If you find yourself in Fort Wayne on a crisp Saturday afternoon in October, you’ll hear it before you see it. It’s the sound of pads popping and a crowd that—honestly—is way too loud for a school with about 2,300 students. This is Bishop D’Arcy Stadium. It’s the home of Saint Francis Indiana football, and if you’re under the impression that small-college ball is just "high school plus," you haven't been watching the Cougars.
They win. A lot.
Since the program kicked off its first season back in 1998 under Kevin Donley, it hasn't just been a local team; it’s been a national brand in the NAIA (National Association of Intercollegiate Athletics). We aren't talking about participation trophies here. We’re talking about a program that has hauled in two national championships and reached the title game five other times. It’s a culture. It’s a machine. And frankly, it’s one of the best-kept secrets in Indiana sports for anyone who isn't already a die-hard alum.
The Kevin Donley Era: Building a Dynasty from Scratch
You can’t talk about Saint Francis Indiana football without talking about Kevin Donley. Most coaches inherit a legacy. Donley? He built the porch, the walls, and the roof. When the University of Saint Francis (USF) decided to start a football program in the late 90s, they hired a guy who already knew how to win.
Donley is a legend. Period.
He’s the winningest coach in NAIA history. Think about that for a second. In a sport where coaches burn out or jump to the next big paycheck every four years, Donley stayed. He turned a startup program into a perennial powerhouse. People often ask how a small Franciscan school in Fort Wayne competes with the massive state schools or the big-budget private colleges. It’s basically about consistency. Under Donley, the Cougars established a "next man up" philosophy decades before it became a trendy NFL catchphrase.
The mid-2010s were the peak. 2016 and 2017. Back-to-back National Championships.
📖 Related: Ryan Suter: What Most People Get Wrong About the NHL's Ultimate Survivor
Those years weren't fluke runs. They were the result of a recruiting pipeline that focused on "Indiana tough" kids—guys who maybe got overlooked by the Big Ten but had chips on their shoulders the size of the Great Lakes. Players like Nick Ferrer, who threw for a staggering amount of yards and touchdowns, became the faces of a program that didn't just want to participate. They wanted to dominate.
What Makes the Mid-States Football Association So Brutal?
The Cougars play in the MSFA (Mid-States Football Association), specifically the Mideast League. If you aren't a gearhead for college football tiers, let me break it down: this league is a meat grinder.
You’ve got teams like Marian University down in Indy and Concordia Ann Arbor. Every week is a playoff game. There are no "cupcake" Saturdays when you're chasing an MSFA title. This is a massive reason why Saint Francis Indiana football stays relevant. They play a schedule that prepares them for the postseason.
- Marian University Rivalry: This is the one. The "Holy Grail" game. When USF plays Marian, throw the records out. It’s personal, it’s loud, and it usually has massive playoff implications.
- Indiana Wesleyan: A newer rival on the block, but they’ve quickly become a thorn in the side of the established order.
- The Travel: These kids are on buses heading to Michigan, Ohio, and across Indiana. It’s blue-collar. It’s gritty.
The sheer physicality of the MSFA is why USF players often get looks from pro scouts. While it’s rare for an NAIA player to go high in the NFL draft, plenty of Cougars have found their way onto rosters in the CFL, Arena leagues, or as undrafted free agents. They know how to hit.
The Transition Period and the Future of the Program
Every dynasty hits a bump. Lately, the landscape of college football has changed. You’ve got the Transfer Portal. You’ve got NIL (Name, Image, and Likeness). For an NAIA school, these things are... complicated.
A few years ago, Saint Francis Indiana football saw a shift. Donley moved into an emeritus role, and the program had to figure out how to maintain that "Donley Magic" without the man himself on the headset every single play. It hasn't been a total collapse—far from it—but the margin for error in the NAIA has shrunk. Teams like Northwestern (Iowa) and Keiser (Florida) have raised the stakes.
👉 See also: Red Sox vs Yankees: What Most People Get Wrong About Baseball's Biggest Feud
The Cougars are currently in a "retooling" phase. They aren't rebuilding—that implies you've hit rock bottom. They’re still winning games. They’re still a threat. But the dominance of the 2016-2017 era is now the benchmark that every new recruiting class is measured against. It's a heavy burden, but honestly, it's the one you want. You'd rather have the pressure of a championship history than the apathy of a losing one.
The Game Day Experience: More Than Just a Game
If you're heading to a game, you need to know about the atmosphere. It’s not a 100,000-seat stadium, and that’s why it’s great. You are right there.
Bishop D’Arcy Stadium is nestled on the edge of the USF campus. You can smell the concessions, you can hear the coaches yelling at the refs, and you can see every bead of sweat. It’s intimate. For a family in Fort Wayne, it’s one of the best values in sports. You get high-level, tactical football for a fraction of what you’d pay to sit in the nosebleeds at Lucas Oil Stadium or Ross-Ade.
The fan base is a mix of "town and gown." You have the students, sure, but you also have the local community that has adopted the Cougars as Fort Wayne’s de facto "pro" team on Saturdays.
Realities of Recruiting in the Modern Era
How do they get players to come to a small private school in Fort Wayne? It’s not the weather. Indiana winters are brutal.
It’s the pitch of "playing for something." At a D1 school, a kid might sit on the bench for three years and never see a snap. At USF, you have a chance to be part of a championship run early. Coaches sell the brotherhood. They sell the education—Saint Francis is known for its nursing and health sciences programs. It’s a pitch that works on a specific type of athlete: the one who loves the game more than the "clout" of a big-name jersey.
✨ Don't miss: OU Football Depth Chart 2025: Why Most Fans Are Getting the Roster Wrong
However, it’s getting tougher. With D2 schools now offering different scholarship packages and the Transfer Portal allowing kids to jump ship easily, keeping a roster together for four years is a Herculean task. The coaching staff has to be as much "retention specialists" as they are "defensive coordinators."
Why Saint Francis Indiana Football Still Matters
In a world where college sports feels increasingly corporate—where conferences are merging and TV deals are worth billions—Saint Francis Indiana football feels real. It feels like what college football used to be.
It’s about the kid from a small town in rural Indiana getting a shot. It’s about the community coming together. It’s about the fact that on any given Saturday, a team from Fort Wayne can take down a giant.
Whether they are hoisting another trophy in December or grinding out a win on a rainy afternoon in September, the Cougars represent a specific kind of Midwestern excellence. They don't brag much. They just show up, hit hard, and usually, they leave with a "W."
How to Support and Follow the Cougars:
- Check the Schedule: The NAIA season usually kicks off in late August. Most games are on Saturdays. If you're local, get to Bishop D'Arcy Stadium early for tailgating.
- Watch Online: The Cougars usually stream their games through the USF Athletics portal. It’s a great way to catch the action if you can't make it to Fort Wayne.
- Follow the Stats: Keep an eye on the MSFA standings. The Mideast league is consistently ranked as one of the toughest in the country, so a win there carries a lot of weight in the national polls.
- Engage with the Alumni: The USF football alumni network is massive. If you're a student or a local business owner, connecting with this group is a great way to see how the program's values translate into the real world.
The next time someone tries to tell you that the only football that matters in Indiana happens in Bloomington, West Lafayette, or South Bend, tell them they're missing out. There’s a powerhouse in Fort Wayne, and they’ve got the rings to prove it.