The theater was half-empty. Or at least, the front rows were. When the news leaked that Vinícius Júnior wouldn't be the Ballon d'Or 2024 winner, Real Madrid famously grounded their private jet. No Florentino Pérez. No Carlo Ancelotti. No Vini. It was a chaotic, petulant prelude to a night that actually ended up honoring something rarely celebrated in modern football: the guy who makes everyone else look better.
Rodrigo Hernández Cascante—better known as Rodri—walked up to that stage on crutches. It was a poignant image. The Manchester City midfielder, the literal engine of the most dominant club side in the world and the tactical heartbeat of a resurgent Spain, was finally getting his flowers while sporting a torn ACL. He isn't a "YouTube highlights" player. He doesn't do step-overs. He doesn't dye his hair or post lifestyle reels on TikTok. He’s the guy who simply doesn't lose.
Honestly, the 2024 vote felt like a correction for years of defensive midfielders being ignored.
The Math Behind the Rodri Victory
People are still screaming about the robbery. If you look at the raw numbers, you might get why Madrid fans are upset. Vinícius Júnior had a season that was, by all accounts, electrifying. He scored in the Champions League final. He tore through defenses in La Liga. He was the "main character."
But the Ballon d'Or is voted on by 100 journalists from the top 100 FIFA-ranked nations. They look at three things: individual performance, team success, and class/fair play.
Rodri’s 2023-24 season was statistically absurd for a holding midfielder. He went 74 games unbeaten for club and country. Think about that for a second. More than a year of professional football without tasting defeat. He won the Premier League. He won the Club World Cup. Then, he went to Germany and anchored Spain to a perfect Euro 2024 run, winning Player of the Tournament in the process.
📖 Related: NFL Football Teams in Order: Why Most Fans Get the Hierarchy Wrong
While Vini Jr. struggled with a disjointed Brazil at the Copa América, Rodri was the undisputed tactical master of Europe. He had more touches, more successful passes in the final third, and more ball recoveries than almost any other elite "pivot" in the game. He also scored massive goals—like the one against West Ham to help clinch the league title. He wasn't just a "DM." He was the Ballon d'Or 2024 winner because he was the most influential player on the two best teams in the world.
What happened to the Real Madrid boycott?
The drama in Paris was thick. Real Madrid believed that if the criteria didn't favor Vini, it should have gone to Dani Carvajal, who won both the Champions League and the Euros. When they realized the points were trending toward Rodri, they stayed in Spain. It was a PR nightmare.
L'Équipe and France Football maintained that the voting was tighter than usual, but Rodri’s consistency was the tie-breaker. You can't ignore a guy who dictates the tempo of every single match he enters. It’s not just about the goals; it’s about the control.
The "Invisible" Impact of a Modern Pivot
If you watch Rodri, you see a guy who plays like he has a drone view of the pitch. He knows where the pressure is coming from before he even touches the ball. Pep Guardiola has called him the best midfielder in the world for years, and for once, the voters agreed.
Most people get the "defensive midfielder" role wrong. They think it’s about sliding tackles and breaking legs. It’s not. It’s about "La Pausa." It’s the ability to slow the game down when it’s chaotic and speed it up when the defense is sleeping. Rodri finished the season with a pass completion rate north of 92%. In the high-octane environment of the Premier League, that’s basically sorcery.
👉 See also: Why Your 1 Arm Pull Up Progression Isn't Working (And How to Fix It)
- The Euro 2024 Factor: This is likely what tipped the scales. While the Champions League is massive, international tournaments carry huge weight in Ballon d'Or years. Spain's win wasn't a fluke; they played the best football in the tournament, and Rodri was their brain.
- The Manchester City System: Without Rodri, City looks human. We saw it when he was suspended or injured. The win rate drops significantly. That "irreplaceability" factor is exactly what the journalists look for.
Addressing the Vini Jr. Controversy
It's okay to feel bad for Vini. He’s a phenomenal talent and probably the most exciting player to watch in transition. However, his 2023-24 season had lulls. His disciplinary record—while often a result of being targeted by defenders—likely cost him a few points in the "class and fair play" category of the voting criteria.
The Ballon d'Or isn't just the "Best Attacker Award," even though it has felt like that since the Kaká era. By choosing Rodri, the committee sent a message: we see the guys in the shadows. We see the guys who keep the structure together.
The Legacy of the 2024 Vote
Rodri is the first Spaniard to win the award since Luis Suárez (the elder) in 1960. Not Xavi. Not Iniesta. Not Busquets. None of that legendary trio managed to lift the golden ball because they were always in the shadow of Messi and Ronaldo.
In a way, Rodri winning is a win for that entire school of Spanish midfield play. It’s an admission that the sport had been neglecting the very players who make the "Joga Bonito" possible.
The list of the top five was telling:
✨ Don't miss: El Salvador partido de hoy: Why La Selecta is at a Critical Turning Point
- Rodri (Manchester City / Spain)
- Vinícius Júnior (Real Madrid / Brazil)
- Jude Bellingham (Real Madrid / England)
- Dani Carvajal (Real Madrid / Spain)
- Erling Haaland (Manchester City / Norway)
Real Madrid had three players in the top four and still felt slighted. That tells you everything you need to know about the ego involved in modern football. But the record books won't care about the boycott. They will only show that in 2024, the best player in the world was a 6'3" guy from Madrid who plays with his shirt tucked in and doesn't own a Ferrari.
What This Means for Future Betting and Scouting
If you're a scout or a fan looking for the "next big thing," the 2024 result changes the scouting profile. Clubs are going to overpay for "Rodri-clones" now. The value of a press-resistant number 6 has skyrocketed.
For the players, the message is clear: You don't need to score 40 goals to be the best. You need to be the most necessary.
How to evaluate future winners based on the 2024 shift:
- Look at "Expected Threat" (xT): Rodri leads the world in moving the ball into dangerous areas from deep.
- Weight International Trophies Heavily: In a tournament year, the winner almost always comes from the winning side or the MVP of that tournament.
- Check the "Big Game" Stats: Did they perform in the semifinals and finals? Rodri did. Vini did too, but the international failure was the anchor that dragged his candidacy down.
The Ballon d'Or 2024 winner marks the end of the "stats-padding" era and the return of the tactical genius. Whether you love or hate the result, you have to respect the consistency of a man who turned winning into a mundane, weekly habit.
To truly understand Rodri’s impact, stop watching the ball during a match. Watch him. Watch how he directs his teammates with his hands. Watch how he occupies the space that hasn't even become dangerous yet. That is why he has the trophy.
Actionable Insights for Football Fans:
- Re-watch Spain vs. Germany (Euro 2024): If you want to see a masterclass in midfield positioning under pressure, that’s the tape.
- Analyze the "Rodri Drop": Follow Manchester City’s points-per-game stats during his current injury spell. It provides a real-time data set on why he won the award.
- Broaden your "Best" Criteria: Start looking at ball progression and "line-breaking passes" rather than just G/A (Goals and Assists). That is where the modern game is won.