Hollywood has a "nice guy" problem. We love them until we don't. For a decade, Ryan Reynolds was the undisputed king of the internet’s heart—the guy who could sell you gin, cell phone plans, and R-rated superhero movies with a wink and a self-deprecating tweet. But lately, the wind has changed. If you spend five minutes on certain corners of Reddit or X (formerly Twitter), you’ll see the phrase ryan reynolds is an asshole popping up with alarming frequency.
Why?
It's not just one thing. It’s a messy cocktail of on-set feuds, legal drama involving his wife Blake Lively, and a growing suspicion that his "relatable" persona is actually a finely tuned marketing machine. Honestly, the shift is jarring. You’ve got people who once worshipped his Deadpool wit now claiming he’s a "toxic narcissist." Let’s look at the actual facts behind the backlash.
The T.J. Miller Incident: Where the "Asshole" Narrative Began
Most of the "mean guy" rumors started with a single podcast interview. T.J. Miller, who played Weasel in the first two Deadpool films, went on The Adam Carolla Show and basically dropped a nuclear bomb on Reynolds' reputation.
Miller claimed that during a riffing session on set, Reynolds got "horrifically mean" to him while in character. According to Miller, Reynolds said something along the lines of, "You know what’s great about you, Weasel? You’re not the star, but you do just enough exposition so that it’s funny, and then we can leave and get back to the real movie."
Miller felt the attack was personal, not professional. He described Reynolds as an "insecure dude" who changed after the massive success of the first film. Now, it’s worth noting that Miller himself is a controversial figure with his own share of legal and professional issues. In fact, he later walked some of this back, saying Reynolds reached out via email to clear up the "misunderstanding."
But the damage was done. The "asshole" label stuck because it confirmed a suspicion many people already had: that the charming, fast-talking guy on screen might be a bit of a bully when the cameras stop rolling.
The It Ends With Us Disaster and the Justin Baldoni Feud
Fast forward to 2024 and 2025. This is where things got really ugly. During the press tour for It Ends With Us, rumors of a massive rift between Blake Lively and director/co-star Justin Baldoni began to leak.
Reynolds wasn't even in the movie. Yet, he was everywhere.
Reports surfaced that Reynolds had rewritten a key rooftop scene, which many felt undermined Baldoni’s creative control. Then came the lawsuits. In early 2025, Baldoni filed a massive $400 million lawsuit alleging extortion and defamation against both Lively and Reynolds.
The documents were explosive. Baldoni’s camp alleged that Reynolds had "verbally abused" him in an intense tirade during a meeting in a penthouse suite. One producer allegedly stated that in a 40-year career, they had never seen anyone spoken to in such a manner. The internet took sides immediately. For many, this was the definitive proof that ryan reynolds is an asshole behind the scenes—a powerful Hollywood elite using his "Maximum Effort" PR machine to crush a smaller director.
✨ Don't miss: Is Kiké Hernandez Gay? The Truth About the Dodgers Star's Personal Life
Is It Authenticity or Just Really Good Branding?
We have to talk about the "Nice Guy" mask. Reynolds is a brilliant marketer. He doesn't just act; he owns a creative agency. Every tweet, every "random" interaction with a fan, and every viral video is technically a product.
Take the 2025 Toronto International Film Festival incident. A video went viral of Reynolds being "rude" to a child reporter. When the kid said, "Nice to meet you," Reynolds reportedly snapped, "Nice to meet you too, let’s skip to the question."
On one hand, he’s a busy guy on a red carpet trying to be funny. On the other hand, it looked... bad. It looked like the sarcasm he uses to be charming had curdled into something dismissive and cold. This is the core of the ryan reynolds is an asshole debate: Is he actually a jerk, or is he just a guy whose "sarcastic dad" bit is finally starting to grate on people?
The "Mean Girl" Association
You can't talk about Ryan without talking about Blake. The couple is often viewed as a single entity. When Blake Lively faced a "mean girl" reckoning during her 2024/2025 press tours—largely due to her handling of domestic violence themes in her movie—Reynolds was caught in the splash zone.
💡 You might also like: Hugh Jackman and Meg Ryan: Why Their Chemistry Still Works in 2026
Critics pointed out their "contrived" social media banter. People started digging up old interviews, like the one where Reynolds joked about "coaching" his seven-year-old daughter to say "disturbing" lines on the Deadpool & Wolverine set. What was meant to be a funny anecdote suddenly felt "callous" to a more cynical public.
What Most People Get Wrong
Despite the headlines, it’s rarely black and white. For every T.J. Miller story, there’s a Hugh Jackman or Jake Gyllenhaal story. Gyllenhaal and Reynolds have been "best friends" since filming Life in 2017, though even that relationship has been subject to "fallout" rumors on TikTok.
The truth is likely somewhere in the middle. Reynolds is a high-powered producer and business mogul. In Hollywood, you don't reach that level of success—running a soccer club (Wrexham AFC), a gin brand (Aviation), and a film studio—by being everyone's best friend. You have to be tough. Sometimes, "tough" looks like "asshole" to the people on the receiving end.
How to Form Your Own Opinion
If you’re trying to figure out if the hate is justified, look at the patterns rather than the isolated clips.
- Watch the Unedited Interviews: Don't rely on 10-second TikTok clips. Look at his full interactions on red carpets. Does he seem genuinely engaged, or is he waiting for his turn to speak?
- Follow the Legal Outcomes: The lawsuits with Justin Baldoni are the real litmus test. If the courts find evidence of "extortion" or "bullying," the "asshole" label moves from gossip to fact.
- Consider the Source: T.J. Miller has a history of erratic behavior. Justin Baldoni was in a power struggle over a film's creative direction. Everyone in these stories has an agenda.
The "Nice Guy" era of Ryan Reynolds is definitely over. Whether he’s actually the villain some claim him to be, or just a powerful man who’s tired of playing pretend, remains the biggest mystery in Hollywood right now.
To stay truly informed, keep an eye on the 2026 court dates for the Lively-Baldoni case. That’s where the private text messages and unedited "tirades" will finally see the light of day. Until then, take the "lovable prankster" and the "toxic bully" narratives with a heavy grain of salt. Neither is the whole story.