The internet almost imploded when the news broke. Everyone was convinced that Barry Keoghan, the "hot rodent boyfriend" of the year, had pulled a fast one on our favorite pop princess. If you spent any time on TikTok in late 2024 or early 2025, you probably saw the frantic "blue eye" edits and the "Please Please Please" lyrics being dissected like a high school biology project. The narrative was set: Sabrina Carpenter bf cheated, the relationship was dead, and we were all just waiting for the diss tracks to drop.
But honestly? The truth is a lot more complicated than a spicy blind item.
Did Sabrina Carpenter’s Boyfriend Actually Cheat?
We have to talk about the December 2024 fallout. That's when the rumors really peaked. It started with a blind item on DeuxMoi—the holy grail of unverified tea—that basically said a "foreign actor boyfriend" was getting cozy with a TikTok influencer at the San Vicente Bungalows in LA while his A-list singer girlfriend was busy performing her biggest tour date. It didn't take a genius to connect the dots to Barry and Sabrina.
The "influencer" in question was rumored to be Breckie Hill. The internet went into a full-on spiral.
Here is the thing: People love a villain. They saw Barry as the guy who fumbled the bag of the century. However, on December 7, 2024, Breckie Hill herself posted a TikTok titled "Addressing everything." She was pretty blunt about it. She said she had never even met Barry Keoghan in her life and the only time she’d seen him was on her TV screen. She explained that her "salty" margarita review and "Blackberry Smash" drink review (which fans thought was a code for Barry) were just... reviews.
Basically, the "evidence" was just a series of coincidences fueled by fans who were already protective of Sabrina.
The Breakdown of the Breakup
- The Official Stance: Sources close to the couple told People that they were "taking a break" because they were both young and career-focused.
- The "On and Off" Cycle: By August 2024, insiders were already saying the relationship was turbulent.
- Barry’s Side: An insider defended the actor, claiming he was "always very faithful" and that there was absolutely no third party involved.
- Sabrina’s Subtle Shade: Even though no one used the word "cheating" officially, Sabrina didn't exactly stop the rumors. She reposted TikToks about being glad she didn't get back with an ex in 2025, set to her song "Manchild."
Why the "Sabrina Carpenter bf cheated" Narrative Stuck
It’s about the branding. Sabrina has built an entire career on being the girl who gets "the short end of the stick" in romance. From the Olivia Rodrigo / Joshua Bassett drama to the Shawn Mendes rumors, she’s the patron saint of the messy Situationship. When the Barry Keoghan rumors hit, they fit the "Short n' Sweet" aesthetic perfectly.
The lyrics in "Taste" and "Coincidence" already had everyone primed to look for betrayal.
Even if Barry didn't physically cheat, the "not-innocent-at-all" messaging rumors mentioned in the blind items were enough to sour the public's opinion. Barry ended up deactivating his Instagram because the hate was so intense. He mentioned on X (formerly Twitter) that he couldn't let "absolute lies" and "disgusting commentary" about his character distract him from his family and work. It was a mess. A total, 100% certified Hollywood disaster.
The Timeline of Chaos
- September 2023: They meet at Paris Fashion Week. Pure "Bed Chem" vibes.
- March 2024: The Oscars afterparty hard launch. The beaded friendship bracelet was everything.
- June 2024: Barry stars in the "Please Please Please" video. Irony at its finest.
- December 2024: The breakup news hits. The internet decides he's a cheater.
- January 2026: Sabrina is officially single and thriving, subtly shading the "Manchild" in her past.
Is She Dating Anyone Now?
As of early 2026, Sabrina seems to be flying solo. Or at least, she's keeping it way more low-key than her year with the Saltburn star. There was a weird rumor about David Dobrik for a second, but that felt more like a PR stunt or a random sighting than anything real.
She’s at the top of her game. She doesn't need a boyfriend to stay in the headlines, though the "did he or didn't he" mystery definitely helped the Short n' Sweet album cycle stay relevant for an unnervingly long time.
If you're looking for a smoking gun, you won't find one. No photos of Barry with another woman ever surfaced. No "other woman" has actually come forward with receipts. It’s all speculation, hearsay, and the power of a really good pop song making us want to believe the worst of the men in her life.
How to Tell if a Celeb Rumor is Legit
Don't believe everything you see on a "blind item" account. These are often sent in by fans with an agenda or people who just want to see the world burn. Look for the "soft launch" of the breakup—usually a lack of Instagram likes or the deactivation of accounts. In this case, Barry deactivating was the biggest signal that things had turned toxic.
Next time you see a headline about a celebrity breakup, check the sources. "An insider" usually means a PR person. "A source close to the star" usually means the star's best friend. If both sides are staying silent but the "leaks" are one-sided, someone is trying to win the breakup in the court of public opinion.
Actionable Insights for Fans:
💡 You might also like: China Anne McClain Bikini Style: What People Get Wrong About Her Fashion Shift
- Stream the Music: If you want to know how Sabrina feels, listen to the lyrics. She’s a songwriter; she puts the truth in the bridge, not the press release.
- Watch the Social Cues: Reposts and "likes" are the new official statements.
- Wait for the New Album: Usually, the real tea comes out in the next project, not the tabloids.
The era of Sabrina Carpenter bf cheated rumors might be over, but the songs it inspired are going to be on our playlists forever. Stay skeptical, stay caffeinated, and remember that in Hollywood, the "truth" is usually somewhere in the middle of a TikTok comment section and a lawyer-approved statement.