He was once "America’s Mayor," the guy walking through the smoke of Ground Zero. Now, Rudy Giuliani spends his time in federal courtrooms, arguing over the fate of his 1980 Mercedes and whether he’s "willfully" hiding his luxury watch collection. If you haven't been following the Rudy Giuliani Georgia defamation contempt hearing saga, it's honestly a wild ride of legal maneuvering, missed deadlines, and high-stakes asset seizures.
Basically, it all stems from a massive $148 million judgment. A jury decided Giuliani owed that staggering sum to Ruby Freeman and Shaye Moss—two Georgia election workers whose lives were turned upside down after he spread false conspiracy theories about them during the 2020 election. But winning the money was just the beginning. Actually getting Rudy to pay? That's where it gets messy.
Why the Contempt Hearing Even Happened
You’ve probably seen the headlines about Giuliani being held in contempt. It wasn't just for one thing. In early January 2025, U.S. District Judge Lewis Liman lost his patience. The court had set a strict December 20 deadline for Giuliani to turn over evidence—things like the full names of his doctors and professional service providers.
✨ Don't miss: Breaking News Staten Island New York: What’s Actually Happening Right Now
Why doctors? Because Rudy was trying to claim that his Palm Beach condominium was his primary residence (his "homestead"), which would make it harder for the election workers to seize it. To prove he actually lived in Florida, the judge wanted to see his local records.
Giuliani blew past the deadline.
He didn't just miss it; he basically ignored it. When he finally showed up—remotely, from that very Florida condo—he claimed the requests were a "trap" or just too broad to handle. Judge Liman wasn't buying it. He ruled that Giuliani "willfully violated a clear and unambiguous order."
💡 You might also like: Kristi Noem Killed Her Dog: What Really Happened with Cricket
The Fallout of Being in Contempt
When a federal judge finds you in contempt, the consequences aren't just a slap on the wrist. In this case, Liman lowered the boom by:
- Blocking evidence: Giuliani was banned from using certain emails or texts to prove his Florida residency.
- Assuming the worst: The judge decided that since Rudy wouldn't name his Florida doctors, he probably didn't have any, which gutted his "primary residence" argument.
- Legal "Gaps": The court ruled it could make "adverse inferences" about the gaps in evidence Rudy failed to provide.
It was a total legal disaster for the former mayor. For a while there, it looked like he was going to lose absolutely everything, including the roof over his head in Palm Beach and his prized New York Yankees World Series rings.
The Surprise Settlement That Changed Everything
Just when it looked like we were heading for a trial to decide the fate of his remaining assets, a deal was struck. On January 16, 2025, lawyers for both sides emerged from a room in the Manhattan federal courthouse with news.
Giuliani and the Georgia election workers reached a settlement.
This was huge. Honestly, most people thought they’d be fighting over those World Series rings until the end of time. Under the deal, Giuliani gets to keep his Florida condo and those famous rings. In exchange, he agreed to pay "unspecified compensation" and—this is the big one—never to defame Ruby Freeman and Shaye Moss again.
It’s a "shut-up" clause, basically. If he starts talking about "suitcases of ballots" again, the whole deal could blow up.
What Most People Get Wrong About the $148 Million
There’s a lot of talk online that Rudy is "off the hook" because of the settlement. That’s not really true. While the specific terms of the final payout are confidential, he had already surrendered a massive amount of wealth.
Think about it: he already lost his $5 million Upper East Side apartment. He had to hand over a 1980 Mercedes-Benz that used to belong to screen legend Lauren Bacall. He gave up dozens of luxury watches. He even had to surrender a shirt signed by Joe DiMaggio.
The $148 million figure was always going to be impossible to collect in full because Giuliani simply doesn't have that much money. Experts estimated his total net worth was closer to $10 million. By the time the Rudy Giuliani Georgia defamation contempt hearing wrapped up, the election workers had basically squeezed most of the available blood from the stone.
The Human Cost
We shouldn't forget why this started. Ruby Freeman and Shaye Moss weren't political figures. They were just doing their jobs. After the 2020 election, they faced a literal "living nightmare" of death threats and racist harassment because of the claims Giuliani pushed.
In their statement after the settlement, they called it a "major milestone." They finally got their names cleared. They got some level of financial restitution. And most importantly, they got a legal guarantee that the man who started it all would finally stop talking about them.
Actionable Insights: What This Means for the Future
If you’re following this case because you’re interested in law, politics, or just the drama, here are the key takeaways from this legal saga:
- Contempt is a Heavy Tool: You can’t "run the clock" on a federal judge forever. Liman’s ruling shows that if a defendant is "recalcitrant," the court will eventually stop asking and start penalizing.
- Asset Protection Has Limits: Trying to claim a "homestead" exemption in Florida is a classic move, but you actually have to live there. Documentation matters.
- Defamation is Getting Expensive: Between this case and the Dominion lawsuits, the legal system is putting a very high price tag on spreading election-related misinformation.
- Check the Dockets: If you want the real story, look at the court filings in the Southern District of New York (SDNY). Media snippets often miss the nuance of the "adverse inferences" that actually win or lose these cases.
The saga of the Rudy Giuliani Georgia defamation contempt hearing is officially over as of early 2026. The judgment is satisfied, the assets are distributed, and the legal battles have moved on to other fronts. It's a sobering look at how fast things can change for one of the most powerful lawyers in the country.