagine the scenes if that had gone in.
Russell Martin vs Pep Guardiola: The Possession War
Earlier in the 2024/25 campaign, we saw the other side of Saints vs Man City. Russell Martin, a man so committed to passing out from the back he’d probably try it in a hurricane, actually earned Pep’s respect.
Guardiola isn't exactly known for handing out participation trophies, but after City’s narrow 1-0 win at the Etihad in October 2024, he was glowing. He said he would "learn a lot" from Martin. Think about that for a second. The man who won everything at Barcelona, Bayern, and City was taking notes on a manager whose team was bottom of the league.
👉 See also: Miami vs Virginia Tech: What Most People Get Wrong About This Rivalry
"The build-up is exceptional. They open the channels. They link well with the striker and every moment makes sense." — Pep Guardiola, October 2024.
The problem? Saints were basically playing City’s own game against them, but with less expensive players. It was brave, maybe even "self-defeating stupidity" as some critics called it, but it made for fascinating football. They had 43% possession at the Etihad. Most teams go there and don't see the ball for ten minutes at a time.
Historical Context: A Rivalry of Extreme Margins
If you want to understand why this fixture feels so unpredictable, you have to look at the history. It’s not just recent draws and narrow wins.
- The 2-0 Carabao Cup Stunner (2023): Everyone expected a City stroll. Instead, Sekou Mara and Moussa Djenepo scored before half-time, and City didn't even register a shot on target.
- The 6-1 Drubbing (2018): Then you have the days where City just decide to be City. Sterling and Agüero were unplayable.
- The 1910 Beginning: Their first meeting was a 5-0 win for City in the FA Cup. It took Southampton 16 years to get revenge with a 4-3 thriller.
Across 103 meetings, City lead the way with 42 wins to Southampton's 33. It's closer than people think. In the Premier League era, though, the gap has widened. City have 23 wins to Saints' 7 since 1992.
What Most People Get Wrong About This Matchup
People see "Saints vs Man City" and assume it’s a foregone conclusion. They think it's just about holding on for 90 minutes.
But Southampton’s DNA, especially under the current regime, isn't about just defending. Even when they’re losing, they try to control the tempo. This creates a weird tactical stalemate where City can't just counter-attack because they have the ball, and Southampton won't just hoof it because they want to play.
It leads to these high-tension, low-scoring games where one mistake—like a Flynn Downes misplaced pass or a Matheus Nunes cross—decides everything.
Tactical Keys to Watching This Game
If you're watching a future clash, look at the full-backs. Pep loves to invert them. Rico Lewis or Josko Gvardiol will drift into midfield to create a 3-2 build-up.
Southampton usually counter this by using their wing-backs to pin City’s "midfield" full-backs wide. If Saints can force City to play down the wings rather than through the middle, they have a chance. That’s exactly how they secured that 0-0 draw in May 2025.
✨ Don't miss: Jerry West LA Lakers: Why He Was the Heart of the Franchise Long After He Stopped Playing
Actionable Takeaways for the Next Encounter
If you are looking to understand how the next Saints vs Man City match will go, don't just look at the table. Here is how to actually analyze it:
- Check the Lineup for a "Target Man": If Southampton start a physical striker like Paul Onuachu (or whoever is the current big man), they aren't planning to play through the lines. They're looking for an out-ball.
- Watch the First 15 Minutes of Possession: If Saints have more than 40% of the ball early on, City might get frustrated. Frustrated City players make uncharacteristic fouls.
- Monitor the xG vs. Reality: City will always have a higher xG. The question is whether the Saints keeper (likely Ramsdale or his successor) is having a "one of those days" performances.
- Account for the "Pep Rotation": Guardiola often rotates heavily for this fixture, especially if it falls between Champions League legs. This is when the upsets happen.
Southampton are currently fighting their way through the Championship in early 2026, but the lessons from their 2025 stalemate against City remain. They proved that even the "worst" team can halt the most expensive machine in world football if the tactics—and a bit of luck from the crossbar—align perfectly.
To stay ahead of the next tactical shift, track the average position of City’s holding midfielder. If they’re pushed beyond the center circle within the first ten minutes, expect a long night of defending for the Saints. Conversely, if Southampton manage to string ten passes together in their own half without losing it, you're in for a much more competitive game than the betting odds suggest.