You probably remember her as the quirky, big-hearted Mennonite girl trying on "English" clothes for the first time in New York City. Back in 2012, Sabrina Burkholder was the breakout star of Breaking Amish, bringing a specific kind of raw, unfiltered energy that reality TV rarely captures anymore. She wasn't just another cast member; she was the emotional anchor. But if you’ve been following her journey lately, you know the sparkle from those early TLC days has been replaced by a much grittier, and often heartbreaking, reality.
Honestly, the story of sabrina from return to amish isn't a simple Hollywood-style redemption arc. It’s messy. It’s a series of two steps forward and three steps back. By early 2026, the updates coming out of her camp have shifted from the joy of new beginnings to sobering reports of legal trouble and family instability.
The Near-Fatal Wake-Up Call
Most fans point to 2018 as the year everything changed. It was the year Sabrina technically died.
She’s been very open about her struggle with heroin, a battle that nearly ended in a York County, Pennsylvania, parking lot. She was celebrating her 32nd birthday—if you can call it that—when she suffered a massive overdose. Her heart stopped. Her boyfriend at the time, Jethro Nolt, and a friend named Sean had to perform desperate CPR until paramedics arrived with Narcan.
Sabrina later described having visions of her biological mother and grandmother while she was "gone." It’s the kind of story that sounds like a tabloid fabrication, but for her, it was a terrifyingly real catalyst. She went to rehab, moved out of Pennsylvania, and tried to "change her people, places, and things," as the old recovery saying goes. For a while, it actually seemed to work.
A New Chapter That Unraveled
By 2021, things looked up. She was clean. She was back on Return to Amish. She even welcomed her fifth child, a daughter named Kalani.
👉 See also: Ted Nugent State of Shock: Why This 1979 Album Divides Fans Today
"Honestly, my addiction was probably the hardest part of my life, so being sober and having children isn't that hard," she told People at the time.
But life after reality TV is rarely that stable. While she seemed focused on her younger children—Zekiah, Skylar, and Kalani—her older two daughters, Oakley and Arianna, had already been legally adopted by her sister-in-law years prior. That loss of custody was a wound that never truly healed, and the pressure of raising a new family while the world watched every move started to show.
What Really Happened with Sabrina from Return to Amish Recently?
Fast forward to the end of 2025 and the start of 2026, and the narrative has taken a sharp, dark turn.
Social media and local reports have painted a bleak picture. While she once lived for the cameras, her recent "public" life has been defined by police blotters rather than TLC airtime. In late 2025, news broke that she was facing eviction and had been involved in multiple arrests. Perhaps most devastatingly, reports surfaced in October 2025 that the Department of Children and Families (DCF) had stepped in, taking custody of her younger children.
There was also a bizarre and deeply concerning incident involving a Christmas Day burglary allegedly linked to a social media acquaintance. These aren't the kind of "storylines" producers dream up; these are the real-world consequences of someone struggling to stay afloat without a solid support system.
✨ Don't miss: Mike Judge Presents: Tales from the Tour Bus Explained (Simply)
It’s easy to judge from a couch. It's much harder to understand the vacuum that opens up when the reality TV checks stop coming and the "fame" remains.
The Problem with "Reality" Fame
Sabrina’s journey highlights a massive flaw in how we consume these shows. We love the "fish out of water" trope, but we rarely talk about the trauma of being an adoptee in a strict Mennonite community who is then thrust into the "English" world with no life skills.
She didn't have a safety net.
When she stumbled, she didn't just fall; she hit the pavement in front of millions of people. Some cast members, like Kate Stoltz, used the show as a springboard to a legitimate career in fashion. Others, like Sabrina, seemed to get stuck in the cycle of trauma that the show exploited for ratings.
Where She Stands in 2026
So, where is she now? Basically, she’s in a fight for her life and her family. Again.
🔗 Read more: Big Brother 27 Morgan: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
The situation with Jethro Nolt appears to be over, and her current environment seems far from the stable "clean" life she described a few years ago. There are rumors of her associating with a "rougher crowd," which is always a red flag for someone in recovery.
- Custody Status: Her children are reportedly in state care or with relatives, a repeat of the heartbreak she faced with her first two daughters.
- Legal Woes: Pending court dates for various charges continue to hang over her.
- Recovery: While she hasn't publicly confirmed a relapse, the pattern of her recent behavior has many fans and experts deeply concerned.
It’s a tragedy in real-time. You’ve got a woman who has survived a literal death and come back, only to find herself trapped in the same cycles of poverty and instability.
What Can We Learn?
If you're looking for a happy ending, you might have to wait—or accept that it might not come. Recovery isn't a straight line. It’s a jagged, ugly scribble.
The biggest takeaway from the saga of sabrina from return to amish is that "leaving the Amish" is the easy part. It's the "living in the world" part that breaks people.
To help someone in this position, or to understand the nuance, look into resources for adult adoptee trauma and long-term addiction recovery. If you want to follow her journey responsibly, look for updates from verified news outlets rather than speculative social media accounts that often prioritize clicks over her actual well-being. Supporting organizations like NAMI (National Alliance on Mental Illness) or local recovery centers is a practical way to turn your interest in her story into something that helps others facing similar battles.
The cameras are mostly gone, but the struggle is very much alive.