You’ve probably driven through it and barely blinked. Or maybe you stopped for gas on Route 25A and thought, "This place is kinda quiet." Honestly, that’s exactly how the locals like it. Saint James New York is a weird, beautiful, and deeply stubborn slice of Long Island that refuses to turn into just another suburban strip mall.
People think it’s just a sleepy hamlet in Smithtown. They're wrong. It’s actually one of the most historically dense and culturally "stubborn" places in the United States.
The General Store That Won't Quit
Basically, the heart of this place is the St. James General Store. It’s not a recreation. It’s not a museum piece with actors in bonnets. It is the oldest continuously operating general store in the country. Built in 1857 by Ebenezer Smith—who was a descendant of the legendary "Bull" Smith—it has seen everything.
It survived the Civil War. It survived the Great Depression. It survived the rise of Amazon.
When you walk in, the floorboards groan in a way that feels like a conversation. The lighting is dim. It smells like old wood and cinnamon. You can still buy pickles from a barrel and penny candy that actually costs more than a penny now, but the vibe is the same. In the late 1800s, this was the town’s first post office and held the first telephone in the area. Today, it’s where you go to remember that the world wasn't always digital.
✨ Don't miss: Am I Gay Buzzfeed Quizzes and the Quest for Identity Online
Why the "Glitterati" Loved It
There was a time when Saint James New York was basically the Hamptons before the Hamptons existed. In the early 20th century, the LIRR brought a flood of stage and screen stars.
We’re talking names like:
- Buster Keaton (the man who literally invented the stunt)
- Irving Berlin (who probably hummed "God Bless America" while looking at the harbor)
- The Barrymores (Lionel, Ethel, and John all hung out here)
- Myrna Loy
They didn't come here for the nightlife. There isn't any. They came because the North Shore has these jagged, rocky beaches and hidden inlets that felt a thousand miles away from the chaos of Manhattan. Even today, if you head up toward Deepwells Farm, you can feel that old-world ghost. William Jay Gaynor, a former Mayor of New York City, lived there. He was the guy who got shot in the neck while boarding a ship to Europe and just... kept being mayor for a while. That’s the kind of energy this town was built on.
The 2026 Real Estate Reality
Let’s be real for a second. If you’re looking to move to Saint James New York in 2026, you need a healthy bank account. As of January 2026, the median sale price for a home here is hovering around $731,000, and that’s for something that might still need a new kitchen.
🔗 Read more: Easy recipes dinner for two: Why you are probably overcomplicating date night
Inventory is tight. Super tight.
Homes often go pending in under 20 days. You’ve got the Fairfield at St. James community for the 55+ crowd, which is huge and keeps the median age around 47, but the single-family homes near the Harbor are where the real competition is. Most of these houses were built in the 70s, but you'll find plenty of pre-1940s gems if you’re willing to deal with the "character" (read: expensive repairs) of an older foundation.
Hidden Gems and Local Life
If you want to live like a local, you don't go to the big chains. You go to Energy Fitness on 25A if you want to see everyone you know. You take the kids to Veterans Memorial Park.
But the real secret? The trails.
💡 You might also like: How is gum made? The sticky truth about what you are actually chewing
The Avalon Nature Preserve is just a stone's throw away in Stony Brook, but Saint James residents treat it like their backyard. It’s 216 acres of "I can’t believe I’m still on Long Island" beauty. Also, don't sleep on the local food scene. It's not trendy, but it’s consistent. You want a bagel? You go to the local spots where they’ve been boiling them the right way for thirty years.
What You Need to Know Before You Visit
- The Train Station: The St. James station house is the second-oldest on Long Island. It’s tiny. It looks like a movie set. If you're commuting to the city, it's about a 90-minute trek, so bring a book.
- The Beaches: These aren't the sandy, flat beaches of the South Shore. These are North Shore beaches. They are rocky. They are cold. But the sunsets over the Long Island Sound? Unbeatable.
- The Names: You’ll hear "Nissequogue" and "Head of the Harbor." These are technically separate incorporated villages, but they share the 11780 zip code and the Saint James identity. It’s all one big, leafy family.
Saint James New York isn't trying to impress you. It isn't trying to be the next big "it" destination. It’s a place that values history, privacy, and the fact that you can still buy a wooden toy at a store that's been standing since before the lightbulb was invented.
Actionable Next Steps
If you’re planning a trip or a move, here’s how to actually experience the hamlet:
- The Saturday Morning Routine: Start at the General Store on Moriches Road right when they open. Grab some tea or vintage candy.
- The Deepwells Hike: Walk the grounds of Deepwells Farm County Park. Check their calendar for the "Deepwells Mansion" events—they often have craft fairs or paranormal tours that are actually pretty legit.
- Real Estate Scouting: If you're buying, look at the "Cambon Ave" or "Plante Tree Ln" areas for a mix of mid-century builds and more modern renovations.
- Commuter Tip: Use the Smithtown station if you miss the Saint James train; it’s only 10 minutes away and has more frequent service on the Port Jefferson branch.