You’ve probably heard the phrase "the dark night of the soul." It’s everywhere. People use it to describe a bad breakup, a career slump, or just a week where everything feels like it's falling apart. But the man who actually coined that phrase, Saint John of the Cross, wasn't talking about a bad mood. He was talking about something much more radical. He was talking about a total internal demolition.
John of the Cross was a 16th-century Spanish mystic, a priest, and a rebel who got tossed into a tiny, freezing prison cell by his own friends. He spent nine months in a space barely big enough for his body, treated like a traitor. And yet, that’s where the poetry started. It’s weird, honestly. You’d expect bitterness, but instead, we got some of the most beautiful literature in the Spanish language.
He didn't see the "darkness" as a punishment. For him, the darkness was a doorway. If you’re trying to understand why this guy still matters in 2026, it’s because he provides a roadmap for what to do when your internal world goes silent.
The Prison Cell That Changed Everything
Most people think of saints as these pristine figures floating on clouds. John was the opposite. He was born Juan de Yepes y Álvarez in 1542 in a small village near Ávila, Spain. His family was dirt poor. His father died young, and his brother died of malnutrition. Life was hard.
When he eventually joined the Carmelites, he met Teresa of Ávila. She was a powerhouse. She wanted to reform the order—go back to the "discalced" (shoeless) roots of poverty and prayer. John was all in. But the "Calced" Carmelites? They weren't fans. They kidnapped him in 1577.
They locked him in a monastery in Toledo. It was basically a closet. No light except for a tiny slit high up in the wall. He was fed bread and water and the occasional sardine. He was publicly lashed. This wasn't some spiritual retreat; it was torture. But here’s the kicker: in that literal and metaphorical darkness, John didn't break. He started composing poems in his head.
He didn't have paper at first. He memorized the verses. When he finally escaped—and his escape was like something out of an action movie, involving knotted bedsheets and jumping over a wall into the dark—he brought those poems with him. Those poems, like The Spiritual Canticle and The Dark Night, became the foundation of his entire philosophy.
What Most People Get Wrong About the Dark Night
Let’s get one thing straight. Saint John of the Cross didn't think the "dark night" was clinical depression. While the symptoms might look similar—loss of interest in things you used to love, a feeling of emptiness, a sense of being lost—the "night" John describes is specific.
✨ Don't miss: Green Emerald Day Massage: Why Your Body Actually Needs This Specific Therapy
It’s the "passive night of the senses."
Basically, John argues that we get addicted to "spiritual sugar." We like the good feelings of meditation or the "high" of doing a good deed. But eventually, if you want to grow, those feelings have to go away. Why? Because as long as you’re chasing the feeling of being good, you’re still focused on yourself.
The darkness is God (or the Universe, depending on how you want to frame it) pulling the rug out from under you so you learn to walk on your own. It’s a stripping away of the ego. It’s painful. It feels like death. But John insists it’s actually a "sheer grace."
He uses the image of a log being thrown into a fire. At first, the log is cold and wet. When the fire hits it, it doesn't look pretty. It smokes. It turns black. It smells bad. It looks like it’s being destroyed. But eventually, the fire dries out the wood, and the log becomes the fire. That’s the goal. Not to watch the fire, but to be transformed into it.
The Three Signs of the Night
How do you know if you're actually in the "Dark Night" or if you're just having a rough time? John actually lays out specific markers in The Ascent of Mount Carmel. He was surprisingly psychological for a guy living 500 years ago.
- First Sign: You find no pleasure or comfort in the things of God, but you also find no pleasure in anything else. It's a total state of "meh." If you were just being worldly, you'd find pleasure in distractions. If you're in the night, even the distractions feel empty.
- Second Sign: You feel like you're not doing anything, and it bothers you. You feel like you're wasting time. You think you're backsliding because the "spark" is gone.
- Third Sign: You find it impossible to meditate or use your imagination like you used to. Your mind just goes blank.
If you hit all three, John says: "Stay still." Don't try to force the old feelings back. You can't. The "night" is doing the work for you. You just have to let it happen. It’s about "attentive loving waiting."
Why the Poetry Matters More Than the Prose
If you read John’s prose—his explanations of his poems—it can be dense. He writes like a lawyer-philosopher. It’s heavy on Scholasticism. But the poetry? That’s where the soul is.
🔗 Read more: The Recipe Marble Pound Cake Secrets Professional Bakers Don't Usually Share
Take The Dark Night poem. It’s a love story. It’s about a woman sneaking out of her house at night to meet her lover. It’s erotic, risky, and full of movement.
