When the first plane hit the North Tower at 8:46 AM on a crisp Tuesday morning, New York City was actually in the middle of an election. People forget that. Primary Day was supposed to be the biggest news of the week. Instead, the world stopped. If you’re asking who was the mayor during 9/11, the answer is Rudy Giuliani, but the "how" and "why" of his presence that day are way more complicated than just a name on a ballot. He was a man whose term was literally weeks from ending. He was, for all intents and purposes, a "lame duck" about to hand over the keys to City Hall.
Giuliani wasn't just at his desk when it happened. He was nearly killed. While the towers were burning, he and his top aides were inside a temporary command post at 75 Barclay Street. When the South Tower collapsed, the building they were in shook so violently they thought it was coming down too. They were trapped. They had to break out through a basement and find their way through a cloud of debris that turned day into night. That image of Giuliani walking through the dust, flanked by police commissioners and soot-covered staffers, became the defining visual of leadership in a moment of total existential dread.
The Leader New York Didn't Expect to Need
Before September 11, Giuliani was actually kinda polarizing. Seriously. His approval ratings were dipping, and people were tired of his aggressive "broken windows" policing and his frequent public spats with everyone from museum directors to street vendors. He was the "law and order" guy, but the city was ready for something different. Then the sky fell.
It’s hard to describe the vacuum of information that existed in the first hour. Was there a third plane? A fourth? Was the subway a target? Giuliani didn't hide in a bunker. He was on the ground. He spoke to the press constantly, and honestly, his voice was the only thing keeping the city from a total, unmitigated stampede of panic. He famously told the world that the number of casualties would be "more than any of us can bear." He didn't sugarcoat it. That bluntness, which had annoyed people for years, suddenly became a bedrock of stability.
The Command Center That Wasn't
One of the biggest controversies—and something experts still debate—is the location of the Office of Emergency Management (OEM). Giuliani had put the city's high-tech command center on the 23rd floor of 7 World Trade Center. Critics, including many in the FDNY, had warned that putting a command center in a known terrorist target (after the 1993 bombing) was a bad move. They were right. When the towers fell, 7 World Trade Center was eventually destroyed, and the "bunker" was useless.
This meant the mayor during 9/11 had to run the city's response from the streets and from a makeshift spot at the Police Academy. It was chaotic. Communication lines were down. Radios weren't working between the police and fire departments—a systemic failure that cost many first responders their lives. Giuliani had to manage a rescue operation while the very infrastructure designed to handle it was literally smoldering rubble.
💡 You might also like: Michael Collins of Ireland: What Most People Get Wrong
A Partnership of Necessity: George Pataki and George W. Bush
Giuliani wasn't acting alone, though he often got the lion's share of the credit. You had Governor George Pataki and President George W. Bush in the mix. The dynamic was tense but functional. While Bush was being moved around on Air Force One for security, Giuliani was the face on the flickering TV screens in every bar and living room across America. He became "America’s Mayor," a title coined by Oprah Winfrey. It stuck because he filled a psychological hole. People needed to see a human being standing in the wreckage saying, "We are still here."
The Recovery and the Dust
The months following the attacks were a blur of funerals and debris removal. Giuliani was at almost all of them. He attended hundreds of memorials for fallen firefighters and police officers. He basically lived at Ground Zero.
However, we have to talk about the air.
At the time, the EPA, under Christine Todd Whitman, famously said the air was "safe to breathe." Giuliani echoed this sentiment, pushing for Wall Street to reopen quickly and for the city to get back to business. We know now that was a health disaster. Thousands of first responders and residents have since developed 9/11-related cancers and respiratory illnesses from the toxic cocktail of pulverized concrete, asbestos, and jet fuel. Looking back, the rush to "return to normalcy" is one of the most scrutinized parts of his tenure. It was a trade-off between economic survival and long-term public health, and the consequences are still being felt in hospitals today.
Why 2001 Was a Turning Point for NYC Politics
Giuliani actually tried to extend his term. He argued that the city was in too much turmoil to change leadership. He wanted to stay on for another three months, or even have the term limits overturned. It didn't happen. The city's political establishment pushed back, and Michael Bloomberg eventually won the election.
📖 Related: Margaret Thatcher Explained: Why the Iron Lady Still Divides Us Today
It’s weird to think about now, but Giuliani’s exit was marked by a weird mixture of universal praise and deep-seated political friction. He left office on December 31, 2001, with an approval rating that was astronomical. He had taken a city that felt broken and, through sheer force of will (and a lot of yelling), made it feel functional again. Whether you agree with his methods or his later political evolution, his actions in those specific 102 minutes and the weeks that followed are an objective case study in crisis management.
Looking Back: The Facts vs. The Myth
A lot of what we remember about the mayor during 9/11 is filtered through the lens of Time Magazine's "Person of the Year" cover. But the nuances matter.
- The Radios: The failure of FDNY radios to receive the "evacuate" order in the North Tower is a stain on the administration’s preparation.
- The DNA Lab: Giuliani pushed for the creation of a massive DNA identification project that eventually helped identify thousands of remains, a process that took years.
- The Economy: He successfully lobbied Congress for $20 billion in aid, which kept the city from a total financial collapse.
He was a man of contradictions. He was the guy who stayed calm while the world burned, but he was also the guy who ignored the warnings about the 7 WTC bunker location. He was the empathetic mourner at funerals and the hard-nosed politician who wouldn't yield an inch of power.
How to Research This History Further
If you're trying to get the full, unvarnished story of this era, don't just rely on news clips. The 9/11 Commission Report is the gold standard, but it's dense. For a more "on the ground" feel, look into the oral histories recorded by the New York Public Library. They have thousands of hours of recordings from regular New Yorkers who saw the mayor on the street that day.
Also, check out the archives of the New York Times from September 2001. Seeing the ads for Broadway shows and the primary election coverage right next to the disaster reports gives you a sense of how jarring the transition was. The city didn't just change overnight; it changed in a heartbeat.
👉 See also: Map of the election 2024: What Most People Get Wrong
Actionable Steps for Understanding 9/11 Leadership
Understanding the role of the mayor during this crisis isn't just a history lesson; it's about understanding how cities handle the unthinkable. Here is how you can dig deeper into this specific moment in time:
1. Study the 9/11 Commission Report's Chapter on Preparedness.
Don't read the whole thing if you don't have time. Focus specifically on the sections regarding "Command and Control" in New York City. It outlines exactly where the communication broke down between Giuliani's office, the NYPD, and the FDNY. It's an eye-opener on the gap between public perception and operational reality.
2. Visit the 9/11 Memorial & Museum (Online or In-Person).
The museum has a specific exhibit on the "City Response." It houses the actual artifacts from the Mayor’s office and the temporary command posts. Seeing the soot-covered blackberries and hand-drawn maps used by officials brings the "low-tech" reality of that day to life.
3. Watch the Documentary "102 Minutes That Changed America."
This film uses raw footage without narration. You can see the progression of the day and often spot the mayor and his team moving through the streets. It provides the context of the physical environment they were navigating, which was far more perilous than most realize.
4. Review the World Trade Center Health Program Data.
To understand the "post-9/11" legacy of Giuliani's administration, look at the health outcomes for workers at Ground Zero. This provides the necessary counter-balance to the heroism of the day, showing the long-term cost of the decisions made regarding the site's cleanup and safety.
The story of the mayor during 9/11 is ultimately a story about the limits of human leadership. Rudy Giuliani wasn't a superhero; he was a city official who happened to be the one standing there when the impossible happened. He made some brilliant calls and some catastrophic mistakes. Learning about both is the only way to truly understand what happened to New York on that Tuesday in September.