You’ve seen it. If you’ve ever driven north of Ithaca on Route 34, heading toward the quiet stretches of Lansing, that giant red brick building is basically impossible to miss. It sits there on the corner, looking like it’s been plucked out of a different century and dropped right into the middle of modern New York. It’s the Rogues Harbor Inn NY, and honestly, the place has a vibe that’s hard to pin down. Is it a cozy bed and breakfast? A local haunt for a decent burger? Or just a massive historical monument that happens to serve beer?
Actually, it’s all of that.
The building itself dates back to 1830. Major General Matthew McPherson built it, and if you look at the architecture, you can tell he wasn't exactly going for "subtle." It’s Federal-style, looming three stories high with walls that are surprisingly thick. People always ask about the name. "Rogues Harbor" sounds like something out of a pirate movie, doesn't it? But we're nowhere near the ocean. The name actually comes from the local reputation the area had back in the 1800s. Legend says it was a bit of a rowdy spot where travelers and locals weren't always on their best behavior. It was a "harbor" for "rogues." Kind of perfect, really.
Why People Keep Coming Back to the Inn
Walking inside is a trip. You aren't getting the polished, sanitized experience of a Hilton. Not even close. It feels lived-in. The floors creak. The wood is dark. There’s a specific smell of old brick and simmering food that you only find in places that have seen a hundred winters.
Historically, this place was a major stop for stagecoaches. Imagine that for a second. Before the Finger Lakes were a wine-tasting destination, they were a rugged frontier. Travelers would pull up in horse-drawn carriages, desperate for a warm meal and a bed that didn't involve sleeping on a wagon floor. The Rogues Harbor Inn NY provided that sanctuary.
✨ Don't miss: Taking the Ferry to Williamsburg Brooklyn: What Most People Get Wrong
Today, it functions largely as a restaurant and a craft brewery destination, but the "inn" part is still very much alive. The rooms upstairs are named after historical figures or local themes. They aren't "modern luxury" in the way some people might want—don't expect a smart fridge in your suite—but they are authentic. You get the high ceilings and the original window moldings. If you're the kind of person who likes history you can actually touch, it's pretty great.
The Underground Railroad Connection
There is a lot of talk about the Rogues Harbor Inn NY being a stop on the Underground Railroad. It’s a common story in this part of New York, especially given how close we are to Auburn and the Harriet Tubman Home. While local tradition strongly maintains that the inn's basement served as a hiding spot for people escaping slavery, historians are often more cautious.
Documenting these sites is notoriously difficult because, well, the whole point was that it was a secret. However, the physical structure of the basement—with its thick stone walls and various nooks—certainly fits the profile of the safe houses found throughout the Finger Lakes region. Whether or not there’s a "smoking gun" piece of paper proving it, the local community has held onto this history for generations. It adds a layer of weight to the building. It wasn't just a place for "rogues" to drink; it was potentially a place where people's lives were saved.
Food, Beer, and the Modern Experience
Let's be real: most people visiting today are there for the taproom. The Finger Lakes beer scene is massive now, but Rogues Harbor has been holding it down for a long time.
🔗 Read more: Lava Beds National Monument: What Most People Get Wrong About California's Volcanic Underworld
They do classic American pub fare. We’re talking:
- Fish and chips that actually have a crunch.
- Burgers that are big enough to require multiple napkins.
- Local steaks that haven't been messed with too much.
The beer is brewed on-site, and they usually have a solid rotation of IPAs, stouts, and ales. It’s the kind of place where you see farmers in dusty boots sitting two tables away from Cornell professors. That’s the magic of Lansing, honestly. It’s a bridge between the academic bubble of Ithaca and the rural reality of Upstate New York.
Is It Haunted?
You can't have a 190-year-old building with creaky floors and not have ghost stories. Ask any of the staff. They’ve heard footsteps when nobody is there. They’ve seen shadows move in the corner of their eye. Some people say Major McPherson never really left.
Whether you believe in ghosts or just think it’s the wind catching an old frame, the atmosphere at night is definitely... potent. When the sun goes down and the shadows stretch across that red brick exterior, you definitely feel the age of the place. It’s not scary, exactly. It just feels crowded with memories.
💡 You might also like: Road Conditions I40 Tennessee: What You Need to Know Before Hitting the Asphalt
Planning a Visit to Lansing
If you're heading to the Rogues Harbor Inn NY, don't just stop there and turn around. Lansing is underrated. You have Myers Park just down the hill, which has some of the best views of Cayuga Lake you can find without paying for a private boat tour. There are cliffs, a swimming area, and plenty of space to just sit and watch the water.
The inn is located at the intersection of NY-34 and NY-34B. It’s a landmark for a reason.
Pro-tip for travelers:
Check their hours before you go. Like many historic spots in rural NY, they aren't always open 24/7. They tend to have shorter hours in the mid-week or during the deep winter months. If you want to stay overnight, call ahead rather than just relying on a booking site. Talking to the people who actually run the place is the best way to get the real story anyway.
The Reality of Maintaining a Legend
Keeping a building like this standing is a nightmare. It’s expensive. It’s constant work. Over the years, the Rogues Harbor Inn NY has gone through different owners and different phases. Some years the focus is more on the brewery; other years it’s more about the fine dining or the B&B aspect.
There was a time a few years back when people were worried about the building's future. It’s a massive footprint to maintain. But it’s still here. It’s survived the Civil War, the Prohibition era (where I’m sure those "rogues" were very busy), and the rise of modern chain hotels. It stays because it’s a part of the identity of the town.
Actionable Tips for Your Trip
- Arrive Early for Dinner: Especially on weekends. The locals fill up the bar area fast, and you want to snag a spot where you can see the original woodwork.
- Check the Tap List: They often have small-batch brews that don't make it into cans or bottles. If they have a seasonal stout, get it.
- Walk the Exterior: Before you go inside, walk around the building. Look at the brickwork. Look at the scale of the windows. It’s a masterclass in 19th-century construction that you don't see anymore.
- Ask the Server: Ask them what their favorite "weird" thing about the building is. Everyone who works there has a story—either a ghost story or just a strange fact about a hidden door or an old piece of hardware.
- Combine with a Hike: Hit Salmon Creek Falls nearby first. It’s a short walk to a stunning waterfall, and you’ll definitely earn that burger and beer afterward.
The Rogues Harbor Inn NY isn't a museum, though it sometimes feels like one. It's a living piece of New York history that you can actually sit inside and have a drink. In a world of cookie-cutter developments and "modern farmhouse" aesthetics that are fake, this place is the real deal. It’s rough around the edges, it’s got character, and it’s been waiting for you for nearly two hundred years.