Saga of Erik the Red: What Most People Get Wrong

Saga of Erik the Red: What Most People Get Wrong

If you think you know Erik the Red, you’re probably thinking of a generic, horned-helmet Viking. You’ve seen the statues. You know he "discovered" Greenland. But the actual text of the Saga of Erik the Red is way weirder, more political, and significantly more chaotic than the history books usually let on. Honestly, the man was basically the ultimate "bad neighbor" who happened to be really good at branding.

Let’s get one thing straight right away. Erik didn’t just wake up one day and decide to be an explorer. He was a fugitive. His father, Thorvald Asvaldsson, got kicked out of Norway for "some killings." Like father, like son, Erik eventually got exiled from Iceland for the exact same reason. He had a temper. He killed a few people over a dispute involving some borrowed wooden planks—literally building materials—and suddenly found himself with nowhere to go.

That’s the backdrop of the Saga of Erik the Red. It’s not a story of noble discovery. It’s a story of a man who was running out of map.

The Greenland Scam: A Masterclass in Marketing

When Erik was booted from Iceland for three years, he sailed west. He’d heard rumors of land. He found it, too. But Greenland isn't exactly a tropical paradise. Most of it is a giant ice sheet. So why is it called Greenland?

Because Erik was a genius at PR.

The saga explicitly says he gave the land a "favorable name" so that people would want to go there. He knew he couldn't survive alone; he needed a colony. He spent his three years of exile scouting the few patches of green fjords in the south, then went back to Iceland and pitched it like it was the new Mediterranean. It worked. In 985, he led 25 ships back to Greenland. Only 14 made it. The rest were lost at sea or turned back. That’s the grit we’re talking about.

✨ Don't miss: Why T. Pepin’s Hospitality Centre Still Dominates the Tampa Event Scene

What the Saga Actually Says

Most people confuse the Saga of Erik the Red with the Saga of the Greenlanders. They aren't the same. They often contradict each other.

In the Saga of the Greenlanders, Leif Erikson (Erik’s son) is the hero who intentionally sets out to find North America. But in the Saga of Erik the Red, Leif is almost an accidental footnote. He gets blown off course on his way from Norway back to Greenland and just... bumps into North America. He finds wild grapes and "self-sown wheat," shrugs, and keeps going home.

The real star of this specific saga? A guy named Thorfinn Karlsefni.

Karlsefni is the one who actually tries to settle what they called Vinland. He marries a widow named Gudrid Thorbjarnardóttir—who, frankly, is the most interesting person in the entire Viking Age—and they take 160 people to the New World.

The Mystery of the "Unipeds" and the Skraelings

The Saga of Erik the Red gets incredibly strange when it describes the encounters in North America. They didn't just find trees and grapes. They found people they called "Skraelings."

🔗 Read more: Human DNA Found in Hot Dogs: What Really Happened and Why You Shouldn’t Panic

Historians generally agree these were the ancestors of the Beothuk or the Dorset people. The interactions were... tense. It started with trading (the Vikings traded red cloth for furs), but it ended in blood. In one bizarre scene, the saga claims the Norse were attacked by a "Uniped"—a one-legged creature.

"It ran down to the creek where the ship lay... it shot an arrow into Thorvald's intestines."

Thorvald, Erik’s other son, died from that wound. Was it a literal one-legged monster? Probably not. It was likely a misunderstanding of indigenous clothing or just a tall tale added by a storyteller 200 years later. But it shows how alien and terrifying the Americas felt to these people.

Freydis: The Woman Who Scared an Army

You can't talk about the Saga of Erik the Red without talking about Freydis Eiriksdóttir. She was Erik’s daughter, and she was terrifying.

During one battle with the Skraelings, the Norse men started to retreat. Freydis was eight months pregnant at the time. She couldn't keep up with the running men, so she turned around, picked up a sword from a fallen Viking, and slapped the blade against her bare breast while screaming a war cry.

💡 You might also like: The Gospel of Matthew: What Most People Get Wrong About the First Book of the New Testament

The attackers were so bewildered and intimidated by this sight that they actually fled. It’s one of the most iconic scenes in all of Norse literature. It perfectly mirrors her father's legendary "fiery" personality.

Faith, Family, and a Dying Tradition

By the end of the saga, things get heavy. The Norse world was changing. Christianity was moving in, and it tore Erik’s family apart.

  • Leif Erikson converted and brought a priest to Greenland.
  • Thjodhild (Erik’s wife) converted instantly and built the first church in the New World.
  • Erik the Red stayed stubborn. He refused to give up the old gods.

The saga notes that after Thjodhild converted, she refused to sleep with Erik because he was still a "heathen." Imagine being the "King" of Greenland and getting locked out of your own bedroom because of a new religion from the south. It adds a human, almost petty layer to this epic history.

Why Should You Care in 2026?

We used to think these sagas were just campfire stories. Then, in the 1960s, archaeologists found L'Anse aux Meadows in Newfoundland. It’s a real Viking settlement. The "Saga of Erik the Red" was right all along—at least about the geography.

The settlements in Greenland eventually collapsed in the 1400s. No one knows exactly why. Maybe the climate got too cold (the Little Ice Age). Maybe the trade in walrus ivory dried up. Or maybe they just got tired of fighting for a "Green" land that was mostly white.


Actionable Next Steps

If you want to truly understand the world Erik built, don't just read a summary. Do this:

  1. Compare the texts: Read the Saga of Erik the Red alongside the Saga of the Greenlanders. Look for the contradictions—especially regarding who "found" America first. It's like a 1,000-year-old "he-said, she-said."
  2. Look at the maps: Pull up a satellite map of Qassiarsuk, Greenland. That’s Brattahlid, Erik’s home. You can still see the foundations of the houses today.
  3. Study Gudrid: If you want the real human story, look up Gudrid Thorbjarnardóttir. She traveled from Iceland to Greenland to North America, back to Iceland, and eventually walked to Rome. She’s the most traveled woman of the Middle Ages, and her story starts right here in this saga.

Erik the Red wasn't just a Viking. He was a survivor, a liar, and a father to a generation of explorers who pushed the boundaries of the known world until they hit a wall they couldn't climb.