"On a darkened night,
Kindled in love with yearnings—oh, happy chance!—
I went forth unobserved,
My house being now all stilled."
Notice the house being "stilled." That’s his way of saying his passions and his ego finally shut up. Only when the "house" is quiet can he slip out into the night. It’s a paradox: the darkness is what allows the union to happen. You can’t see the stars when the sun is out.
The Practical Side of a 16th-Century Rebel
John wasn't just some guy staring at a wall. He was an administrator. He traveled thousands of miles across Spain on foot and by mule. He founded monasteries. He was a spiritual director to hundreds of people.
He was known for being incredibly kind but also incredibly blunt. He hated "spiritual kitsch." He didn't like people getting obsessed with visions or statues or "holy" objects. He thought all of that was just more "stuff" cluttering the soul. He once famously told a nun to stop worrying about her visions and go eat some good food. He was grounded.
His advice for life was simple: Nada.
This is his famous "Nada" doctrine. To get to the "All," you have to be willing to have the "nothing." If you're clinging to your reputation, your possessions, or even your "spiritual progress," you're too full. You have to be empty to be filled.
💡 You might also like: Why the Man Black Hair Blue Eyes Combo is So Rare (and the Genetics Behind It)
The Controversy and the Legacy
Not everyone loved him then, and not everyone loves him now. Some critics think John is too world-denying. They argue his "Nada" is a bit too close to nihilism. Even in his own time, the Inquisition kept a very close eye on him. They were suspicious of anyone claiming they could have a direct, "dark" union with God without needing a mountain of church rituals in between.
But the 20th and 21st centuries have seen a massive resurgence in interest. T.S. Eliot borrowed heavily from him in Four Quartets. Thomas Merton, the famous Trappist monk, was obsessed with him. Even psychologists like Carl Jung saw in John a profound understanding of the "shadow" and the process of individuation.
The reality is that Saint John of the Cross provides a framework for suffering that isn't about "fixing" it. In a culture that is obsessed with "toxic positivity" and "hustle culture," John’s message is the ultimate counter-culture. He’s saying that the moments when you feel most empty and most "in the dark" might actually be the most productive moments of your life.
Actionable Insights: Applying the "Dark Night" Today
You don't have to be a monk to use John's wisdom. Whether you’re a believer or a secular seeker, the "Dark Night" framework offers a way to navigate life's inevitable voids.
- Reframe the Silence: When you hit a wall in your creative work, your relationships, or your inner life, don't immediately try to "hack" it. Instead of asking "How do I get out of this?", ask "What is this emptiness trying to clear out?"
- Practice "Nada" (Letting Go): Identify one thing you are clinging to for your sense of identity—it could be your job title, your social media presence, or even a specific "good person" narrative you tell yourself. Practice mentally detaching from it for five minutes a day.
- The House Being Stilled: We live in a world of constant noise. John’s "stilled house" refers to the senses. Try 20 minutes of literal silence. No podcasts. No music. No "productive" thinking. Just sitting in the "darkness" of the present moment.
- Value the Poetry Over the Plan: Logic only gets you so far. When life feels chaotic, look to art, poetry, and symbols rather than just "how-to" guides. Sometimes a metaphor (like the log in the fire) explains your pain better than a diagnostic manual ever could.
- Distinguish Between Depression and Desolation: If you’re feeling empty, check John’s "Three Signs." If you still have the capacity for pleasure in hobbies or food, it’s probably not a "dark night." If everything feels equally gray despite your best efforts, it might be a season of pruning. (Of course, always consult a professional for mental health—John would likely agree that the body needs care before the soul can fly).
Saint John of the Cross reminds us that the end of our rope isn't the end of the world. It’s often just the beginning of a different kind of sight—one that doesn't need the sun to see what's real.
Next Steps for Deepening Your Understanding
To truly grasp the nuance of John’s work, start by reading his poetry first, specifically The Dark Night of the Soul and The Living Flame of Love. Avoid the dense theological commentaries until you’ve sat with the verses themselves. For a modern perspective on how these 16th-century ideas map onto modern psychology, Gerald May’s book The Dark Night of the Soul is the definitive bridge between John’s mysticism and contemporary mental health. Finally, if you want to see the physical reality of his life, researching the architecture of 16th-century Toledo provides a stark context for the "narrow way" he described.